C.J. Gardner-Johnson and Eagles defense want to ‘toe the line’ but not cross it after Commanders matchup boils over

C.J. Gardner-Johnson doesn’t overcomplicate things.

The Eagles safety’s balancing act of maintaining the fiery personality that drives him on the football field without overstepping the boundaries laid out by NFL officials may seem difficult from an outsider’s perspective, but Gardner-Johnson deduced it to a succinct few words when asked about it on Friday.

“You keep popping [stuff],” he said. “You just don’t get caught.”

A few days after getting ejected from the Eagles’ loss to the Washington Commanders last Sunday, Gardner-Johnson’s apparent quandary and concise conclusion can be applied to an Eagles defense once again preparing for a division rivalry this Sunday against the Dallas Cowboys.

» READ MORE: Eagles announce Jalen Hurts will miss Sunday’s game vs. Cowboys with a concussion

Several players said Eagles coach Nick Sirianni addressed the need to avoid crossing the line after the defense had three personal fouls in last Sunday’s 36-33 loss to the Commanders. The day after the game, Sirianni told reporters something similar.

“There is a reason we have an edge on defense,” Sirianni said. “We have really good players who play with great passion and great fire. That’s huge. We just always have got to understand and know to do it within the confines of the rules.”

Friday marked the first time Gardner-Johnson spoke to reporters since he was tossed in the third quarter of the loss. The 27-year-old was charged with two unsportsmanlike conduct penalties, the second of which was for “taunting,” according to NFL official Shawn Smith in a pool report after the game.

When asked about the two penalties, Gardner-Johnson conceded that he needed to do a better job staying levelheaded despite the heated nature of division rivalry games.

“To be honest with you, in rivalry games, intensity is always high,” Gardner-Johnson said. “So I kind of expected things to be up, so I just have to do better as a football player and control my emotions. That’s all.”

Gardner-Johnson, who has a well-earned reputation for trash talking over his six-year career, also said his conversations with Sirianni this week have focused on preserving his individuality with added emphasis on playing within the rules.

“I don’t have any limitations,” Gardner-Johnson said. “I don’t think I’m limited here. I think Nick does a great job of letting me be myself, but as a football player, I have to make sure to toe the line and [when to] stay behind the line and not cross it. That’s all Coach would tell me.”

» READ MORE: If the Eagles lose against the Cowboys, blame the kelly green jerseys

It’s possible that line has moved for Gardner-Johnson and the Eagles defense, though.

The group, which ranked first in yards allowed and fifth in points allowed entering Week 17, has become known for its physicality and playing with an edge this season. Gardner-Johnson and defensive tackle Jalen Carter have served as tone-setters at various points of the year with their play but were flagged for personal fouls against Washington.

It’s also worth noting that the Week 15 matchup against Pittsburgh featured a brief scuffle after Steelers tight end Darnell Washington tried blocking veteran cornerback Darius Slay through the end zone and into the stands.

Gardner-Johnson wouldn’t say whether the defense’s intense reputation is starting to precede it with referees but said it wouldn’t change going forward either way.

“That question I’m not answering because at the end of the day, the intensity of the defense is showing in numbers,” Gardner-Johnson said. “We’re just going to keep playing week in and week out.”

Sunday will be the next test. Although the Cowboys have been eliminated from the playoffs, they’ve won four of their last five games and come to the Linc with a chance to play spoiler to the Eagles’ pursuit of clinching the NFC East.

With that in mind, Carter said he’s expecting another gritty game for the Eagles despite the disparity between their 12-3 record and the Cowboys’ 7-8.

“They’ve got a different mindset right now,” Carter said. “Not to speak on the playoffs, but we know they’re not in the playoffs, so it’s a different mindset. This will probably be a playoff game in their mind. I know they’re going to come out and try to be more physical than us and play more as a team than us. That’s just something we have to do better than them.”

» READ MORE: Kenny Pickett and the Eagles receivers are feeling ‘more comfortable’ after a week of reps together

So how will the group manage opponents trying to challenge their physicality without the penalties?

“Just don’t let it happen,” Carter said. “That’s pretty much it. We’re grown; we’re not little kids. You don’t have to repeat things 20 times. The first time you hear it, you adjust.”

Gardner-Johnson added: “The message is it is all about us. We control what we can control, and ball is the main objective and topic. All the extra stuff is not needed. We just have to focus on ball and play within ourselves.”

The Eagles play in Week 17 against the Dallas Cowboys. Join Eagles beat reporters Olivia Reiner and EJ Smith as they dissect the hottest storylines surrounding the team on Gameday Central, live from Lincoln Financial Field.