Skip to content

Will the Eagles tank, and what would that mean for Nick Sirianni and Sean Mannion? | Best of unCovering the Birds

How do you evaluate the coach and offensive coordinator from a team that is trading stars and playing backups?

Now that the Eagles are back from the bye, how will they approach the rest of the season? There are still eight games to go, but at 2-7, the team is facing long playoff odds. The possibility of securing a prime spot in the draft becomes more of a reality with every loss. In the face of crippling injuries and a personnel shakeup, will Nick Sirianni be able to keep the Eagles together? What factors could determine whether the head coach, his staff, and players stay or go? The Inquirer’s Jeff McLane and Jeff Neiburg answer these questions and address other big picture issues as the Eagles get back to work following a week off.

Jeff Neiburg: This is a difficult spot for for [Sirianni] to be in, unless they’ve already made the decision [on retaining him] one way or the other, right? Because if they’re gonna look at these next eight weeks for data to say whether or not Nick deserves to be back next year, isn’t it kind of an impossible situation? Like, what does it mean [if] his job is to take a bad roster and make it not look as bad? What does it say about a coach because he made Joe Milton keep games close?

The state of the roster right now is so bad, and the state of the offense is so bad, that I think it’s even unfair to take too much data from what’s gonna transpire over the next eight weeks. Who gets graded on how the team looked with Joe Milton behind this offensive line? Who gets graded on how the defense looks when they just traded away the nose tackle [Jordan Davis] and they don’t have another one? Like the run defense is gonna be brutal, I think, over the next couple weeks.

There’s so many new factors here. And I’m not trying to cop out of the answer [about Sirianni’s job security]. I don’t have a real take on what this says about Nick’s job. My take is that if you haven’t made a decision one way or another yet, you’re doing yourself and him a disservice by by thinking that you’re gonna infer a lot and gain a lot of information from what happens over the next eight weeks, because so much of what happens on the field is probably out of Nick Sirianni’s control.

A) The players aren’t good enough, B) Players who aren’t gonna be back, what are the motivations of certain players? I’m not questioning anybody’s work ethic or effort or anything like that, but there’s a lot that’s gonna happen on the field that I think is out of Nick Sirianni’s control. And I don’t know that he should be back, I don’t know that he shouldn’t be back, but I just know that the next eight weeks is kind of like some of the most meaningless slop that Nick Sirianni’s ever gonna be coaching in his career. And it’s kind of like an unfair situation for him to be in.

Jeff McLane: Yeah, they’re making these moves, which aren’t going to help. You talk about motivation. Look, I’ve been around, I’ve seen teams enter this phase and it does affect them, whether they want to admit it or not. And I asked Nick Sirianni this question [Wednesday] about like, what’s your message to your players when you see two starters getting traded and you see veterans getting released?

It’s like, “Hey, we’re not giving up on the season.” They’re gonna say they’re not, but essentially they are giving up on the season in some regard. Certainly you gotta always be competitive and play hard, but that’s easier said than done. And I saw it in 2012, I saw it in 2015, and I saw it at times in 2020.

And it goes all the all the way back to those questions that were asked of Jason Kelce, a veteran captain on the team in 2020. It’s like, what about playing younger guys? And he’s just like, “I don’t believe in that.” You know, like I think you got to do whatever you can to win every week, each and every week, which is why when they did clearly try and tank that last game, he was — he may deny it now — but he was upset when they benched Jalen Hurts for Nate Sudfeld. If they had any chance to win, it was with Jalen Hurts at quarterback and they proceeded to lose that game.

What does that say? What are you telling? Do you want to have that type of culture, of accepting loss? And maybe that kind of comes off as too Pollyanna-esque. And I’m sure the large majority of fans are fully on board that they wanted to see more guys being dealt at the trade deadline. They probably want to see every young player play in these last eight games of the season. And you’ll probably see a little bit of that.

But to me, as someone who covers a team as a journalist, I don’t look at it from that point of view. And certainly we will start looking ahead to the future about the draft and what they may do. But to me it’s like, what does this say about this franchise? What does it say about the people in charge? What does it say about the players that are still here? And and we’ll find out something about them.

To me, when you bring in that type of thinking, it can kind of persist beyond just the last eight games of the season or even the last game of the 2020 season. They used that move-up in the draft essentially to get another pick. They probably still wouldn’t be able to get DeVonta Smith [with the original pick], but they used it obviously [to trade up], and Howie kept kind of duplicating what he could get.

