One for the ladies
Kathryn Bigelow is well positioned to become the first female Oscar winner for directing. Take that, "Avatar."
Kathryn Bigelow made history Saturday when the director of The Hurt Locker, a tale of risk junkies defusing improvised explosive devices in Iraq, became the first woman to receive top honors from the Directors Guild of America (DGA).
Prospects are good that she'll make history once again on March 7 at the Oscars. In a battle-of-the-exes twist, Bigelow could take the prize over former spouse James Cameron, whose Avatar is the top-grossing movie of all time.
She's a lock for an Academy Award nomination (which will be announced this morning). Because it's so rare that the DGA winner doesn't go on to win an Academy Award - only six times in 61 years - odds are Bigelow could be the first woman director in the Academy's 82-year history to crash the celluloid ceiling. It's a feat that the three prior nominees - Lina Wertmuller (Seven Beauties), Jane Campion (The Piano), and Sofia Coppola (Lost in Translation) - failed to accomplish.
"This is Sally Ride, first woman in space big," declared Melissa Silverstein on her Women & Hollywood blog on Sunday (http://womenandhollywood.com). "This is Sandra Day O'Connor, first female on the Supreme Court big. This is Billie Jean King beating Bobby Riggs big."
OK, definitely a watershed moment. But I'm skeptical that Bigelow's probable nomination and possible win will represent any substantive change for women in Hollywood. When Hattie McDaniel became the first African American to win an Oscar (for 1939's Gone With the Wind), it did not immediately open the door for other black actors. After Wertmuller became the first female director nominated, 17 years passed before Campion became the second.
Yes, Bigelow's movie about how warriors get addicted to the rush of war is truly great. But 2009 was by most measures only a good year for women filmmakers, who are consigned mostly to romantic comedies and biopics.
According to Martha Lauzen, a communications professor at San Diego State, the percentage of movies directed by women was 9 percent in 2008. By my math, 17 of the top 250 box-office movies in 2009 were directed by women, a jot under 7 percent.
Since 1998 the number of women filmmakers has held between 7 percent and 10 percent, said Lauzen, who for nearly 20 years has tracked employment of women in the film industry.
"We have to celebrate Bigelow's achievement," said Jeanine Basinger, professor of film history at Wesleyan University.
"If Bigelow wins, it's a breakthrough," she said. "Still, as a film historian, when I contemplate the minuscule numbers of women directors today as compared to the more equal numbers of women and men during the silent era, I am always surprised.
"There used to be no gender bias in filmmaking, nor was there the gender specificity we see today," she said.
What Basinger refers to is that, notwithstanding The Hurt Locker, most of the films from women in 2009 are romantic comedies (see Anne Fletcher's The Proposal or Nancy Meyers' It's Complicated) or biopics about founding mothers of 20th-century culture (Anne Fontaine's Coco Before Chanel and Mira Nair's Amelia, about aviatrix Amelia Earhart).
Unless you're Woody Allen, rom-coms aren't taken seriously by the Academy. And unless you're a foreigner - like Dutch director Marleen Gorris, who won best foreign film in 1995 for Antonia's Line, or German filmmaker Caroline Link, who won the foreign prize in 2002 for Nowhere in Africa - the Academy doesn't honor biopics seen from a female perspective. Gandhi is Oscar-worthy, not Coco.
The cause lies not in women's lack of talent, but in the Academy's general bias against movies about the female experience. Bigelow, who specializes in genre movies about men addicted to danger (see Point Break), is more in the Academy's traditional mold.
As Basinger said, the greatest thing about a prospective Bigelow win would be "that it says that a good film is not defined by the gender of the filmmaker."
Female Directors, 2009
Here are the top-grossing movies in North America last year from women directors.
Alvin and the Chipmunks: The Squeakquel
Betty Thomas $209 million Rank: 9
The Proposal
Anne Fletcher $163 million Rank: 16
It's Complicated
Nancy Meyers $104 million Rank: 31
Julie & Julia
Nora Ephron $94 million Rank: 34
Jennifer's Body
Karyn Kusama $16 million Rank: 116
Amelia
Mira Nair $14 million Rank: 126
Whip It
Drew Barrymore $13 million Rank: 129
The Hurt Locker
Kathryn Bigelow $13 million Rank: 130
Sunshine Cleaning
Christine Jeffs $12 million Rank: 132
An Education
Lone Scherfig $9 million Rank: 144
Post Grad
Vicky Jenson $6 million Rank: 152
Coco Before Chanel
Anne Fontaine $6 million Rank: 154
Bright Star
Jane Campion $4 million Rank: 161
Yoo-Hoo, Mrs. Goldberg
Aviva Kempner $1 million Rank: 193
Amreeka
Cherien Dabis $621,000 Rank: 225
The Girl From Monaco
Anne Fontaine $602,000 Rank: 227
Humpday
Lynn Shelton $407,000 Rank: 243
Source: Box Office Mojo. EndText
Read about this morning's nominations for the Academy Awards at www.philly.com.
EndText