President Trump’s social media pardon of Pete Rose raises questions worth asking
What is a “Complete and Total pardon?” What is he pardoned for? And why now? The questions that really matter are often the ones we would’ve been asking if not for the distraction.

As the dutiful sports columnist working the night shift when President Donald Trump announced he had pardoned Pete Rose, I have been told that it is my place to respond. It is a difficult task. The most pertinent response would require breaking the third wall. It would investigate the merits of lending credence to an issue that exists solely to provoke a response. In short, it would require way too many words, all of which have probably been written.
My general operating procedure is to treat the things that the President of the United States says with as much gravity as he himself treats them. Often times, that means treating them superfluously. Words needn’t always be words in the traditional sense, i.e. symbolized thought. Sometimes, they are just inhaled air that the vocal cords eject from the body via the mouth.
There’s something worth remembering whenever the POTUS says or does something that, in a normal world, would warrant a response. Our world is one in which the POTUS is Trump. That’s not to say that every Truth Social post is authored without the careful deliberation commensurate with the power and gravity of the office. But some of them aren’t, it seems more likely than not. And so we must take a critical eye.
The first thing I do is look at all the other things that the president has said or done immediately after the thing in question. In this case, Trump’s Truth Social post granting a “Complete and Total pardon” to Rose was quickly buried under a flurry of posts that included two video clips headlined “Biden’s Border Invasion is Almost Complete” and a screenshot of a post from Laura Loomer, a far right influencer who has recently come under fire for accepting undisclosed payments for her political posts.
“I have just given a Complete and Total Pardon to the Late, Great Pete Rose, a true Baseball SUPERSTAR & LEGEND, whose record of 4,256 Hits in a Season will never be broken,” Trump wrote, a few hours after he sent out pictures of his remodeled front office and later offered congratulations to the Anderson University Women’s Volleyball Team on winning the South Atlantic Conference.
Another helpful thing is to look at the substance of the post. Does the material in question suggest some level of forethought and diligence on behalf of its author? Does it warrant careful consideration? Does it prompt a reckoning that attempts to balance Rose’s disgraceful post-playing career with his unparalleled ability to hit a baseball with a bat? Do we meditate on society’s permissive infatuation with anybody who possesses Rose’s skills?
A few notes.
Rose does not actually hold MLB’s single season record for hits.
That single season record — Ichiro Suzuki’s, not Rose’s — is nowhere close to 4,256 hits.
Rose did set MLB’s career record with 4,256 hits, an error later corrected in the Truth Social post.
Details aside, Trump’s post raises a number of substantive questions.
What differentiates a “Complete and Total pardon” from the standard presidential pardon? Are there two files? If so, are there separate files for “Complete” pardons and “Total” pardons? Or is it like a square and a rectangle?

David Murphy alerts
Then there is the biggest question of all.
For what offense is Trump completely and totally pardoning Rose?
The Truth Social post makes no mention of a crime. In 1990, Rose pleaded guilty to two counts of filing false federal income tax returns for failing to report income from autograph signings, memorabilia sales and gambling winnings. But baseball didn’t ban Rose because he didn’t pay taxes on his gambling winnings. And MLB reinstated him well before Thursday’s pardon announcement.
Rose never faced criminal charges for a woman’s allegation that he had sex with her when she was a minor during his career with the Reds. Trump certainly didn’t pardon Rose for being snippy with an Inquirer reporter who asked him about the allegations at a 2022 ceremony honoring the Phillies’ 1980 World Series championship team. Even if we are to believe that Rose’s pardon was complete and total in the most literal and omnipotent sense, why did Trump wait until two years after Rose died at 83 years old? Might’ve it come in handy at the pearly gates?
These probably seem like rhetorical questions. That makes them worth asking. They can remind us of the questions that actually matter. Often, they are the ones we’d be asking if not for the distraction.
























