Eagles grades: Vic Fangio’s defense stands tall, racks up five sacks in win over Steelers
The Eagles' seven-game losing streak is history, as Byron Young and Jeremiah Trotter Jr. shine vs. Pittsburgh.

Instant grades on the Eagles’ performance in their 19-16 win over the Pittsburgh Steelers:
Quarterback: B-
Joe Milton wasn’t exactly accurate. He made the occasional bad read from the pocket. And he projected some of his passes. But he also played winning football and guided the Eagles to their first victory since Week 2. Milton completed just 11 of 21 passes for 141 yards, but he had no turnovers and was enough of a threat on several designed runs. He also had some impressive throws — the most important when he hit DeVonta Smith for seven yards on third and six to seal the outcome.
» READ MORE: Eagles snap seven-game losing streak, grind out 19-16 win over Steelers behind defense, kicking game
Milton also roped a 14-yard completion to receiver Darius Cooper over the middle to convert a key third-and-10 in the fourth quarter. He made an impressive 29-yard throw to Cooper after getting chased by Steelers defenders to his left in the first quarter. A few plays later, Milton feathered a 38-yard pass to tight end Dallas Goedert.
There were misses. He overthrew Smith after he got behind the Steelers secondary on a deep post to open the second half, and threw behind him two plays later on third down.
Running back: C+
Saquon Barkley got most of his yards on a 38-yard touchdown run at the end of the first quarter that was vintage Barkley. The initial blocking gave him space, but he split two defensive backs with his burst and waltzed into the end zone. He also gained 12 yards on the left edge on his first carry.
Barkley still ran with conviction and for 75 yards on 17 carries before leaving late with an unspecified injury. Will Shipley returned from injury and took Barkley’s spot. He gained just nine yards on four rushes.
Receiver / Tight end: B
While Smith returned from a three-game absence due to a hamstring injury, the Eagles lost their other starter outside when Dontayvion Wicks was placed on injured reserve after suffering a foot injury on Friday.
Smith’s return didn’t exactly buoy the pass offense. Milton missed him a few times, but the receiver also couldn’t secure a third-down pass on an out pattern in the fourth quarter. Smith made a tough 11-yard grab over the middle in the first quarter and finished with five catches for 41 yards.
Cooper did well during Milton’s scramble to work back toward his quarterback and keep both feet inbounds on the 29-yarder. He pulled in a 9-yard grab on a third down out in the fourth quarter. Cooper had a strong downfield block on Barkley’s 38-yard score. He led the Eagles with 59 yards on four grabs. Makai Lemon had a Milton strike go right through his hands in the third quarter. He caught just one of three targets for three yards.
Goedert got behind the edge on his 38-yard catch in the first quarter. He had an illegal shift penalty that wiped out a 12-yard run in the first quarter. Goedert later whiffed on a run block that resulted in a Barkley loss just before the break.
Tight end Johnny Mundt had no chance to block T.J. Watt when matched up against the Steelers edge on a Barkley run that resulted in lost yards. Zach Ertz played a little, but the tight end wasn’t targeted and remains eight receptions from setting the franchise mark for career catches.
Offensive line: C
There was improvement in isolated moments for coach Chris Kuper’s unit. It wasn’t always pretty. There were still missed blocks, assignments, and opportunities. But the ground game was more effective and Milton had time when he needed it the most.
Jordan Mailata and Landon Dickerson had key blocks to the left on Barkley’s 38-yard touchdown, and there were a few other positive runs, but the ground game was often stuck in neutral. Mailata got beat by Alex Highsmith on an outside rush that resulted in a strip sack. Mailata was able to recover Milton’s fumble, though.
Markel Bell needed help vs. the dangerous Watt, but the edge rusher was held to no sacks. Left guard Dickerson and center Drew Kendall did better in setting protections vs. the blitz. Less under center, play-action plays helped their cause. Tyler Steen couldn’t maintain his run block and Barkley was dropped in the backfield in the red zone in the first quarter. The right guard appeared to struggle again when Watt split defenders and got to Barkley behind the line.
Defensive line: B+
Despite the trade of Jordan Davis to the Jacksonville Jaguars, the Eagles’ defense stifled one of the best run offenses in the league. Steelers running back Jaylen Warren, who entered with an NFL-best mark of 5.7 yards per carry, was held to just 1.7 yards on six rushes in the first half. Warren and backup Rico Dowdle were only marginally better in the second half.
The Eagles’ D-line led the way against the pass with five sacks of the increasingly statuesque Aaron Rodgers. Byron Young started at nose tackle with Davis gone. He thrived with more playing time. He had a run stop near the line and registered his first sack of the season when he ragdolled left guard Spencer Anderson on the way to Rodgers. Young picked up his second sack in the third quarter. Even defensive tackle Gabe Hall, who was called up from the practice squad for his first game of the season, got in on the sack party in the fourth quarter.
