One of the few good things to come out of the extraordinary run of injuries along the Eagles’ offensive line this season has been the play of Nate Herbig, an undrafted second-year player who started the first eight games, five at left guard and three at right guard. Herbig played every snap, and showed a lot of raw power.
Herbig, 6-foot-4, 334, began the season as the replacement for Brandon Brooks (Achilles tear) on the right side, then went to the left when Isaac Seumalo suffered a knee injury, and offensive line coach Jeff Stoutland decided Herbig was more adaptable than Matt Pryor. Then Herbig went back to the right when Pryor missed a game because of COVID-19 quarantining. Stoutland praised Herbig’s willingness to move around as needed.
- Doug Pederson attempts to apportion Eagles blame generally, which is a lot like not apportioning it at all
- Doug Pederson says Jason Peters remains the Eagles’ starting left tackle; on blame, there’s ‘plenty to go around’
- Loss to the Browns is latest sign the Eagles’ arrogance is catching up to them | Mike Sielski
But Herbig did not start Nov. 15 against the Giants, and didn’t play any offensive snaps. The official word was that he had a finger injury, which NBC10 said affected his entire hand. Herbig did not appear on the injury report leading up to the game in Cleveland. He was inactive, on a day when the Eagles ended up using all nine active offensive linemen. Seumalo returned from his knee injury at left guard, and Pryor started at right guard. Sua Opeta was the top backup guard.
“There’s nothing more to it,” coach Doug Pederson said Monday. “Opeta has deserved the opportunity right now, and with Isaac coming back, it was just, we had all the offensive linemen available and we had to put a couple of guys down, inactive for the game. Herbie’s doing fine. ... Each week he’s competing for one of those backup spots right now, or potentially a starter spot, if there’s an injury.”
The news that Herbig isn’t considered one of the Eagles’ top five offensive linemen right now surprised observers, who haven’t seen Pryor do anything great, and haven’t seen Opeta do much at all. Pro Football Focus gives Herbig a 64.0 overall grade for the season, 64.1 in pass-blocking and 63.7 in run-blocking. Pryor’s grades are 55.9, 58.9, and 53.3, though he did grade out well at Cleveland -- 64.9, 67.2, 61.0. Opeta’s grades are 57.6, 52.7, and 57.9.
That Alex Singleton, waived six times in a journey that began in 2015 with Seattle, would end up becoming the Eagles’ best linebacker? That says a lot about Singleton’s determination. It says something less laudatory about the state of the Eagles’ roster.