Flyers exceed expectations with thrilling first-round series win over the Penguins in overtime

The biggest Flyers home game in 16 years was the best of that mostly dull and empty stretch of time, 77 minutes and 32 seconds of total tension, loads of scoring chances, a near-equal number of stellar saves by the two goaltenders, all of the action and apprehension inside Xfinity Mobile Arena building and building and building … until Cam York flicked a little wrist shot from the right point that sailed on an enchanted journey to the back of the Pittsburgh Penguins’ net. Until the place felt like a gigantic joy-filled balloon that just popped.

Flyers 1, Penguins 0 in overtime. Welcome back to springtime, Flyers fans.

» READ MORE: Cam York’s OT winner eliminates the Penguins, as Flyers advance to the second round for the first time since 2020

No sense in minimizing what Wednesday night meant. The last time the Flyers had a playoff game in this arena that mattered so much was during their run to the 2010 Stanley Cup Final. Sure, they had been in the postseason thereafter, but none of those series carried the weight of this one. Those minidramas had played out during a different era for the franchise, when playoff berths were expected and perhaps taken for granted. The context now is different, not just because the Flyers hadn’t been a playoff team for so long, but because Game 6 was a pivot point for both the series and the Flyers’ immediate future.

Consider the two possible outcomes and their ramifications. The Flyers finished off the Penguins and got the better of Sidney Crosby for one of the rare times in his 21-year career. They have advanced to the second round for the first time since 2020, and they have cemented this season as a success. They now take on the Carolina Hurricanes — the top team in the Eastern Conference — in a pressure-free atmosphere. They are, as the cliché goes, playing with house money now, and the table in front of them is covered in chips.

On the flip side of that thrilling coin, there would be really no way to sugarcoat it if they had lost Wednesday night and were to lose again Saturday. The goodwill that they had generated over the last month and a half, the belief that they were finally making the transition from a bad-to-mediocre team to a solid and competitive one, wouldn’t disappear, no. But it would be tainted. The mere act of qualifying for the playoffs for the first time since the COVID-extended season of 2019-20 had awakened a dormant fan base and stripped away much of its cynicism. Becoming just the fifth NHL team to lose a seven-game series after leading it three games to none would dampen those happy, hopeful sentiments at least.

Mike Sielski alerts

Weekly

Catch Mike Sielski’s sharp takes and in-depth sports analysis, sent straight to your inbox.

At its most consequential, such a collapse could compel the Flyers’ leadership — president Keith Jones, general manager Danny Brière, chairman Dan Hilferty — to take a hard look at the roster and ask themselves, What did we learn about the young players who are here? Who among them pleasantly surprised us? And did we see something that raises concerns? The salary-cap space that they’ll have this offseason is unlikely to do them much good. More and more teams sign their best and most promising players long before those budding stars are eligible for free agency, so the pickings figure to be slim there. Instead, to make whatever additions and changes they decided were necessary to improve, the Flyers would have to make a trade.

Perhaps Jones and Brière would be inclined to consider and make such changes anyway, but they can do so now with freer minds, with the knowledge that this team did truly take a step forward — and, at the moment, still can keep moving. The crowd at Xfinity Mobile Arena stayed and roared and soaked it all in. Of course they did. It had been such a long time since spring had come around for them.