In fact, an analysis of 50 years of research on suicidal thoughts and attempts found medical professionals’ ability to predict suicidal behavior is only slightly better than chance.
Researchers at the University of Pittsburgh are hoping to change that with a new predictive scoring tool they’ve developed. In a study published Wednesday in JAMA Psychiatry, they showed the tool correctly predicted suicidal behavior in 87 percent of cases.
More studies are needed to verify its reliability, but it’s a start, said Nadine Melhem, a coauthor of the study and an associate professor of psychiatry at Pitt’s School of Medicine. “We want to equip clinicians with something that gives them more confidence in their ability to predict suicidal behavior in a patient.”
Melhem and her team developed the predictive risk scoring tool after studying 663 children for 12 years. The children were considered at high risk for suicide because their parents had mood disorders. Over the years, researchers periodically evaluated the parents and children for psychiatric diagnoses and symptoms, such as depression, hopelessness, and irritability.
They found that the strongest predictor of suicidal behavior was not just the severity of depressive symptoms, but how much those symptoms varied over time.
“It’s a shift in thinking about which risk factors are most predictive,” Melhem said.
Currently, many therapists rely on psychiatric diagnoses. For example, patients with depression or substance use disorders are considered at greater risk for suicide than patients with anxiety or eating disorders.
“But diagnoses are labels that don’t change,” Melhem said, while suicidal behavior varies during the course of a psychiatric illness. “We want to reflect and address what are the symptoms that change with that risk.”
The study suggests therapists should think not only about how a patient feels in the moment, but how severe their symptoms have been in the past and how often those symptoms change.
Melhem and her colleagues combined this information with other known risk factors for suicide — like being younger than 30, having a history of childhood abuse, and having a parent who attempted suicide — to create the predictive risk score.
If a patient meets the criteria for more than three items on the scoring tool, then it indicates they’re at high risk for suicidal behavior.
The tool identifies suicide risk about as well as a mammogram identifies cancerous masses, Melhem said. That means it may lead to some false positives, but “in an outcome like suicidal behavior, that’s better than a false negative,” she said.
The scoring tool has only been tested in the same population used to develop it, so further research is needed to verify its reliability.
It’s also unclear if it would work for all youths, or only those whose parents have mood disorders.
But the main benefits, Melhem said, are that the tool is low-cost and based on information therapists are already collecting.
“We just want to bring that information to the forefront of clinicians’ minds,” Melhem said.