Skip to content
Link copied to clipboard

Review: PROOF

Toby Zinman found this production of PROOF both luminous and moving, making the math as well as the characters accessible and interesting.

By Toby Zinman

For the Inquirer

David Auburn's Pulitzer Prize winning play, Proof,  has found a perfect venue in the intimate Independence Studio on 3 at the Walnut Street Theatre. This luminous production, directed by Kate Galvin, invites you onto the porch  and into the lives of four interesting people.

Unlike so many characters in contemporary plays, these interesting people are all kind and all smart—mathematical wizard smart; nobody is cruel or snide or selfish or violent. Makes a nice change.

Another nice change is how much more coherent and moving the script itself seemed to me in this production, having seen both the original New York production and, a few years later, a local production, and in both the play struck me as inauthentic and contrived.

The plot  revolves around a monumental mathematical genius, Robert (Bill Van Horn) whose beautiful mind snapped years ago; when the play opens, he's already dead. His younger daughter Catherine (Alex Keiper), who inherited his talent and may have inherited his madness, sacrificed her life and education to care for him.  Her older sister Claire (Krista Apple) turns up for the funeral, and his former grad student protege, Hal (David Raphaely), now a math professor himself, is going through the notebooks his mentor left behind. When he discovers a final notebook containing a ground-breaking elegant proof, the plot turns.

Catherine tells Hal about Sophie Germain, an 18th-century French mathematician who discovered what are now called Germain Primes, a kind of prime number; her story is emblematic of the place of women in higher mathematics, not just in the 18th century, either, and a significant signal in the plot of Proof

The title of  the play resonates in several ways: mathematically, a proof is of a theorem, a series of formal statements showing that one assertion necessarily leads to the next. This kind of proof is hard. Proof, as we generally use the word, is the result of evidence, making it much easier than trust. And Proof is, finally, about trust as well as a proof and the lack of proof about the proof.

All the performances are tender and subtle and absolutely convincing.  The lovely set—a brick wall, old porch furniture, dried leaves caught in the window screens-- is designed by Andrew Thompson, and the lighting, designed by J. Dominic Chacon, is full of charm and significance as night turns to dawn and then morning light breaks.


Walnut Street Theatre's Independence Studio on 3, 9th and Walnut Sts. Tickets $30. Information: 215-574-3550 or Through Feb.5.