New life
for forsaken rails
JOSEPH KACZMAREK / For the Inquirer
The tracks in Oreland, Montgomery County, are among close to 100 miles of unused railroad rights-of-way in Southeastern Pennsylvania.
Tracks from railroads' past seen as path to future.
Jason Laughlin / Inquirer Staff Writer jlaughlin@phillynews.com
Sunday, August 16, 2015

In a narrow corridor just outside Philadelphia, unused train tracks slowly surrender to rust and rot.

Hidden by trees and underbrush from surrounding starter homes and shops, for 200 yards the rails wend through overgrown grass and wildflowers like the exposed vertebrae of ancient serpents.

The tracks in Oreland, Montgomery County, are among close to 100 miles of unused railroad rights-of-way in Southeastern Pennsylvania, rail experts estimate, two-thirds of them owned by SEPTA.

Unused and Repurposed Rail Lines

MERCER

COUNTY

Lansdale-Doylestown Line

Extend passenger service

along existing freight line

Doylestown

PA.

N.J.

BUCKS

COUNTY

476

Pottstown

Trenton

95

Lansdale

MONTGOMERY

COUNTY

Horsham

Norristown High Speed Line

New track to extend to King of Prussia

422

Levittown

Oreland

Willow

Grove

276

Phoenixville

Norristown

King of Prussia

CHESTER

COUNTY

76

BURLINGTON

COUNTY

IVY

RIDGE

LINE

Media-Elwyn Line

Extension to Wawa

along existing freight line

PHILA.

202

Cherry

Hill

Rail lines by use

West Chester

Camden

Passenger

Freight

Passenger

and freight

Unused

Rail proposals

1

Springfield

Elwyn

Haddonfield

Wawa

DELAWARE

COUNTY

N

Chester

CAMDEN

COUNTY

MILES

DEL.

0

5

Unused and Repurposed Rail Lines

MERCER

COUNTY

Lansdale-Doylestown Line

Extend passenger service

along existing freight line

Doylestown

PA.

N.J.

BUCKS

COUNTY

476

Pottstown

Trenton

95

Lansdale

MONTGOMERY

COUNTY

Horsham

Norristown High Speed Line

New track to extend to King of Prussia

422

Levittown

Oreland

Willow

Grove

276

Phoenixville

Norristown

King of Prussia

CHESTER

COUNTY

76

BURLINGTON

COUNTY

IVY

RIDGE

LINE

Media-Elwyn Line

Extension to Wawa

along existing freight line

PHILA.

202

Cherry

Hill

Rail lines by use

West Chester

Camden

Passenger

Freight

Passenger

and freight

Unused

Rail proposals

1

Springfield

Elwyn

Haddonfield

Wawa

DELAWARE

COUNTY

N

Chester

CAMDEN

COUNTY

MILES

DEL.

0

5

Unused and Repurposed Rail Lines

Rail lines by use

Passenger

Freight

Passenger and freight

Unused

Rail proposals

MERCER

COUNTY

Lansdale-Doylestown Line

Doylestown

PA.

N.J.

BUCKS

COUNTY

476

95

Lansdale

MONTGOMERY

COUNTY

Norristown High Speed Line

422

Oreland

276

CHESTER

COUNTY

76

BURLINGTON

COUNTY

IVY

RIDGE

LINE

Media-Elwyn Line

PHILA.

202

Cherry

Hill

Camden

1

Springfield

Elwyn

Haddonfield

Wawa

DELAWARE

COUNTY

N

Chester

CAMDEN

COUNTY

MILES

DEL.

0

5

Lansdale-Doylestown Line: Extend passenger service along existing freight line
Norristown High Speed Line: New track to extend to King of Prussia
Media-Elwyn Line: Extension to Wawa along existing freight line
SOURCES: SEPTA; Robert P. Thomas
The Philadelphia Inquirer

A century ago, these corridors were the backbone of the region's economy. Now, they are increasingly important answers to transportation problems.

For the first time in more than 30 years, SEPTA is taking steps to reactivate a fallow stretch of rail from Elwyn to Wawa and is considering reopening another line in northern Montgomery County to passenger trains. A resurgent freight rail industry sees its inactive tracks as valuable investments. Meanwhile, trail builders are using these forsaken assets to create a cyclist and pedestrian network that is among the most ambitious in the country.

JOSEPH KACZMAREK / For the Inquirer
Runners on the Pennypack Trail in Abington, where a railroad used to run.

At the end of the 19th century, Pennsylvania had one of the nation's most active rail networks.

"Unless you had cars or you wanted to travel really slow with your horse and wagon, trains were it," said James Innes, a Cheltenham resident and rail enthusiast who has been active in developing rail routes into trails.

JOSEPH KACZMAREK / For the Inquirer

The railroad companies were aggressive competitors, said Robert Thomas, a Philadelphia architect who culls old maps and deeds for rail routes that can be used as trails.

“Whenever you have development, there's a fever.”
Robert Thomas, a Philadelphia architect

"Whenever you have development, there's a fever," he said.

Railroad companies courted customers by building lines near each other. The Manayunk Bridge, once part of the Pennsylvania Railroad system, carried tracks that were almost parallel to those of the Norristown line, which once belonged to the competing Reading Railroad.

Redundancy hurt the industry. In the 1920s, an increase in paved roads made trucks a viable shipping option, Thomas said. The Eisenhower administration invested in highways in the 1950s, boosting American car culture.

