How Rachel Carson, Jane Jacobs, Jane Goodall, and Alice Waters Changed Our World
By Andrea Barnet
Ecco. 514 pp. $29.99
Reviewed by Joanna Scutts
They were single and married, mothers and not, educated and self-taught, financially comfortable and struggling. Their work spans the second half of the 20th century and continues into the present. They did not know one another.
In Visionary Women, her lively new biography of Rachel Carson, Jane Jacobs, Jane Goodall, and Alice Waters, Andrea Barnet makes a compelling case that these four women "changed our world." As she shows, their impact is nothing short of revolutionary.
Visionary Women links her subjects chronologically, with an emphasis on the 1960s. It was then that the women became, collectively, "a kind of true north for the gathering counterculture." They were Davids aiming slingshots at the Goliath of postwar America, which was waging an all-out "war on nature" with wrecking balls and toxic pesticides, paving paradise to put up a vast suburban parking lot.
In Silent Spring (1962), Carson shocked the nation by laying bare the enormous environmental cost of technological progress. Jacobs, in turn, was fighting to keep another fragile and beautiful ecosystem — her New York City neighborhood — from being flattened by the highways whisking white families to the suburbs. Meanwhile, Goodall camped for months in the jungles of Tanzania to bring back reports of the intelligence and sociability of chimpanzees, which upended the scientific establishment's assumption of human supremacy. Finally, Waters, more product than driver of the counterculture, built a restaurant and a worldwide reputation on the idea that the best meals were created in a respectful symbiosis among environment, farmer, chef, and diner.
Barnet is careful not to rely on too-easy assumptions about gender. When she describes Carson's style of fostering connection rather than competing with her peers as "female," the word is set off in scare quotes. Her subjects' femaleness mattered most, unsurprisingly, to men: It was what they saw first and what some of them could not see past. Over and over Goodall fended off the sexual advances of her much older mentor. Carson was dismissed by her critics as a cat-loving spinster, and Jacobs as a "sentimental Hausfrau." Jacobs embraced her maternal identity, deploying local children — her "little elves" — to knock on doors, gather signatures, and draw the attention of the press. It was a way of forcing into the foreground the future that her opponents refused to acknowledge.
When Barnet writes of the complacent world into which Carson's Silent Spring would erupt, "People looked inward to home and family, diverted themselves with easy pleasures, and turned a blind eye to social and racial injustices," she means white people — those who, like her subjects, were the intended beneficiaries of the vast postwar technological and consumer boom. Barnet acknowledges that the cliché of the suburban American Dream was based on segregation and exclusion. She observes that Jacobs testified to a Senate subcommittee in 1962 about endemic racism at the Federal Housing Authority and that her ideas about the failures of housing projects influenced James Baldwin, yet we don't hear voices from communities of color — the main targets of urban-renewal policies. Likewise, if there has truly been a "paradigm shift" in the way Americans value the natural world since Carson's book was published, it needs to extend to an understanding of the central role of race in environmental catastrophes like the Flint, Mich., water crisis.
Still, Barnet makes a powerful case for a shared perspective among her subjects, likening Carson's understanding of the sea to Jacobs' view of the city as "a balance of live and ever-evolving forces, a fluid network of exchanges, as much a process as a place." Goodall recorded everything about her chimpanzees in capacious detail, without hierarchy or categorization, looking "with a kind of blinkered intensity, drawing upon all her senses." Waters, a young student in France, recalled lavishing a similar attention on "what the fruit bowl looked like, how the cheese was presented, how it was put on the shelves, how the baguettes twisted. The shapes, the colors, the styles."
All four women learned by immersing themselves in their environment and letting their eyes lead the way. Of the many lessons they have to teach us, this may be the most potent of all: Pay attention.