With Democratic trifecta, Pa. legislators can reshape reproductive health policy
Lawmakers should seize the opportunity to build a system grounded not in political ideology, but in science, equity, and respect for people’s ability to make decisions about their own lives.

Sonya Borrero is a physician and health services researcher, Greer Donley is a professor of law, and Riley Steiner is a public health scientist, all with CONVERGE at the University of Pittsburgh.
Starting in January, the government in Pennsylvania will have a Democratic trifecta for the first time in over 30 years. This historic alignment presents a long-awaited opening to reshape reproductive health policy in the commonwealth. Gov. Josh Shapiro has already identified protecting abortion rights as a top priority for his first 100 days.
As reproductive health scholars and practitioners at the University of Pittsburgh, we see this as an extraordinary opportunity not only to protect abortion rights, but to fundamentally rethink how our laws support Pennsylvanians’ reproductive lives. We believe this moment calls for an agenda grounded in medical evidence, patient autonomy, and access for all.
We offer a path toward reproductive freedom which would begin with three essential actions:
Repeal the entirety of the antiquated and medically unjustified Pennsylvania Abortion Control Act
Codify comprehensive reproductive rights in statute and enact policies that expand access to reproductive healthcare
Amend the Pennsylvania Constitution to explicitly enshrine these rights for future generations
Repeal the Pennsylvania Abortion Control Act
Enacted over four decades ago with the stated aim of protecting women’s health, the Pennsylvania Abortion Control Act (PACA) functions to restrict access to abortion care, which we know is actually harmful. It mandates waiting periods and specific counseling, requires laboratory testing regardless of clinical need, imposes facility standards that are not always justified by clinical risk, bars many licensed healthcare providers from offering abortion care, requires parental consent for minors seeking abortion care, and prohibits abortion after 24 weeks of pregnancy.
Patient safety is not achieved by imposing the most stringent possible regulations. It is achieved by applying the right medical standards, grounded in evidence and proportionate to clinical risk.
The scientific evidence provides little justification for these requirements. In 2018, the prestigious National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine published a landmark review concluding that abortion is safe, serious complications are rare, and medically unnecessary restrictions can undermine the quality and timeliness of care. Moreover, such restrictions disproportionately affect people with fewer financial resources, those living in rural communities, and those already facing inequities in healthcare access, like young people.
Patient safety is not achieved by imposing the most stringent possible regulations. It is achieved by applying appropriate medical standards, grounded in evidence and proportionate to clinical risk. Repealing PACA would allow Pennsylvania to regulate abortion according to the same principles of quality, safety, informed consent, and professional accountability that govern other medical care. The legislature should also review and repeal other Pennsylvania laws, like facility requirements, that impose medically unjustified restrictions or create unnecessary barriers to reproductive healthcare, bringing the commonwealth’s policies into alignment with current medical evidence and professional standards.
Repealing these laws that create barriers to access is foundational and must complement efforts to explicitly give Pennsylvanians the right to reproductive autonomy. Without doing so, any rights established cannot be fully realized.
Importantly, these actions would be aligned with what Pennsylvanians say they want. Forthcoming findings from a statewide survey conducted by the PA Catalyst team at CONVERGE indicate that the majority of Pennsylvanians want the commonwealth to have laws and policies that make it easier to get abortion care.
Codify reproductive rights
Second, the legislature should pass new laws that comprehensively codify reproductive rights in state law and make it easier for Pennsylvania’s to actualize their rights. Protecting abortion access is essential, but reproductive freedom encompasses far more than the ability to end a pregnancy. It also includes the ability to prevent pregnancy, pursue pregnancy and parenthood, and receive high-quality care throughout pregnancy and childbirth and the postpartum period.
As such, a comprehensive reproductive rights package should protect access to contraception, abortion, miscarriage management, fertility care, and pregnancy care, while safeguarding individuals from coercion and discrimination in reproductive healthcare.
These protections must extend to everyone, including adolescents and people seeking care later in pregnancy. The legislature should resist the temptation to carve out exceptions that undermine the very rights it seeks to establish. Research from PA Catalyst suggests that such restrictions are not essential to securing public support for reproductive rights.
Beyond codifying rights, it is imperative that the legislature also pass policies that support people’s ability to make and effectuate reproductive decisions. Many states have already taken steps to strengthen contraceptive access, but Pennsylvania has lagged behind and is now a regional outlier. Catching up would mean mandating contraceptive coverage, including for extended contraceptive supplies and over-the-counter methods at the point of sale, to eliminate out-of-pocket costs as well as allowing pharmacists to prescribe contraception. To ensure access to abortion, Pennsylvania should follow Illinois’ lead and allow presumptive eligibility for pregnancy-related Medicaid to include abortion care.
To truly protect reproductive autonomy, Pennsylvania must also support pregnancy and parenthood for Pennsylvanians. For instance, the state could expand insurance coverage for infertility treatment and fertility preservation and must continue to invest in equitable maternal healthcare, including efforts to reduce maternal mortality.
These are not separate or competing priorities. They reflect a common principle: People should have the freedom, resources, and medical care necessary to make unconstrained decisions about their reproductive lives and pursue their own goals.
Amend constitution
Third, the legislature should simultaneously start the process of amending the Pennsylvania Constitution to explicitly protect these same reproductive freedoms. Though it might seem redundant to pursue both statutory and constitutional paths to protect reproductive rights, both are essential. Codification ensures that the rights begin immediately. But statutory rights can be repealed by a future legislature. And recent victories in the state Supreme Court could shift if judicial elections start to favor conservative judges.
To get a reproductive freedom amendment on our statewide ballot, the legislature would need to pass the proposed amendment in two successive legislative sessions. Beginning that process now would put Pennsylvanians on a path toward more enduring protections.
Gov. Shapiro and the General Assembly have an extraordinary opportunity to make Pennsylvania a national leader in reproductive freedom. They should seize this moment to build a system grounded not in political ideology, but in science, equity, and respect for people’s ability to make decisions about their own lives.
About guest essays
Guest essays, or op-eds, are commentary pieces that present the opinion or perspective of the author. Many are submitted to us by Inquirer readers and writers with insight on the news, but we also solicit op-eds from authors on specific topics. For more information visit our guidelines.

Inquirer Opinion Newsletter
























