Skip to content

Dad shot dead after killing two sons, wounding third in Pennsauken

Weird. Quiet. Different. Antisocial. The words to describe Alfred Moton came easily yesterday for his neighbors in Pennsauken. But none of those neighbors, or the police, could build a bridge from Moton's quirky past to the rage that caused him to kill two sons and wound a third son before making a suicidal charge at police inside his burning home Thursday night.

Pennsauken firefighters in and outside the house at 4434 Royal Ave. after extinguishing a fire that caused heavy damge. The fire is believed to have been set by the father of three boys, all of whom he shot before being shot himself by police. (Curt Hudson / For the Daily News)
Pennsauken firefighters in and outside the house at 4434 Royal Ave. after extinguishing a fire that caused heavy damge. The fire is believed to have been set by the father of three boys, all of whom he shot before being shot himself by police. (Curt Hudson / For the Daily News)Read more

Weird. Quiet. Different. Antisocial.

The words to describe Alfred Moton came easily yesterday for his neighbors in Pennsauken. But none of those neighbors, or the police, could build a bridge from Moton's quirky past to the rage that caused him to kill two sons and wound a third son before making a suicidal charge at police inside his burning home Thursday night.

"He was definitely bizarre, but can bizarre explain it?" asked Chaurdron Carter, the Motons' next-door neighbor. "Can bizarre come to this?"

The Motons' two-story, brick home was blackened and boarded up yesterday afternoon, and the smell of charred wood drifted over the entire neighborhood. A few miles away, at Cooper University Hospital, 16-year-old Charles Moton remained in critical condition with a gunshot wound to the chest.

His brothers, Alfred "AJ" Jr., 18, and Stephen, 12, died when their father shot them in their Royal Avenue home Thursday night around 10:30 and then lit the house on fire, police said. Police shot Alfred Moton, 54, when he charged at them from a back sunroom holding a can of gasoline, a lighter and a handgun shortly afterward, they said.

"They were yelling, 'Put it down, put it down, put it down,' " said Abe Stevens, a neighbor. "Then I must have heard about nine shots."

Stevens said he saw one of the teens jump over his fence after the shooting, but he collapsed shortly afterward. On Beacon Avenue, resident David Lee said Charles Moton collapsed in his driveway and was barely breathing when a Pennsauken officer started performing CPR. AJ was found dead on nearby Henwood Avenue. Stephen never made it out of the house.

"It was crazy out here," Lee said.

Authorities also discovered an elderly man in the burning home but he was not seriously injured. Neighbors said they believed the man was a relative of Moton's wife.

Years of ignoring neighbors and sequestering his family meant few in the neighborhood knew anything about Moton personally.

"He didn't interact with anyone," said a female neighbor across the street who asked not to be identified. "No one got close to him. He was a different kind of guy."

Authorities said Moton was a dental assistant in Camden County, but most neighbors assumed he had a blue-collar job to match his motorcycle and navy-blue Ford F-150 pickup. His wife, Leonor, was much friendlier, they said. She was working a late shift as a nurse at a Camden County hospital when the shootings occurred.

Stevens was there when Leonor Moton pulled up in her silver van amid a throng of police cars.

"I heard her crying out there. When the cops told her, she broke down," he said.

When reached by phone in Camden yesterday, a relative of Leonor Moton's said the family did not want to comment. On Atlantic Avenue in Camden, a man who bought a rowhouse from Moton in 2001 said he was "weird" and had a sharp edge about him.

"He wasn't a soft guy. He was like military," the man said. "He didn't take anything from the boys on the corners around here. He wasn't scared of them."

AJ Moton rarely mentioned his father, former classmate Alex Salcedo said, but there was a sense that the elder Moton was "very strict."

In January, AJ mentioned his father's conspiracy theories in a Facebook update.

"My dad is talkin about how the H1N1 shots are a set up for 2012, just like in I AM LEGEND, and the he's talkin about how the government is makin a DEATHSTAR to destroy earth to regular the population, gawd he's so crazy, nuffin gonna happen anyway lmao," the post stated.

Salcedo described AJ, who was studying biology as a freshman at Rowan University, and his brother Charles, a junior at Camden Catholic High School, as outgoing "characters."

"When AJ entered the room, he was a big ball of joy. You could be sad, upset, and angry, and it was like he made everything better," said Salcedo, who graduated from Camden Catholic with AJ this year and played lacrosse with Charles.

School officials at Camden Catholic declined to comment yesterday. A spokesman for Rowan said AJ Moton's death was a "tragedy that would affect the whole university community." At the St. Stephen's School, a few blocks from the Moton home, an administrator declined to comment on Stephen Moton, who was a student there. The parish pastor was at Cooper Hospital with the family yesterday afternoon.

Alfred Moton did not appear to have any serious criminal convictions or long-term financial problems. Police are hoping Charles Moton might be able to shed some light on his father's state of mind before the shooting.

"Pennsauken Police reported no calls for service at that address and no prior experiences with the family that might explain this incident," the Camden County Prosecutor's Office said in a statement.

Neighbors said they didn't see the rage brimming beneath Moton's quiet, emotionless demeanor.

"He just went off," Stevens said. "He was a quiet guy but I guess that's the ones you've got to watch."