Skip to content

Miles Teodecki plays through pain and helps lead Penn to a win over Princeton in its season finale

Though freshmen led the way offensively, Quakers seniors like Josh Narcisse and Cole Olsztyn stepped up on defense and helped knock the Tigers out of contention for a share of the Ivy League crown.

Penn quarterback Miles Teodecki hands off to running back Sean Williams Jr. against Yale in October. Penn beat Yale and Princeton in the same season for the fourth time in 15 years.
Penn quarterback Miles Teodecki hands off to running back Sean Williams Jr. against Yale in October. Penn beat Yale and Princeton in the same season for the fourth time in 15 years.Read moreYong Kim / Staff Photographer

In its final game of the season, Penn didn’t make many mistakes.

Freshman quarterback Miles Teodecki reprised his starting role and led the visiting Quakers to a 19-12 win over Princeton on Saturday, despite playing much of the game on a broken toe.

After Teodecki and the offense jumped out to a 19-0 lead, the Tigers failed to mount a comeback, ending their quest for a share of the Ivy League title.

Quakers coach Rick Santos repeatedly expressed his gratitude to the seniors but said he knows their “record wasn’t what they wanted it to be, and they didn’t leave with a ring.”

Despite that, it’s just the fourth time in the last 15 years that Penn has beaten Princeton and Yale in the same season.

“So that’s a lot for them to take home with, and it certainly gave us a lot of momentum going into the offseason,” he said.

Penn capitalizes on Princeton penalties

Two costly Princeton penalties widened its early deficit.

Penn was setting up for a field goal on its opening drive when Princeton (6-4) was flagged for an illegal shift. Teodecki wasted no time taking advantage of the Tigers’ miscue and put the Quakers on the board with a 2-yard rushing touchdown with 6 minutes, 40 seconds left in the first quarter.

Penn played with patience and scored on all four trips to Princeton’s red zone. Teodecki, who was starting after junior Karson Siquieros-Lasky suffered an ankle injury last week, looked comfortable in the pocket and completed 62.5% of his passes (15 of 24) for 103 yards and a touchdown.

A Princeton player stepped on Teodecki’s toe in the second quarter, but he ignored it and didn’t tell Santos about the pain. An X-ray postgame showed the break.

“It just shows what type of kid he is and his competitive spirit,” Santos said. “He refused to come out of the game and he finished the game, basically for three quarters with a broken toe, and it helped us get the win, so proud of him.”

» READ MORE: Miles Teodecki had offers from Power Four schools. The quarterback chose Penn instead.

Penn also leveraged its run game and outgained Princeton, 114-70. With top running backs Donte West and Tommy Lafayette injured, senior Sean Williams and sophomore EJ Carter stepped up, finishing with 57 and 32 rushing yards, respectively.

Teodecki wasn’t the only Penn freshman to step up on offense. Penn’s second touchdown came courtesy of Owen van der Veen’s 6-yard grab. It was his first career catch. His fellow wide receivers, Simon Cofrancesco and Mason Page, led the Quakers with 30 and 25 yards, respectively.

Defense, defense, defense

Defensively, however, seniors largely led the way against Princeton backup quarterback Ty Ciongoli. Ciongoli started in place of Wyatt Becker, who broke his collarbone last week.

Although Ciongoli completed 20 of 40 passes for 323 yards and a touchdown, he struggled to get into a rhythm early (11 of Princeton’s 14 first downs came in the second half) and threw three interceptions.

The first pick was courtesy of senior defensive back Josh Narcisse, his first interception of the season. Another senior, linebacker Cole Olsztyn, finished with a team-high seven tackles.

“He’s been a tremendous leader all year,” Santos said of Narcisse. “I’m just really happy that he could have that interception in his last game.”

Olsztyn also played a major role in keeping the Tigers off the board in the first half. A 10-yard holding penalty negated a touchdown, and on the next play, Olsztyn recovered a fumble to help preserve the Quakers’ 19-0 lead, which Santos called “tremendous.”

A freshman did notch a highlight play as Luke Flowers recorded the third interception of the day. Junior Jack Grusser added the other.

“We were fortunate to play a lot of freshmen and sophomores, and I think our junior class is very strong — in particular, [on] the defensive side of the ball,” Santos said. “So the future looks really bright.”

Join The Conversation