Skip to content
Link copied to clipboard

Sam Donnellon | Why no DH on the ballot?


DH David Ortiz is listed as first baseman on All-Star ballot.
DH David Ortiz is listed as first baseman on All-Star ballot.Read more

OAKLAND'S MIKE Piazza might not get to cross the Bay Bridge for this year's All-Star Game in San Francisco.

Not because of a bad season or even a recent collision with Boston's Mike Lowell that landed him on the disabled list. Piazza might not go because he is listed as Oakland's designated hitter and thus not included on this year's All-Star ballot.

Frank Thomas, who hit 39 home runs and drove in 114 runs in Piazza's role for the A's last season, is now the Blue Jays' designated hitter. He's not on the ballot either. Neither is Jim Thome, who is hitting .340 and hit 42 home runs for the White Sox last season.

At a time when baseball would like to distract us from Barry Bonds and his pursuit of Henry Aaron's home run record, baseball's 4-decade-long rules war (DH or no DH?) will likely make July's All-Star Game as intriguing for who is not there as much as for who is there.

Why? Because San Francisco is a National League city, and the National League does not play with a designated hitter. The combination of a players vote and the preference of American League manager Jim Leyland may add one or two to the roster, but not all of the above will be going.

Thome can and has played first base for the Sox, but teams are allowed to list only one player at each infield position, and only three outfielders. Paul Konerko, the Sox regular first baseman, is on the ballot.

The Detroit Tigers may have signed Gary Sheffield to be their designated hitter in the offseason, but by listing him as a third outfielder, they bounced their everyday centerfielder and leadoff man Curtis Granderson from the ballot.

Sheffield said recently he didn't know that Granderson wasn't on the ballot, and that he felt bad about it. But I can't shake this sneaky feeling that an All-Star appearance was somehow worked into the 2-year renegotiation of his contract upon arrival in Detroit.

That's a whole other issue about the Midsummer Classic now: Who stands to make money by a ballot inclusion, and who loses out.

More significantly, though, is that Sheffield, who is hitting .218, will siphon votes from stars who actually play in the outfield. Torii Hunter, who plays for small-market Minnesota (and thus has fewer hometown voters), is batting .345.

Listed as a first baseman instead of Sox regular first baseman Kevin Youkilis, Boston DH David Ortiz is likely to make his All-Star team, but clearly at the expense of someone who actually plays the position. In fact, the American League ballot for first basemen is chock full of pretenders and fibbers: New York's Jason Giambi, Cleveland's Travis Hafner, and Detroit's Sean Casey are all disguised designated hitters.

It all seems so unnecessary and counter to what the event is supposed to be about - all-stars. Some hard-core National League fans would probably argue that fair is fair, and with homefield in the World Series determined by the result of this game, the National League should be able to play by its rules every other year.

But here's a quick point: It is the third summer in the last four that the game is being held in a National League park. And the truth is, pitchers are routinely pinch-hit for in All-Star games, and often with sluggers.

You could make the case that because they must spend lavishly for the designated hitter, the American League has more quantity, if not quality, when it comes to sluggers. But again, should an All-Star Game emphasize equity over excellence? And even if one concedes a teeny advantage for the American League with the inclusion of the DH, does it justify the potential exclusion of some of the game's stars - not to mention more recognizable and popular names like Thome and Piazza?

There's never been an All-Star Game no-hitter and, Lord willing, there never will be.

So why play any of these games under National League rules? I mean, I love the double-switch as much as the next guy. But in an All-Star Game?

I'd rather watch Barry Bonds walk.


Send e-mail to For recent columns, go to