

I’m a big believer in Pranksgiving, but my new boyfriend thinks it's too mean
his week’s question (Have your own? Submit it here.):
So I’m a big believer in Pranksgiving. Every year I do a very minor prank like saying I burned all the rolls so handing out saltines instead or pouring the wine but it’s really grape juice with vodka (I put it in a bottle and everything and my mom didn’t notice) or when it was my turn to say what I’m thankful for I read the Bill of Rights (until I was shouted at to stop).
Mostly when I do these there is some brief annoyance or anguish followed by hours of laughing. I think it’s great. But! My boyfriend, who’s coming for the first time this year, is uncomfortable with it and thinks it might be too mean (it’s not). What do you think?
Jason Nark, Life & Culture reporter
I love Thanksgiving. It was, for a very long time, my favorite holiday. I’m all for traditions and I’ve been a prankster my entire life too.
I don’t love this particular prank tradition, to be honest, but if it’s long-established, then your boyfriend needs to zip it. I’m surprised a boyfriend who’s visiting a family for the first time would even chime in on that.
Stephanie Farr, features columnist
I’ve never heard of Pranksgiving so just dropping that portmanteau on us like it’s an established thing was a move. My immediate reaction before I even read the rest of the question was “Oh hell no.”
The Thanksgiving dinner table can already be a tinderbox for family drama. There’s no need to play with fire around it. I’m siding with the boyfriend.
Jason Nark
Yeah, you said some people were in “anguish” so that may be a clue to bid farewell.
Stephanie Farr
It sounds like it kind of ticks her family off but then they try and play it off later, probably to not make her feel bad. The saltines and the Bill of Rights reading aren’t that awful but switching the wine with grape juice and vodka is a level of evil I can’t comprehend.
Jason Nark
I did attend a Thanksgiving once where the family played “things we hate about each other” after dinner. It was disastrous and I was a little shocked, but I grew to love them all.
Stephanie Farr
Wow, that sounds awful, why would anyone do that?!
Jason Nark
Great question.
As someone who’s a bit immature and a fan of dumb humor, even I have come to understand that pranks are overrated and the victims are never crazy about it.
Stephanie Farr
Yeah, nobody likes to feel like the butt of a joke, especially in a group setting. If my 5-year-old nephew is pulling pranks, that’s one thing, but a grown adult doing it just feels awkward.
A first Thanksgiving with a significant other’s family can be awkward enough, and the boyfriend is already probably dreading it, so I can totally understand his request. He’s also (probably) missing out on Thanksgiving with his family to join his partner, so I think she should honor his request.
Jason Nark
You may have convinced me, Stephanie. The boyfriend is showing a little empathy here by considering the feelings of everyone there, so maybe she should listen.
The really immature thing, though, would be to pull the prank on him.
Stephanie Farr
Ha ha! Only if she doesn’t want a boyfriend anymore. I was just thinking, what should actually happen is the boyfriend should secretly reach out to his partner’s family and they should scheme together to turn the tables and play a prank on the prankster this Thanksgiving.
Jason Nark
Yes, even better.
I would like to know how old this would-be prankster is and if she’s contemplated, at all, how long she’ll keep doing this.
Stephanie Farr
Whatever the answer, I think it’s time for a new tradition.

