Read judge's order to kill school tax hike
Lower Merion falsely blamed teacher pensions, special ed
As Kathy Boccella reported in Thursday's Inquirer, Montgomery County Judge Joseph A. Smyth "ordered the Lower Merion School District to revoke this year's tax hike, saying the district misled taxpayers by projecting large budget deficits to justify raising taxes... when it actually had socked away millions."
Read Judge Smyth's decision, in a case brought by Gladwyne lawyer Arthur Wolk and two other taxpayers, here:
http://media.philly.com/documents/08-30-16+Decision+re+Pet+Inj+Relief.pdf
Lower Merion's $100 million Harriton High School, built in 2009. (Inquirer)
Summary: The school district claimed it faced "multimillion-dollar deficits" for special education and teacher pensions. But Smyth found Lower Merion's own audited statements showed it was actually hoarding "multi-million dollar surpluses." The district exaggerated expenses, downplayed income, and used those numbers to win special state permission for large annual tax increases without asking voters.
Highlights: Wolk sued in February to stop this year's 4.44%, $55 million tax hike; in May they sought a court injunction blocking the increase; on June 13 the Democrat-controlled school board enacted the increase; Wolk then asked the court to "rescind" it.
At a hearing next day, Unionville-Chadds Ford School District elected board member and finance committee member Keith Knauss tesfied for the taxpayers, citing state law limiting budgets and increases; Victor Orlando, Lower Merion's school business manager, explained the district's side of the story.
Wolk showed that in the six years 2009-14 the district predicted deficits every year, of a median $6 million -- but actually collected surpluses every year, median $7 million.
Given that pattern, Judge Smyth found Orlando's claim "he was unable to predict" another surplus this year -- despite having almost all the tax and spending data needed -- to be "not credible."
Smyth found an average annual "overestimation" of 5.5% for Lower Merion school expenses, plus a 1.1% "underestimation" of revenues.
"In each year of projecting a deficit in the budget published to the public, the School District did so in connection with proposing a tax increase," the judge noted. And every time, in those six years, there was actually a surplus.
"Since 2006 the School District has raised its taxes by a total of 53.3%," Smyth noted. Yet Lower Merion also "has approximately $50 million to $60 million in the bank."
What's wrong with boosting taxes every year to set aside enough to build, say, another school? Under the Pa. School Code (as amended in 2003) "no school district may approve an increase in taxes unless it has adopted a budget" that includes a small surplus. Lower Merion budgets "technically complied" by claiming its surplus was below its 8% limit. But its actual surplus was higher, each year.
Lower Merion dealt with these illegal cash pile-ups by "transferring surpluses from undesignated funds to other, designated accounts," such as the capital account for building projects.
State law (Act 1, the Taxpayer Relief Act) prohibits schools from raising taxes by more than a limit -- currently 2.4% -- unless they can show a deficit, get state permission, or win a voter referendum.
Instead of putting it up to a vote, Lower Merion got the state to approve its outsize tax increases by claiming it needt to pay "special education and employees pensions."
"However, neither the Department's proposed budgets nor the actual surpluses it experienced in prior years" were provided to the state to justify the tax increases.
But the district's own audits showed surpluses sometimes in the "millions" for special education -- and a $15.3 million pension set-aside that "was not being used for pensions," which instead "were being funded out of the budget."
So Lower Merion's own numbers showed a tax increase below the state's 2.4% special-permission limit "would be sufficient to cover any budgetary imbalance."
In short: "Lower Merion School District, over the course of approximately the last ten fiscal years, deliberately engaged in a course of conduct that
"(1) ovestimated in... millions, the deficits the District would incur,... and published these estimates to justify tax increases;
"(2) failed to predict, although the sdata was patently clear... that the District would actually end the fiscal year with a multimllion-dollar surplus;
"(3) raised taxes... wihtout a referendum of the voters by consistently" telling state officials "that costs for pensions and special education could not be covered by a tax increase...
"(4) transferred money.. to avoid the statutory cap" on surpluses, again to justify "raising taxes."
State law didn't actually require Lower Merion to show the state Education Department its budget to win permission to rasie taxes above the state target, Judge Smyth noted.
State law does require school districts to follow "state guidelines for good accounting practices," including not using surpluses for "recurring expenses," which are supposed to be part of the annual budget. But not, Smyth found, in Lower Merion schools.
There is "no particular sanction" for what the school district did. But Lower Merion "knew or should have known" they were breaking the rule.
"They are skirting the purposes of the law" in order to raise taxes beyond state guidelines "without going to a referendum of the voters."
This is "less than the transparent budgeting and taxing process the Public School Code and the Taxpayer Relief Act sought painstakingly to institue," and violated both spirit and letter of the law.
So Judge Smyth agreed to give Wolk his injunction and rescind the tax increase above the 2.4% state limit.
We might expect an appeal, and suits against other districts.
























