Skip to content

Philly schools will spend $11 million more on subs — school board roundup

The district cut 200-plus building substitutes this year to save money, but now must pay $11 more. The school board also remembered Malayshia Allford.

The Philadelphia school board authorized spending an additional $11 million on substitute teachers. The school system cut building subs this year, saying that move would save $13 million.
The Philadelphia school board authorized spending an additional $11 million on substitute teachers. The school system cut building subs this year, saying that move would save $13 million.Read moreJose F. Moreno / Staff Photographer

The Philadelphia School District will pay an additional $11 million to employ substitute teachers — months after it cut 200-plus building substitutes in what it said was a move to save $13 million.

The school board voted Thursday night to up its contract with ESS Northeast, its substitute provider. It had authorized a $158.5 million contract from 2022 through 2027, but will now pay $169.5 million over that term.

ESS, the board’s resolution said, “has achieved a higher fill rate than initially anticipated, requiring an increase in authorized compensation to cover the additional substitute coverage provided.”

The board technically ratified the contract for “services rendered through November 19, 2026, ensuring uninterrupted classroom coverage.”

Board documents said the prior renewal did not allocate sufficient funding.

ESS’s fill rate is improving, the documents show. In November of 2025, 75% of substitute teaching requests were filled, up from 55% in November of 2022.

Lift Every Voice Philly, a parent-led advocacy group, had campaigned against eliminating building subs — saying the move would tax already-strained school resources — and said the $11 million bill was a natural consequence.

“Now, the district is scrambling to cover staffing, paying an additional $11 million for just ten weeks of substitute coverage, and leaving our children and schools to bear the consequences,” the group said in a statement Thursday.

The substitute measure passed unanimously. No board member offered public comment about the additional allocation.

Remembering Malayshia

The board began Thursday’s meeting with a moment of silence for Malayshia Allford, the 10-year-old who was allegedly killed by her foster mother, a former district teacher.

Board president Reginald Streater said he and Superintendent Tony B. Watlington Sr. attended Malayshia’s celebration of life service this week, offering condolences to her family. Malayshia attended Lamberton Elementary in West Philadelphia.

» READ MORE: How the paths of 10-year-old Malayshia Allford and a Philadelphia teacher tragically collided

“It weighs heavily on all of us, on this board, and I know everybody in this room,” Streater said of Malayshia’s death. “Our thoughts and deepest sympathies are with are with her family, loved ones, classmates, teachers, and everyone who knew her and cared for her as well.”

Carprice Williams, Malayshia’s foster mother, was a fifth-grade teacher at Cassidy Elementary, also in West Philadelphia. A foster child placed in her care in 2021 was hospitalized with near-fatal injuries.

How Williams was allowed to continue to teach, and continue to foster children, is now the subject of intense scrutiny, and formal investigation.

“This tragedy reminds us of the profound responsibility we all share to protect, nurture and care for our children, particularly those who are the most vulnerable,” Streater said.

The PFT wants the district to halt school closures

Philadelphia Federation of Teachers president Arthur Steinberg addressed the board Thursday night, asking them to adopt the PFT’s counterproposal to the district’s facilities master plan, which would close 17 schools.

The first phase of the PFT’s plan would keep all 17 schools open with modernizations it says would cost $25 million the system already has, and could be accomplished relatively quickly.

» READ MORE: Philly teachers union says it has a plan to prevent 17 Philly school closures — for $25 million

“You haven’t explained why any one of these schools must close,” Steinberg said. “It is now clear to me that closing schools was always the goal.”

Steinberg said “everyone hates” the district’s $3 billion plan, which includes 169 modernization projects but is mostly unfunded.

The district has formed transition committees at all of the 17 closing schools — those committees began meeting this month.

“After one meeting, we have members now from the 17 closing schools ... that are resigning from those committees, because they believe their input is not being seriously considered,” Steinberg said.