Skip to content

Garden war: Green alums ask Penn to fight Drexel growth plan

Drexel: Garden 'no longer safe'

A classic University City tale (or any Collegetown USA): Four Penn grads (Class of 2010) are collecting alumni siguatures asking Penn President Amy Gutmann to intervene against proposed land use changes at neighboring Drexel. Some of the Penn gardeners have also founded a Facebook group: "UCHS Garden is Sacred, Parking Lots are not." They say Drexel wants to replace the mini-farm adjoining the former University City High School with "a parking lot."

Drexel, which paid the School DIstrict $15 million for the larger school property, has high-rise ambitions for the site and its whole neighborhood as President John Fry seeks to boost enrollment by one-third and lure corporate employers. The plans, the college says, don't include paving over the gardens. But Drexel also says "it will no longer be safe to have a garden," at least during planned construction. Read from the grads' letter to Gutmann, then Drexel's response; emphases added:

As Penn alumni involved with the Agatston Urban Nutrition Initiative (AUNI) and the Netter Center for Community Partnerships, we are concerned about Drexel University's redevelopment plans for University City High School (UCHS). We are dismayed to learn that AUNI's UCHS garden, an award-winning urban farm located on the UCHS campus, will soon be demolished. This garden symbolizes so much that we love about Penn and the time that we spent in West Philadelphia...

The Class of 1970 made a significant reunion gift to enhance it. Millions of dollars have been raised and invested to develop the garden as a cornerstone of Penn's partnership with West Philadelphia... Founded in 2000, the UCHS garden is Philadelphia's oldest operating youth-run market garden. It was named best youth garden by the Philadelphia Horticultural Society eight times between 2003 and 2011, and has provided year-round part-time jobs and mentorship for hundreds of high school students....

The garden produces about two tons of fruit and vegetables annually, 10% of which is donated to local communities and 25% of which is sold to low-income Philadelphians...  Perhaps most significantly, the garden commemorates the Black Bottom, a neighborhood displaced by Penn's northern expansion in the late 1960s...

We are all proud to have been involved with the UCHS garden and we remain connected to it both personally and professionally. We believe that the garden can continue to be a model site for innovative community partnership. We ask that the Penn administration do all that it can to protect the garden so that it can enrich our community for years to come. Thank you very much for your time and consideration.

I ran that by Drexel spokesman Niki Gianarakis. Drexel's response:

Drexel University entered into a partnership with Wexford Science & Technology, LCC, to purchase the former University City High School and Drew School property in order to the transform the site with a potential K-8 public school, as well as residential, retail, and office space. The development aligns with the University's commitment to serve as an engine for economic growth and development in West Philadelphia and its desire to improve public education in the surrounding neighborhoods.

Redevelopment of the University City High School and Drew School buildings will include environmental remediation of the entire site including the area occupied by the University of Pennsylvania Agatston Urban Nutrition Initiative (AUNI) garden. It will no longer be safe to have a garden on the site during the remediation.

Echoing the Penn grads, Drexel admitted: Over the years, the garden has been a valuable and community-building resource in this community, and has come to symbolize the spirit of the former Black Bottom community. Although: Plans for the former school parcel are still in development and do not include replacing the current garden with a parking lot.

There will be a community advisory group that will work with Drexel and Wexford as the planning for this site proceeds. This will be the appropriate forum to consider ways to continue to honor the Black Bottom, and the legacy of this garden.

So: An 'engine for economic growth' with offices, labs, homes or dorms? Or the survival of an "innovative community partnership" growing 4,000 pounds of produce a year, neighborhood connections and alumni nostalgia? Once it's built, will the sun still reach the ground enough hours to add calories? What's the highest and best use, planners?