JOSEPH KACZMAREK / For the Inquirer
James Innes points out an unused section of railroad tracks in Oreland.

Rail service in this region took a blow as late as the 1980s. The Center City commuter tunnel linked for the first time the old Pennsylvania and Reading railroads, Thomas said — but the diesel engines that serviced parts of Montgomery, Bucks, Berks, and Schuylkill Counties couldn't run through tunnels due to their toxic exhaust. Those areas lost train service.

At the height of rail service in 1920, companies operated 11,500 rail miles in the Keystone State, according to American-Rails.com. Now there are about 5,000 miles.

Railroads in Pennsylvania
1846: Pennsylvania Railroad is chartered to build a line from Harrisburg to Pittsburgh to Erie.
By 1900: Pennsylvania Railroad has one of the nation's most active rail networks with services across the country.
1920s: Paved roads become more common.
1924: Reading Company Railroad separates from its subsidary, The Philadelphia & Reading Coal and Iron Co. Having multiple railroads servicing the same region and competing with each other hurts the railroad industry.
1950s: Baltimore and Ohio Railroad concedes its Philadelphia and New York City markets to the wealthier Pennsylvania Railroad and New York Central Railroads.
1956: The Eisenhower administration invests heavily in the Interstate System, promoting the American car culture and hurting the railroad industry.
1960s and 70s: Nearly every major railroad line in Pennsylvania goes bankrupt.
1995: SEPTA purchases the right-of-way to 1.6 miles of the City Branch in Philadelphia for $8.5 million.
SOURCES: The Pennsylvania Railroad, U.S. Department of Transportation, Reading Company Technical & Historical Society, Explore Pa. History, American-Rails

The tracks in Oreland have not been active since the 1950s, Innes said. They were once busy with trains hauling limestone from nearby quarries that have since closed.

Reactivating an unused line usually requires replacing the old tracks, if any are still left — it's the land, not the hardware, that's valuable. Rail rights of way are fiercely held by SEPTA and commercial rail companies because getting land for rail expansion is expensive and difficult. SEPTA's last major right-of-way purchase, 1.6 miles of the City Branch in Philadelphia, cost $8.5 million in 1995.

The benefit of keeping rights of way is evident in a comparison of two active projects. SEPTA estimates that a 3.4-mile expansion of the West Chester Line along a right of way it owns from Elwyn to Wawa would cost $80 million to $100 million. A five-mile extension of the Norristown High Speed Line to King of Prussia, which will require the acquisition of a new right of way, is expected to cost $650 million.

SEPTA also is studying putting passenger trains on a part of the Bethlehem branch in Montgomery County now used only by freight trains.

JOSEPH KACZMAREK / For the Inquirer

The possibility of inactive rights of way bearing passenger trains again is growing as train travel becomes more popular. SEPTA reported 37.4 million trips in fiscal year 2015, a 2 percent increase over the previous year.

Some of the region's rail routes get reborn for other uses. Utilities like PECO buy rail rights of way and install power lines along them. The region's bicycle trail system is largely built on paths cleared for trains. A Delaware Valley Regional Planning Commission study of traffic on bike trails found 1.4 million bicycles used the area's five biggest trails in the last year.

Groups such as Rails-to-Trails Conservancy and the Bicycle Coalition of Greater Philadelphia are building a regional 750-mile trail circuit. Of the 300 miles finished, 75 percent was once railroad, said Tom Sexton, director of Rails-to-Trails Northeast Regional Office.

"It's the most well-planned-out build-out of a metro multiuse trail in America," he said.

JOSEPH KACZMAREK / For the Inquirer
James Innes approaches a former railroad trestle, now used as a pedestrian bridge in the Wissahickon Valley Park in Flourtown.

Planners also are creating paths alongside active train routes, Sexton said. Bicycle trails paralleling rail routes get people to stations without clogging roads or parking lots, Sexton said, and SEPTA supports trail conversions. SEPTA leases the land for trails and can reclaim it for rail if needed.

“We would prefer that someone is using it. Preservation of it is in everyone’s best interest.”
Byron Comati,
SEPTA's director of strategic planning

"We would prefer that someone is using it," said Byron Comati, SEPTA's director of strategic planning, adding that "preservation of it is in everyone's best interest."

Obtaining rights of way not controlled by SEPTA can get challenging, Thomas said. Short railroads, particularly, can have a convoluted trail of ownership. And there are some inactive tracks that are not available to trail builders. Commercial railroad companies are experiencing a renaissance, said Dave Pidgeon, spokesman for Norfolk Southern, one of the big freight carriers in the Northeast. Their business model depends on being able to serve customers quickly by offering rail service when demand arises, such as when a new factory opens.

"That's why in today's climate we, generally speaking, want to hold on to the lines that we have as much as possible," Pidgeon said.

After visiting the unused tracks in Oreland, Innes, the rail enthusiast, went to a welcoming, sylvan path in Springfield built on an old railroad bridge. An avid biker, he said that riding on an old rail route is a way to touch history.

"You become fascinated," he said, "with what was here before."

jlaughlin@phillynews.com 610-313-8114 @jasmlaughlin

JOSEPH KACZMAREK / For the Inquirer
A runner passes flowers along the Pennypack Trail in Abington, where a railroad used to run.