Q: Is Sen. Ted Cruz, who was born in Canada, eligible to be the U.S. president?
A: Most likely. The legal consensus is that Cruz qualifies because he was born to a U.S. citizen living abroad, making him a U.S. citizen at birth.
Is Ted Cruz eligible to run for president based on the fact he was born in Canada but his mother was American? Exactly what does the Constitution and our other laws say about this?
The U.S. Constitution requires a president to be a "natural born Citizen."
That should disqualify him from being president, right? Not so fast.
In 2013, Sarah Helene Duggin, a Catholic University law professor, wrote: "There is a strong argument that anyone who acquires United States citizenship at birth, whether by virtue of the 14th Amendment or by operation of federal statute, qualifies as natural born."
The nonpartisan Congressional Research Service reached a similar conclusion in 2011.
And this month, Neal Katyal and Paul Clement, two former U.S. solicitors general, writing for the Harvard Law Review, said that Cruz qualifies as a "natural born citizen."
Case closed? Cruz thinks so, as he told Fox News host Sean Hannity on March 23:
So there is still some lingering uncertainty about Cruz's eligibility. That's because the Supreme Court hasn't ruled on the meaning of "natural born citizen," which the Constitution doesn't define.
This is not the first time that a Republican presidential candidate faced such questions. As we have written before, John McCain, who was the Republican nominee in 2008, was born to U.S. citizens in the Panama Canal Zone, and Barry Goldwater, who was the party's nominee in 1964, was born to U.S. citizens in Arizona before it was a state. George Romney, who was born to U.S. citizens in Mexico, ran for president in 1968, but did not win the nomination.
Even Duggin, who wrote in her 2013 article that "a scholarly consensus is emerging … that anyone who acquires citizenship at birth is natural born for purposes of Article II," acknowledges that the issue may not be settled.
"In the absence of a definitive Supreme Court ruling — or a constitutional amendment — the parameters of the clause remain uncertain," she wrote.
– D'Angelo Gore
Gillman, Todd. "Dual citizenship may pose problem if Ted Cruz seeks presidency." Dallas Morning News. 18 Aug 2013.
U.S. Department of State. Acquisition of U.S. Citizenship by a Child Born Abroad. Accessed 24 Mar 2015.
Duggin, Sarah Helene. "Is Ted Cruz a natural-born citizen eligible to serve as president?" Constitution Daily. 28 Oct 2013.
Maskel, Jack. "Qualifications for President and the 'Natural Born' Citizenship Eligibility Requirement." Congressional Research Service. 14 Nov 2011.
Katyal, Neal and Clement, Paul. "On the Meaning of 'Natural Born Citizen.' " Harvard Law Review. 11 Mar 2015.
U.S. Constitution. Article II, Section I.
Naturalization Act of 1790. 26 Mar 1790.
Naturalization Act of 1795. 29 Jan 1795.
Bank, Justin. "John McCain's Presidential Eligibility." FactCheck.org. 16 Jun 2008.
Hulse, Carl. "McCain's Canal Zone Birth Prompts Queries About Whether That Rules Him Out." New York Times. 28 Feb 2008.