Jalen Carter was a last-second addition to the injury report with a quadriceps injury that he reported to the team on the ride to the stadium. He still played, although he wasn’t a standout. Carter stuffed Warren at the line early on. Moro Ojomo was relatively quiet, too. Edge Jonathan Greenard used his motor to bring down Rodgers with a third-down sack in the second quarter. Jalyx Hunt hurried Rodgers into an incompletion on an inside stunt in the first quarter. Nolan Smith Jr. was gifted an unblocked sack in the fourth quarter. Ty Robinson didn’t do much with more playing time.
Linebacker: B+
Jeremiah Trotter Jr. was at the center of the run defense’s strong performance. With Zack Baun (back) sidelined for the foreseeable future after being placed on injured reserve, Trotter called plays on defense. He came up with the stop on fourth-and-1 on the Steelers’ opening drive and made several more impressive stops vs. the run. Trotter led the Eagles with 13 tackles.
Jihaad Campbell was up and down in his return from injury. He dropped Warren in the backfield for a loss in the first quarter. Campbell kept a dump pass to no gain, but injured his left pinky finger on the play. He missed only a few plays when Anfernee Orji took his place. Campbell sniffed out a shovel pass inside the red zone before the half. But he let Dowdle bounce off him for a 10-yard run in the third quarter.
Cornerback: B
Quinyon Mitchell locked up receiver DK Metcalf on a fade pass into the end zone and later in the third quarter broke up a heave to the receiver in the back of the end zone. Mitchell got banged up in the fourth quarter and was replaced by Kelee Ringo. Ringo was in coverage when receiver Max Hurleman caught a late 20-yard touchdown.
Riq Woolen was pulled in the second quarter after he missed several tackle attempts. He got juked by a spin move on a screen pass and couldn’t wrap up on a dump pass later in the second quarter. Jonathan Jones took his spot and made a diving pass breakup at the goal line several plays later. He got burned by receiver Roman Wilson for a 33-yard catch in the third quarter. Woolen was back on the field in the fourth quarter after Jones got hurt.
Cooper DeJean might have gotten into Metcalf’s head after goading him into taking a personal foul in the third quarter. A few plays later, DeJean was in coverage when the receiver couldn’t pull in a quickie that would have converted a third down. And Metcalf was ejected from the game with another unsportsmanlike penalty when he stuck fingers into DeJean’s helmet a series later.
Safety: B
Andrew Mukuba had one of his better outings in what has been mostly a difficult second season. Rodgers was gun shy on deep routes, but partly because the safety and his counterparts kept the deep middle covered. Mukuba wasn’t perfect by any means. Hurleman converted third-and-3 with a 10-yard catch in front of him late in the third quarter and he dropped what should have been a game-ending interception.
Marcus Epps was the primary safety alongside Mukuba in nickel personnel for the second straight game. He read a screen pass and with good form dropped Dowdle in the backfield. Epps wasn’t fooled by a misdirection screen across the formation in the third quarter. Michael Carter II was the sixth defensive back in dime packages.
Special teams: A-
Michael Clay’s units turned the ball over once and committed several penalties, but overall they were sharp. The Steelers didn’t often have good starting field position because of Braden Mann’s punts and Jake Elliott’s kickoffs.
Mann more than flipped the field with a 70-yard punt that went out of bounds at the 4-yard line in the third quarter. Earlier, Mann boomed a 57-yard punt that yielded just a 9-yard return in the second quarter. Elliott nailed 55-, 53-, 41-, and 29-yard field goals and made his lone extra point attempt. He had two first-half kickoffs that gave Steelers returners issues. One dropped in the landing zone before rolling into the end zone for a touchback, while another knuckleball resulted in a short return.
Jaydon Blue fumbled the opening kickoff of the second half and was fortunate his defense mitigated the damage by forcing Pittsburgh to settle for a field goal. Britain Covey averaged 13.8 yards on four punt returns.
Coaching: B
After seven straight losses, Nick Sirianni’s Eagles finally got a win. It was a slog. The offense is still lacking explosion and cohesion. But the defense and special teams held up their ends, even if some fans would rather the Eagles lose out to improve their draft stock.
Sirianni’s questionable conservatism at the end of the first half showed little faith in his offense. Armed with three timeouts and a minute to go, the Eagles called three run plays, satisfied with a 13-3 lead at the break. Maybe there could have been a mistake there, but the Eagles came out and fumbled the ball on the ensuing kickoff after the break. On fourth-and-3 at the Pittsburgh 35, Sirianni had Elliott attempt a 53-yard field goal — that he would make ― rather than go for it. It ended up being the right decision in a three-point win.
Offensive coordinator Sean Mannion went away from the under-center stuff and had Milton more in the shotgun to pose a threat as a runner. There was marginal improvement. When Milton was under center, the Steelers were all over the Eagles. Mannion’s offense was good against the blitz on pass downs in the first half, with Milton completing all three of his attempts for 70 yards, per NextGen Stats.
Vic Fangio’s defense, despite not having two of their mainstays in the middle, played with great effort. Man coverage calls often gave Steelers receivers fits as Rodgers kept holding the ball and taking sacks. It was an impressive showing for Fangio’s group.

























