Skip to content

Thomas J. Elliott, 92, company owner

Thomas J. Elliott, 92, of Northeast Philadelphia, a company owner and college football referee who made a famously controversial call at a Princeton-Rutgers game, died Saturday, May 15, at Vitas Hospice at Nazareth Hospital in Philadelphia.

Thomas J. Elliott, 92, of Northeast Philadelphia, a company owner and college football referee who made a famously controversial call at a Princeton-Rutgers game, died Saturday, May 15, at Vitas Hospice at Nazareth Hospital in Philadelphia.

Mr. Elliott had been a referee for Division I college football games for 15 years when he was forced to make a difficult call at the 1974 Princeton-Rutgers contest.

The stands were packed with rowdy fans and Rutgers was leading, 6-0, with 17 seconds left in the game when Princeton scored. The game was tied and the Princeton kicker wanted to go for the extra point, but fans had torn down both goalposts.

Everyone wanted to give Mr. Elliot advice, he later told Inquirer columnist Bill Lyon. Suggestions included building a makeshift goalpost, having officials stand on each other's shoulders for a human goalpost, and marching the teams to a practice field down the road - an idea Mr. Elliott nixed. "I got this terrible vision of me being followed by two teams and 30,000 people. For a mile," he said.

Mr. Elliott made a decision. He let Princeton throw a pass for a conversion. It was incomplete. The game was over.

"I got booed by both sides," Mr. Elliott told Lyon. Later, though, the division commissioner and Rutgers and Princeton coaches agreed he had made the right call. The game cost colleges money because a rule was instituted that they had to have a set of spare goalposts on hand.

Mr. Elliott, who officiated at the 1977 Army-Navy game, continued to referee college games on Saturdays, and officiated at high school football and baseball games during the week until he was in his 60s.

He attended meetings of referees into his 80s, his son, Tom, said.

Mr. Elliott was past president of the Philadelphia Chapter of the Eastern Association of Intercollegiate Football Officials. From 1983 to 1985 he was supervisor of referees for the former United States Football League. He loved teaching young referees the game, his son said. He was inducted into the Pennsylvania Sports Hall of Fame in 1996.

Growing up in Fairmount, Mr. Elliott played baseball for the Parkway League and later managed a Parkway team. He graduated from St. Joseph's Preparatory School and attended St. Joseph's University for two years.

In his youth, he played semipro football for the Tacony Shamrocks and the Venango Bears and also coached the Bears.

During World War II, he worked at the Naval Shipyard in Philadelphia. After the war, he was an electrician for the Pullman Co. in Philadelphia. In the 1950s he purchased American Kitchen Machinery & Repairs in Old City. The firm, which sells and services restaurant equipment, is now operated by Mr. Elliott's granddaughter Andrea Mahon.

Mr. Elliott's wife of 52 years, Catherine Foley Elliott, died in 1990. A son, Robert, died last year.

In addition to his son and his granddaughter, Mr. Elliott is survived by four other grandchildren and eight great-grandchildren.

A Funeral Mass will be at 10 a.m. Wednesday, May 19, at Christ the King Roman Catholic Church, Morrell Avenue and Chesterfield Road, Philadelphia. Friends may call from 9 a.m. Burial will be in Forest Hills Cemetery, Huntingdon Valley.