Skip to content

Fund guru Bogle talks like Occupy, but he's no radical

"The most effective marketer in the business" has another book

"Sixteen years after he stepped down as chief executive of Vanguard Group to fix his ailing heart, John C. Bogle remains the investment company's ardent cheerleader, a plainspoken advocate of the old virtues of thrift and probity, a blunt critic of financial-industry aggrandizement - and the most effective marketer in the business," I note in this Inquirer review of his new book, Clash of the Cultures. 
Some highlights: The title "conjures thoughts of world war and social strife. But he's talking about 'investment vs. speculation,' two words that to most Americans, who either own no stocks or bonds or have only very small shares in their employers' retirement plans, sound like the same thing."
He's actually distinguishing between long-term and short-term holdings. "In Bogle's approach, investment is sane, virtuous, and leads to reasonable, positive results from companies that make market-useful products. Speculation is cynical, wasteful, alienating, and feeds the rip-off artists who now manage most Wall Street machinery, ignoring its original but all-too-rare function of raising capital for productive (which, to Bogle, means nonfinancial) businesses.
"Bogle calls for private-equity manager fees to be taxed at the (higher) rates levied on ordinary income. He backs a 'Tobin tax' on financial transactions that would presumably push American business away from wasteful money-chasing-money deals toward productive investments in factories, mines, tech centers, and other physical assets.
"These are bold ideas that play well in middle America. But you won't hear them much from Democrats or Republicans, especially in this election year, when they're working Wall Street bosses, bankers, and traders to pay for advertising... 
"Despite those radical touches, Bogle's message is conservative: As an amateur, you can't know enough to pick your own investments, and you can't trust any of those for-profit sharks to do it for you, so trust your money to Vanguard. Our record won't be better than average - no one's can be, except by temporary luck - and we will trim your gains with our fees, but not as much as the others would. And you'll still pay us, because you want to collect money without working, so you have to invest it somewhere...

"Bogle doesn't really want to overthrow the system; it's enough for him to be able to plausibly argue that Vanguard's version is simpler and more cost-efficient."

.