Kyle Schwarber falls in Home Run Derby heartbreaker, Cardinals’ Jordan Walker wins in bonus time
Schwarber mashed 11 home runs in the final round but fell just short against a clutch Walker.
Kyle Schwarber had been here before.
Leading in the final round of the Home Run Derby. His opponent down to one last swing. On the precipice of lifting his tired arms once more to hoist a trophy.
In 2018, it was Bryce Harper who smashed nine home runs in a row in an all-time Derby flourish to vanquish his future Phillies teammate.
So, guess what Schwarber was thinking about Monday night when the Cardinals’ Jordan Walker cut through the boos in sold-out Citizens Bank Park with back-to-back-to-back ... to-back homers to walk off the hometown star, 12-11, in a cruel twist to a pulsating Derby final.
» READ MORE: What makes Bryce Harper and Kyle Schwarber such unique stars? We asked each about the other.
“Oh, trust me,” Schwarber said, “yeah, it was definitely popping in your head. Seeing Bryce do what he did in ‘18, and then, obviously what [Walker] was able to do, the run he just had, it’s impressive. I mean, you tip your cap, right?”
What else was there to do?
Schwarber went deep 10 times in 20 swings to survive the first round, unlike Harper, who hit only eight after making a climb-the-ropes, WWE-style entrance upon being introduced by famed 81-year-old ring announcer (and Philadelphian) Michael Buffer. But we’ll come back to that.
In the semifinals, Schwarber edged Willson Contreras, 9-8, with help from a partisan crowd that booed the Red Sox slugger each time he hit a ball over the fence and roared for every non-homer.
It set up a showdown with Walker, a 24-year-old former top prospect who has 22 homers for the Cardinals, five fewer than in his first three major league seasons combined.
Schwarber went first and hit 11 balls out on 15 swings, all to the familiar right-field bleachers that he reaches so often during the season with his short left-handed stroke. With Phillies assistant hitting coach Rafael Peña throwing to him, he hit six homers on his first nine swings.
And when he needed a breather, Schwarber stepped out and urged on the 43,863 paying customers.
“I thought Kyle had it,” Harper said.
» READ MORE: ‘The game is where it needs to be’: Bryce Harper wants compromise (and no salary cap) to keep sport thriving
Of all people, Harper should’ve known better.
After 19 swings, Walker trailed 11-8. But the righty-swinging outfielder began peppering the left-field bleachers in bonus time — a 407-footer off the top of the wall here, a 413-foot laser there, a 450-foot missile to tie it up.
“The big one was that one where the ball hits the top of the wall there and snuck over,” Schwarber said. “I was like, oh, that one’s not good for us.”
Walker clinched it with one more mighty swing, shades of Harper in ‘18 and Schwarber in Atlanta last year, when he banged three homers on three swings in the first-ever swing off to decide an All-Star Game that was tied after nine innings.
“That’s a pretty special thing that he was able to do,” Schwarber said, “to lock it in there for those swings and to get them over.”
Indeed, it was one swing from being one of the more memorable nights for the Phillies in their 22-year-old ballpark, which is hosting its first All-Star Game.
Buffer started the show by bellowing his catchphrase — “Let’s get ready to rumble!” — and introducing the Derby contestants, who met in a wrestling ring behind second base.
Harper took it from there.
The last player announced, “The Showman,” as he’s called by teammates, raised both arms to salute the crowd. Upon reaching the ring, he climbed up, shook the ropes, and shouted, “Let’s go!”
What can he say? He got caught up in the moment.
“I mean, Buff’s incredible,” Harper said. “He’s so Vegas, right? Being from Vegas, born and raised, they do a lot of fights out there. That’s a guy that I’ve seen a lot on TV. It was insane to see him announcing our names and to announce my name, as well.”
And climbing the ropes?
“I’ve always wanted to do that, too,” Harper said. “Watching wrestling growing up, Sting was one of my favorites. I liked Goldberg, too. I felt like Kevin Nash in that situation, a little bit of nWo. But that was pretty cool.”
» READ MORE: Mike Trout said he loves Philly during Monday’s All-Star festivities. But he seems no closer to playing here.
Harper was the last player to hit, roughly one hour after the Derby began. He enlisted Dodgers third base coach Dino Ebel to throw to him and appeared to get into a groove late in the first round, with six homers in the span of 11 swings.
On his fourth homer, Harper crushed a ball that seemed to disappear beyond the second deck before touching down on Ashburn Alley, estimated at 482 feet. He hit another homer over the batter’s eye in center field.
“I’ve done that in a game, though,” Harper said. “I hit one, what, 480 or something like that to right-center? So, that one felt pretty good. I just wanted to go out there and have some fun and enjoy the best I can.”
Beyond that, Harper was a spectator. And he plans to only watch the Derby from now on. After being nudged into his third career Derby, the 33-year-old said he won’t compete in another.
“Yeah, I’m done,” he said. “I mean, it took a lot for me to do it this time. Once you get out there, obviously your adrenaline’s going and stuff. You want to have a chance to win it. But, yeah, I’m done. I’m going to hang it up from the Home Run Derby.”
Schwarber was reminded that next year’s All-Star Game will be held at Wrigley Field, where he began his career with the Cubs. He couldn’t possibly be a three-time runner-up, could he?
“Oh man, you’ve got to give me another year to think about that,” Schwarber said. “I’m just thinking about trying to make it home tonight and having a beer. But we’ll see what happens moving forward.”
With one month left in the season, the Phillies are jockeying for playoff positioning in the National League. And things are about to heat up with a critical three-game series in Arizona. Diamondbacks general manager Mike Hazen joins Phillies Extra to discuss the wild-card race, the drama involving star second baseman Ketel Marte, and the 2023 NLCS, which left scars in Philadelphia that still haven't healed. Watch here.
You can also subscribe to the podcast version of Phillies Extra on Spotify or Apple Podcasts.
Previous episodes: Tony Gwynn Jr. | Kevin Stocker | Bobby Dickerson | Jim Bowden | John Middleton | Ryan Howard | Dan Baker | Ricky Bottalico | Preston Mattingly | Caleb Cotham
