Mank, a years-in-the-making passion project of David Fincher based on a script by his father, Jack, is a movie made for critics, cinephiles, and deep-dive film historians.
A whirligig retelling of how Herman Mankiewicz came to write the groundbreaking 1941 film Citizen Kane, filmed in velvety black-and-white and studded with fetishistic details of Hollywood’s Golden Age at its most silky and coyly subversive, Mank is designed to send its intended audience aloft on a cloud of nostalgia, albeit with pangs of remorse for what we’ve lost.
Which makes the film’s disappointments all the more painful, and confounding.
On paper, Mank promises equal measures of penetrating insight and pure delight: In the 1920s and 1930s, Mankiewicz — played to perfection by Gary Oldman was a successful, if self-destructive, screenwriter in Hollywood, beckoning former Algonquin Round Tablers from the East Coast with promises of sun, fun, and easy money. (“Millions are to be grabbed out here, and your only competition is idiots,” he famously telegrammed Ben Hecht.)
When the film opens, it’s 1940, when a radio wunderkind named Orson Welles has received carte blanche to make whatever movie he wants and hires Mank, as he’s known, to create a script.
In homage to Citizen Kane, Jack Fincher wrote Mank in the same nonlinear, elliptical style, bouncing from the bed where Mank writes his first draft while recovering from a car accident, back to when he befriends the powerful publisher William Randolph Hearst (Charles Dance) and Hearst’s much younger companion, Marion Davies (Amanda Seyfried).
We get scenes of Mank’s writers’ room at Paramount, with name-droppy appearances by Charles Lederer, Charles MacArthur, and S.J. Perelman. There’s a wonderful sequence featuring Louis B. Mayer (Arliss Howard) walking through the corridors of MGM before demanding a pay cut from his employees, and equally scrumptious set pieces at Hearst’s estate San Simeon.
Through it all, Mank keeps up a steady patter of arch commentary, delivering punny witticisms with the practiced sarcasm of the resolutely un-star-struck. That is, when he isn’t stumbling and mumbling in a drunken shambles: Although one could argue that as high-functioning an alcoholic as Mankiewicz must have been able to hold his liquor, Oldman and Fincher have chosen to portray his binges with W.C. Fields-like excess.
One of the most revolutionary things about Citizen Kane was cinematographer Gregg Toland’s use of light, shadow, and deep focus. Here, Erik Messerschmidt does his version with crisp, meticulously staged images that he inexplicably blows out with distractingly bright backlights.
Like Quentin Tarantino’s Once Upon a Time in Hollywood, Fincher’s enterprise luxuriates in the signifiers of the era, whether in the form of fake cigarette burns once used to cue reel changes or “process” shots of cars moving in front of an obviously ersatz background.
It must have been a ball to do. But it’s questionable whether any of the fuss will appeal to anyone but the most dedicated Citizen Kane fans.
Even with Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross’s propulsive piano-and-drum score, the movie often feels too talky and tendentious by half: This isn’t inside-baseball as much as the foam core under the last layer of the inside of the baseball.
Mank gleefully examines the disreputable underside of old-school Hollywood and its minions. But it’s weighed down by windy expository passages that stop the film in its tracks, whether they’re introducing once-famous figures or explaining the California gubernatorial race in which Hearst and Mayer collaborated to defeat the socialist author Upton Sinclair.
It was Mank’s outrage over that collusion that inspired him to go after Hearst in Citizen Kane. But that also meant he had to betray Davies, with whom he develops a touching friendship over the course of the film.
Mank’s best scenes belong to Seyfried, who gives her character warmth, life, intelligence, and humor: She’s a figure of stunning, ethereal beauty, often looking as though she’s lit from within. But she’s also supremely self-aware, and probably smarter than any of the men posing and posturing around her. Seyfried’s the beating heart of a movie that is constantly teetering on the edge of pastiche, feeling more playacted than fully inhabited.
Mank ** 1/2 (out of four)
Directed by: David Fincher, with Gary Oldman, Amanda Seyfried, Lily Collins.
Playing at: Water Tower Cinema, Lansdale, and available starting Friday on Netflix.
Run time: 2 hours, 12 min.