Skip to content

4 Coatesville area youths killed in car crash

Four Coatesville Area School District students were killed early Sunday morning when their car flipped and slid up an embankment near a challenging stretch of two-lane road in West Brandywine Township.

Tyler Wales hugs Brittany Alison (back showing) on Sunday after Alison, Kelsey Brinton (left) and Mandi Geckle (right) brought balloons and signs to a memorial. Four of their classmates died there in a crash. (Tom Gralish / Staff Photographer)
Tyler Wales hugs Brittany Alison (back showing) on Sunday after Alison, Kelsey Brinton (left) and Mandi Geckle (right) brought balloons and signs to a memorial. Four of their classmates died there in a crash. (Tom Gralish / Staff Photographer)Read more

Four Coatesville Area School District students were killed early Sunday morning when their car flipped and slid up an embankment near a challenging stretch of two-lane road in West Brandywine Township.

The West Brandywine Police Department said in a statement that the crash occurred just before 1 a.m. in the 1300 block of North Manor Road. Police said all four occupants of the car were ejected during the crash.

"Names are not being disclosed at this time due to the pending investigation," police said in a statement.

Police declined to say anything else about the crash or the investigation.

The students were identified by family members, neighbors, or friends, some at the site of the crash and some in interviews.

The four were Collin McElroy, 16; Evan Pringle, 15; Jerry Warfel, 14; and Kyle Marsh, whose age could not be determined.

"Due to the tragic loss of four Coatesville Area School District students, a drop-in grief counseling center will be available to students and staff on Tuesday, July 5, from 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. in the 11/12 building library," said a statement on the school website.

The crash occurred as the car traveled north on Route 82. The road is narrow and, in places, has many twists and turns, though at the scene of the crash it is straight. The area has tall trees with a canopy of leaves that would make it quite dark at night.

The car left Route 82 just past the intersection of U.S. Route 322 - an intersection that has a sign with blinking lights that says "Dip 200 feet."

The marks on the road suggest the driver did not handle the bump.

Police would not describe the make and model of the car or say who was driving.

Friends and family stopped by the scene to lay flowers and leave hats, footballs, and baseballs.

McElroy was going into 11th grade. His Facebook page and friends indicated he loved baseball and riding four-wheelers.

Sean Malone, 17, a friend of McElroy's, said he drove with and played in a baseball game with McElroy two days before the accident. At the site of the crash, Malone left a baseball and a message: "Gone but never forgotten. We'll miss you CMac."

"He was a speed demon," Malone said. "He rode dirt bikes, and it looks like he came up too fast [to the bump]."

Bob Smith, who coached McElroy on one of the baseball teams he played on, came to the scene with his son, Dylan, 17.

"He loved baseball and he loved fast cars," Dylan Smith said of McElroy. "He had a Honda Prelude with 260,000 miles on it. He wished it was a race car."

Chris Paulsen, the uncle of Warfel, is an emergency medical technician.

"I've seen a lot of these, but it's not the same when it's your own family," Paulsen said, standing near the crash site. "He was a good kid. A very good artist. A talented musician. And he loved to restore old cars. He and his dad were restoring an old Nova."