Let’s get this out of the way: Manny Machado won’t sign with the Phillies because they hired his longtime coach or the Chicago White Sox because they filled their lineup with his brother-in-law and one of his best friends.
Machado almost certainly will go where he can make the most money, just like most other marquee free agents.
But if you’re serious about investing upwards of $250 million in one player for the next 8-10 years, it only makes sense to surround him with the best possible support system, especially when that player is as exceedingly gifted yet frequently enigmatic as Machado. So when the Phillies had an unexpected opening last month for a major-league infield coach, Bobby Dickerson rose to the top of their short list before getting the job late Thursday night, according to multiple sources.
Dickerson, 53, knows Machado as well as almost anyone in professional baseball. They met when Machado was 16. As an instructor with the Baltimore Orioles, Dickerson played a central role in turning Machado from a natural shortstop into a two-time Gold Glove third baseman. Over the years, they have had long talks about the All-Star that Machado is and the future Hall of Famer that he can be.
More important, Dickerson knows what makes Machado tick. By all accounts, Machado trusts Dickerson, who learned how to extract the most from a superstar who admittedly doesn’t always play the game at full speed and spawned an even larger group of critics in October when he confessed to not being “Johnny Hustle.”
Case in point: Midway through the 2012 season, with the Orioles trying to improve their defense at third base, many team officials believed Machado could make an easy transition to the position. Problem was, he grew up idolizing Alex Rodriguez and would need to be talked into moving away from shortstop. Dickerson, then a minor-league instructor, had an idea. He would tell Machado that he couldn't do it.
“I’d say, ‘Manny, why don’t you come out here and do some work at third base today? I bet you can’t hang. This is a real man’s position,’” Dickerson recalled last month in an interview with Philly.com. “Things like that, little subtle challenges. I’ve always tried to be a father figure.”
It’s worth mentioning, at this point, that Dickerson is also a darned good infield coach. He gets credit for nurturing second baseman Jonathan Schoop in Baltimore, and with Schoop, shortstop J.J. Hardy and Machado, the Orioles had perhaps the best infield defense in the majors when they won the American League East crown in 2014.
The Phillies were baseball’s worst defensive team last season. They struggled with infield shifts, a problem amplified by right-hander Jake Arrieta’s critical comments in early June. And when infield coach Jose David Flores left last month to join the Orioles' staff under new manager Brandon Hyde, it created an opportunity for the Phillies to bring in a replacement to spur improvement.
Dickerson’s usefulness, then, goes beyond merely being the Machado Whisperer. But if Machado does wind up choosing the Phillies over the aggressive White Sox or a proverbial “mystery team” that unexpectedly emerges (the New York Yankees seem to be heading in another direction after Friday’s signing of infielder DJ LeMahieu), Dickerson’s presence should help allay concerns that exist within the walls of Citizens Bank Park about Machado’s occasionally wavering effort level.
"I'll say this: When Manny puts his mind to something, it's just unbelievable to watch. He's that talented," Dickerson said. "In 2013, he was the best defensive player I've ever seen in my life. If he's locked in, he can change the game with his glove. For sure, I've seen it. The challenge is his locked-in-ness, and that's well-documented.
"What I do respect about Manny is that he owned it. He's not going to be 'Johnny Hustle.' [But] he's going to play 162 games, and when he grounds out, he's going to run three-quarters to first base. OK, that's what you're buying. And you're buying the 40 doubles and the 40 homers."
And it only helps to have someone around who understands how best to tolerate the former while maximizing the latter.