Skip to content

Mayer’s Tavern

Seafood, Gastropub$-$$

Once a rough and tumble Shore bar, Mayer’s Tavern has become a refreshing and friendly gastropub with a spacious outdoor patio and a menu offering smoked bluefish, fried scallops, crab fritters, and, according to critic Craig LaBan, “some of the best house-made french fries you’ll ever experience.” He continues, “The dish I can’t stop thinking about is the most perfect roast chicken, a breast that gets marinated in seasoned yogurt before it’s cooked to a tawny crisp and served over arbol chile-braised collard greens and polenta.”

How we choose our best lists

The Inquirer aims to represent the geographic, cultural, and culinary diversity of the region in its coverage. Inquirer staffers and contributors do not accept free or comped meals — all meals are paid for by the Inquirer. All dining recommendations are made solely by the Inquirer editorial staffers and contributors based on their reporting and expertise, without input from advertisers or outside interests.

Restaurant Details

894 3rd Ave., Cape May, NJ, 08204
6094355078
https://www.mayerstavern.com/
mayerstavern
Doesn't take reservations