» READ MORE: How Week 11 might impact where the Eagles pick in the draft; and sizing up who may be available to them

And maybe it had a lot to do with the turnaround, it had a lot to do with them eventually winning a Super Bowl. You can make that claim, certainly. But with all these draft picks, you still have to go out there and get the right guys. And Howie, to his credit, from 2021 to 2024 probably did as well as anybody in the draft. But these last two drafts have left a lot to be desired. And you’re just kind of naturally assuming just because he had done it before that he could do it again, maybe diminishing the fact that he had a lot to do with why this team is not thriving this year. Now certainly the injuries have played a part in that. We’ll see how the offense looks with DeVonta Smith and Dontayvion Wicks returning.

Nick Sirianni did say that Sean Mannion will remain the play-caller. Of course, he has said similar “truths” before and we found out later that isn’t the case. From what I understand Sean will remain the play-caller, so I take him on his word there. But maybe that’s the evaluation, Jeff, that we can look at here over these next several weeks, beyond just the players. It’s whether Sean Mannion can prove that he is an offensive coordinator, that if they do bring Nick Sirianni back, that they could bring Mannion back for another go-round in 2027.

What do you think? Do you think there’s any possible scenario in which Nick and Sean come back as the offensive minds of this team?

Neiburg: I mean, it seems like an impossible sell, right? But for the same reasons I said that Nick Sirianni’s in an unfair spot, if you are still thinking that Sean Mannion might be the coordinator next year, what kind of curve does he get graded on for what’s gonna happen in the next couple of weeks? That being said, A) it’s an unfair evaluation [but], B) there are some bad rosters in the NFL that at least move the ball a little bit. And this team hasn’t been able to do that, right?

The numbers are are so bad. They punt so much. I saw a list of the best kickers in the NFL yesterday. It was like 1 through 31. And Jake Elliott wasn’t on the list because it was a minimum of 10 field goal attempts. Like they just don’t even have the ball on the plus side of the field, right? So I feel two ways about it. I feel like if you’re still evaluating Sean, what are you gonna learn over the next eight weeks just because there’s Joe Milton — the fourth person to throw passes is throwing passes this week. He’s still the starter. There might be a world where they go back to Tanner McKee. There might be a world where they go to Cole Payton at some point, right? A first-time play-caller dealing with that type of quarterback situation, it’s not ideal. Dealing with his offensive line situation, it’s not ideal. So I feel that way about it. But I also feel like I’ve watched some pretty bad quarterbacks and some pretty pretty bad offenses over the last couple of years at least be able to move the ball a little bit.

» READ MORE: Eagles’ DeVonta Smith looks set to return from injury amid disappointing season

Maybe if you’re still evaluating Sean Mannion, let’s see if this team can look like it can move the ball a little bit. And maybe, an extra week with with Joe Milton and his mobility, maybe it’ll open up a little bit more for the offense. But obviously I’m not optimistic that’s going to happen. So how can you possibly bring back Sirianni and Mannion as the offensive minds. Doesn’t it seem impossible?

McLane: It does. And it also seems impossible to see Nick Sirianni standing up at the podium again, or along with Howie Roseman [at a news conference] saying, “Hey, yeah, you know, the offense didn’t work, the offensive coordinator didn’t work. Everything that we said, every reason that we had given this past offseason for changing the offense almost entirely didn’t work. And now we’re gonna go in this other direction.” I guess maybe the only way Nick could save himself is like, OK I’m just gonna take full control of this thing. I’m gonna call plays, it’s gonna be my scheme, I’m gonna run what I wanna run.

The Inquirer logo
Listen to the latest episode

Now that the Eagles are back from the bye, how will they approach the rest of the season? There are still eight games to go, but at 2-7, the team is facing long playoff odds. The possibility of securing a prime spot in the draft becomes more of a reality with every loss. In the face of crippling injuries and a personnel shakeup, will Nick Sirianni be able to keep the Eagles together? What factors could determine whether the head coach, his staff, and players stay or go? The Inquirer’s Jeff McLane and Jeff Neiburg answer these questions and address other big picture issues as the Eagles get back to work following a week off. Listen here.

Listen to all episodes here or wherever you get your podcasts.

Join The Conversation