Unions vow to fight Christie's veto of free rides
Employee unions vowed Friday to fight Gov. Christie's effort to ban free trips for workers at the Delaware River Port Authority, the New Jersey Turnpike Authority, and other agencies.

Employee unions vowed Friday to fight Gov. Christie's effort to ban free trips for workers at the Delaware River Port Authority, the New Jersey Turnpike Authority, and other agencies.
Christie on Thursday vetoed a vote taken Wednesday by DRPA board members that would have reinstated free trips. And he broadened the ban, sending directives to five other bridge and transportation agencies to abolish "any and all free passage unrelated to official business."
On Friday, the union representing toll collectors on the turnpike said it would file a formal grievance to keep its workers' right to free commutes on the toll road.
"It's been that way for 50 years," said Fran Ehret, president of Local 194 of the International Federation of Professional and Technical Engineers. "If they're going to try to take away something we've had for 50 years, we'll have to grieve it."
A lawyer for DRPA police officers in Fraternal Order of Police Lodge 30, Charles Joyce, said the FOP would challenge the ban on free rides.
"We will vigorously contest the action, and we will prevail," he said. "Gov. Christie is obviously politically grandstanding. We have a clear contractual right to this benefit."
Joyce also scolded three labor leaders who are DRPA commissioners for issuing a statement along with the other five New Jersey board members on Friday, agreeing to Christie's veto and promising, in the future, to "be ever cognizant of putting the interests of our customers first."
Christie, on Thursday, said employees "should pay for their personal, nonbusiness use . . . just as the authority requires of its customers."
He sent directives to the Turnpike Authority, which operates the turnpike and the Garden State Parkway; the South Jersey Transportation Authority, which operates the Atlantic City Expressway; the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, which operates six bridges and tunnels, PATH trains, and other facilities; the Delaware River and Bay Authority, which operates the Delaware Memorial Bridge and the Cape May-Lewes Ferry; and the Delaware River Joint Toll Bridge Commission, which operates the I-78 toll bridge across the Delaware.
A directive was not sent to NJ Transit, whose employees get free rides on the agency's trains. Asked about that Friday, Christie spokesman Michael Drewniak said the governor's office "will also be evaluating all free-passage benefits at any other relevant agencies."
Some of the agencies quickly agreed to Christie's directive; others, including the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, said they needed time to review its implications.
Tom Feeney, a spokesman for the Turnpike Authority, said: "We understand the governor's edict, and the next step is to figure out how to implement it."
Employees on the turnpike and the parkway get free commutes on "nonrevenue" E-ZPass transponders and are required to reimburse the toll agency for any other personal use, Feeney said.
The FOP and International Union of Operating Engineers Local 542, which represents toll collectors and other DRPA workers, filed formal grievances last month, arguing that their free trips were part of their contracts and could not be removed unilaterally.
At Wednesday's board meeting, DRPA chief executive John Matheussen said he agreed and was ruling in the unions' favor. That finding apparently was overruled by Christie's veto.
"Their own management has found it is a clear-cut contractual obligation," said Frank Bankard, business representative for Local 542. "What Christie did is unlawful."
"If Christie is so concerned about saving money, why is he forcing this to arbitration?"
Asked about the apparent conflict between the union contracts and the governor's directives, Christie spokesman Drewniak declined comment.
Joyce, the FOP lawyer, said the Jersey labor leaders on the DRPA board "should be ashamed of themselves."
"They would never let something like this happen to their members. They're just kowtowing to an antilabor governor."
He was responding to a statement issued Friday by the New Jersey DRPA board members.
It said: "If we had it to do again, we would not vote to reinstate" the free rides.
"In retrospect, we recognize that we did not sufficiently consider the comments of Gov. Christie and vice chairman [Jeffrey] Nash. In particular we did not sufficiently consider the interests of our toll payers and PATCO riders.
"Our customers, whether from New Jersey or Pennsylvania, depend on the DRPA and PATCO to deliver quality transportation services at a fair price without incurring the commuting costs for DRPA employees," the statement said.
"In addition, we are prepared to move the remaining reforms proposed by the governor and in the future be ever cognizant of putting the interests of our customers first."
Labor leaders who serve as New Jersey DRPA commissioners are Richard Sweeney, treasurer of Ironworkers Local 399 and brother of State Senate President Stephen Sweeney; Albert Frattali, administrator of the Ironworkers' local's health and pension fund; and E. Frank DiAntonio, retired president of Laborers Local 172.
Until the current dispute over free rides erupted in July, the DRPA's policy had been to allow all employees free passage to commute to and from work and to allow most of them 100 additional free rides a year for personal use.
All DRPA employees hired before Jan. 1, 2007, were entitled to 100 free E-ZPass trips across DRPA bridges and 10 free rides on PATCO High-Speed trains annually. Those employees were entitled to 100 E-ZPass trips a year upon retirement.
Workers hired on or after Jan. 1, 2007, got the freebies while on the payroll, but not after retiring.
Those hired on or after Sept. 14, 2008 - the date of the most recent toll increase - received only the free commuting trips.
The policies were similar for PATCO employees.
Policies at other agencies vary.
At NJ Transit and SEPTA, current and retired employees travel free on their respective agency's vehicles.
All 2,000 Pennsylvania Turnpike employees, including turnpike commissioners, are allowed to ride free on the state's 545 miles of toll roads, said spokesman William J. Capone.
At the Burlington County Bridge Commission, which operates the Tacony-Palmyra and Burlington-Bristol Bridges, there are no free rides.
The Delaware River and Bay Authority, which operates the Delaware Memorial Bridge, offers no free passage.
At the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, nearly 7,600 current and retired employees get free use of E-ZPass tags for all of the agency's Hudson River and Staten Island crossings.
The agency also allows 1,100 PATH rail employees free train use. Spouses of PATH workers and retirees get the perk, too.
In Delaware, "we do not offer [free transportation] as a benefit to any state employees," said Transportation Department spokesperson Sandy Roumillat.
Neil Gray, spokesman for the International Bridge, Tunnel and Turnpike Association, which has about 90 U.S. affiliates, said that while there is "no standard model" or policy, "it is pretty common to have a certain number of free passes for employees," with the privilege many times "limited to employees and commissioners."
He said: "Often, when you have toll collectors, they might need to use the turnpike to get to work."
























