Reader reviewers rate Shatner sitcom

For the 16th year in a row, the Daily News screened some of the fall TV pilots for winners of our Everybody's a Critic contest.

This year's panel, which met last week for sandwiches, cookies and conversation, included: Pam Galowich, of Queen Village; Darnell Elizabeth Grayson, of Northeast Philadelphia; Bill Hollis, of South Philadelphia; Liz Kinky, of Maple Shade, N.J.; Mario Machi, of Bala Cynwyd; Laurie McCourt, of Somerton; Ellen Neubaur, of Modena Park; Damon Oliver, of West Chester; Anthony Tann Jr., of West Philadelphia; Charlotte White, of North Philadelphia; Howard White, of North Philadelphia; and Carol Wright, of North Philadelphia.

You'll be seeing their takes on some of the new shows, along with mine, all week.

Here's what some of our Reader Reviewers had to say about CBS' William Shatner sitcom "$#*! My Dad Says," which averaged a 6.3 on a scale of 1 to 10, with individual scores ranging from 2 all the way to 10:

BILL HOLLIS

Score: 8

"It's good to see the writers have continued to allow Shat's character to be so self-deprecating - gotta love how I'm thinking of my own dad right now."

CHARLOTTE WHITE

Score: 2

"I thought they were trying just a little too hard to be funny."

MARIO MACHI

Score: 3

"William Shatner was the lone bright spot. I followed the Twitter feed [the show is based on] for a while, but I stopped because the jokes were redundant. I feel the TV show will have the same problem . . . I had a root canal today and I enjoyed it more than this show."

ELLEN NEUBAUR

Score: 8

"When I saw William Shatner, I had doubts . . . but I was surprised once I saw this show. It was funny in a normal family-type atmosphere."