Skip to content

Trump's 'sweeping economic plan'

Will it make him popular like Reagan?

In his speech last Thursday on "An American Economic Revival," GOP Presidential candidates Donald "Trump certainly laid out a more sweeping and specific economic plan than anything presented by Clinton so far," writes investment economist Ed Yardeni in his daily newsletter today. (Emphases added)

Yardeni picks through Trump's plan, details below. Bottom line: "Stock investors might conclude that a reprise of Reaganomics might be better than four more years of Obamanomics, i.e., higher taxes, more regulation, and large budget deficits." -- Highlights:

"Many conservatives gave Donald Trump high marks for his speech on Thursday, September 15, when he discussed his economic program. It must have reminded them of Ronald Reagan's economic policies, which were favorably greeted by stock investors. Consider the following:

"(1) Taxes. There are lots of Reagan-style policies outlined in the speech. First and foremost are lower tax rates and tax simplification.

"More specifically, Trump proposes to reduce the number of tax brackets from seven to three, i.e., 12%, 25%, and 33%. He added that "millions and millions" of low-income Americans will pay no income tax at all." Of course, "that's already the case -- half the population" already doesn't earn enough to pay income tax, though 'most everyone who works pays Social Security (some police and other government workers have substitute pensions instead).

"Trump vaguely promised to cap deductions for the wealthy and close special-interest loopholes. Getting Congress to enact specific measures for doing so won't be easy."  He also promised "a new deduction for the average cost of childcare, including for stay-at-home parents."

Top corporate income tax rates "would be slashed from 35% to 15%. In addition, the tax on repatriated earnings would be cut to 10%."

"(2) Regulation. The influence of Trump's supply-side economic advisers is also reflected in his proposals for regulatory relief: 'I've proposed a moratorium on new federal regulations that are not compelled by Congress or public safety, and I will eliminate all needless and job-killing regulations now on the books.

"'This includes eliminating some of our most intrusive regulations, like the Waters of The U.S. Rule. It also means scrapping the EPA's so-called Clean Power Plan which the government itself estimates will cost $7.2 billion a year" to "close down coal-fired power plants."

"(3) Energy. Without providing any specifics, Trump pledged to 'lift restrictions on all sources of American energy production.' It's not clear which he can lift using the President's executive powers and which would require the cooperation of Congress.

"(4) Trade. Trump blamed China for the slowdown in US economic growth, observing that real GDP rose 3.5% per year on average following WWII through 2000. Then China joined the World Trade Organization at the end of 2001, and US growth slowed to 2.0%. [But] seeing causality in that coincidence is certainly debatable.

"Nevertheless, Trump is convinced that bad trade deals have hurt US workers. He repeated his claim that 'households are making less today than they were in the year 2000.'" (Which Yardeni finds is "false" -- see below.)

"He intends to renegotiate NAFTA, to keep the US out of the Trans-Pacific Partnership [which doesn't include China but rather our Pacific allies], and to label China a currency manipulator.

"He will also 'apply tariffs to any country that devalues its currency to gain an unfair advantage over the United States.' "

"(5) Infrastructure. Interestingly, while he mentioned infrastructure spending a few times, he did so in passing, with no indication of any specific program or proposals.

"Near the end of his speech, though, he said, 'We will rebuild our roads, bridges, tunnels, highways, airports, schools and hospitals.'" But no financial details. Obama also wanted to increase infrastructure spending, in his first term, with borrowed money, which Congress refused.

"BOTTOM LINE: This plan seems too good to be true."

"For starters, Trump has to stay with the script, which is not his style. Congress gets the final say on his proposals for cutting taxes and capping deductions and loopholes.

"Trump certainly won't get any cooperation from Democrats, and even Republicans may resist his pushy and politically incorrect style.

"His tough measures on trade could backfire if they lead to a proliferation of protectionism [and drive up U.S. retail and business prices]. Ironically, we may need construction workers from Mexico to rebuild our infrastructure, including the wall to keep them out..."

ALSO: Trump "bemoaned the stagnant standard of living in the US, saying 'Household incomes are down more than $4,000 since the year 2000.'

"This is a widely believed urban legend.... It is based on flawed data...

"Trump’s woebegone income measure is real median household [cash] income compiled by the Census Bureau. He was absolutely right in stating that it was down $4,000 (7.0%) from $57,790 during 2000 to $53,720 in 2014 (Fig. 1)" though most of that gap actually disappeared when 2015 data was released last month.

But: "If he wants to stick with the facts, he should also mention that real median and mean family incomes rose to record highs last year, as did real mean  household income.... 

"Even these happy data series seriously understate the improvement in the standard of living since 2000... Census measures of income are limited to pre-tax money income... They exclude entitlement benefits"  starting with government-funded medical care [Medicare, Medicaid...] They also are based on limited micro data, e.g., surveys, rather than much more comprehensive payroll and tax return macro data.

"A much better measure is personal income, which is compiled monthly by the Bureau of Economic Analysis. We can compare it to the Census measure by multiplying the Census current-dollar mean household income series by the number of households...

"During 2015, personal income [including medical care and other government assistance] totaled $15.5 trillion, while money income totaled $9.3 trillion--a difference of $6.2 trillion!...

"Compare the averages of personal income and money income, both deflated by the personal consumption expenditures deflator (Fig. 4). Since 2000, the former is up 18.8%," more than triple the 5.3% increase in money income.

"Also at a record high during June were both nominal and real retail sales per household (Fig. 6). The latter is up 36% since the start of 2000 to $45,840 during June...

"The overall [Consumer Outlook Index] is back at previous cyclical highs. Apparently, Les Mis [Trump's recent label for what Hillary Clinton calls Trump's 'Deplorables'] aren't very miserable.

"Americans have never been as well off as they are today, and they are relatively optimistic."