Skip to content

Pa. now probing a GOP database

House leaders said it served constituents, not campaigns.

HARRISBURG - A grand jury is examining whether House Republican leaders improperly used a $9 million taxpayer-funded database to improve their chances of winning elections, The Inquirer has learned.

The database, developed by GCR & Associates under a contract signed in 2002 by then-Majority Leader John M. Perzel (R., Phila.), is built on a technique called data mining to create detailed profiles of individuals, which helps lawmakers better tailor messages to constituents.

The state Attorney General's Office is scrutinizing use of the GCR database as part of its expanding Bonusgate probe, which is now focusing on whether lawmakers from both parties misused taxpayer-funded technology.

While lawmakers for years have used state discretionary accounts to improve technology in their legislative caucuses, it is illegal to use public money or resources for campaigns.

Walter Cohen, a Harrisburg lawyer who represents Perzel, said Friday that state investigators were questioning the GCR work as part of a broader review of technology contracts of both parties in the House and Senate.

In an interview Friday, Perzel said neither he nor anyone else in his office had ever used the publicly financed GCR database for campaigns.

Perzel also defended his hiring of GCR, saying it was necessary to modernize constituent services. If a constituent calls with a request, the information is entered and tracked over time, he said.

"You can do an index-card file or you can do it through a computer," said Perzel, who is well-known in Harrisburg as a technology junkie.

House Minority Leader Sam Smith also said that the database had never been used for political purposes, and that it served a legitimate government function.

"The cost concerned me, but it was my judgment that it was a worthy project," said Smith (R., Jefferson), who signed off on later versions of the contract but severely scaled it back in 2007.

In July, Attorney General Tom Corbett charged 12 former and current House Democratic legislators and staffers with participating in a massive conspiracy to award taxpayer-funded bonuses to legislative staff who did campaign work. Since then, the grand-jury probe has widened to include the House Republican caucus. No Republican has been charged.

Kevin Harley, Corbett's press secretary, declined to discuss GCR or any other aspects of the investigation, citing grand-jury secrecy rules.

Companies, particularly manufacturers, have long used data-mining to maximize the effectiveness of their advertising and marketing dollars. The practice uses complex algorithms to search large amounts of data - as varied as motor-vehicle records and credit-card purchases - for buying and shopping patterns.

National political parties have also invested heavily in data mining, believing it can help isolate their strengths and weaknesses with voters.

GCR, based in New Orleans, describes itself as a full-service consulting firm that provides clients with a range of services that include urban planning and election campaigns. According to its Web site, it develops "Web-based tools to transform voter registration records, election information, and precinct geography into a robust set of applications to assist candidates, election officials/agencies, and the media in their understanding and analysis of elections."

Records show the company's work for House Republicans dates to January 2002. In that year - when all House seats were on the ballot - the caucus paid GCR more than $2.5 million, according to state Treasury Department documents.

That contract, signed by Perzel when he was majority leader, called for GCR to develop a database that would mine data including "voter registration information, voting history, and voting effectiveness for all registered voters within each district."

In addition, GCR would work with phone vendors "to target desired voters and add supplemental demographic information." Other sources to be mined, the contract states, were Census Bureau data and lists provided by a variety of companies. The contract also required GCR not to provide the same or similar services to other legislative caucuses in Pennsylvania.

After 2002, the caucus continued to pay the company as much as $120,000 monthly, until spring 2007, soon after the Bonusgate investigation became public. At that time, Smith, the House Republican leader, authorized a new contract that reduced payments to about $35,000 monthly to maintain the database.

That contract is to expire at the end of this month, and Smith said it was unclear whether it would be renewed.

Simultaneously, GCR has worked for the House Republican Campaign Committee - the campaign arm of the caucus - and Perzel's reelection fund. Since 2003, the two committees paid GCR a total of $110,311 for "database maintenance" and "communications," according to state campaign-expense reports.

Al Bowman, spokesman for the House Republican Campaign Committee, declined to discuss what GCR did for the committee.

Perzel said last week that his campaign account separately spent tens of thousands of dollars on technology, and not just on GCR's services, making his political machine one of the most sophisticated in the state.

"Why would he spend all that kind of money if he could get the information without having to spend his campaign dollars?" asked Cohen, his lawyer, who was Pennsylvania's acting attorney general in 1995.

Calls last week to Gregory C. Rigamer, the company's chief executive officer, who signed the contract with House Republicans, were not returned.

The contract also required GCR to collaborate with another technology company, Aristotle Inc. of Washington, D.C. Over the summer, investigators and the grand jury began asking questions about Aristotle, which has been paid nearly $2 million by House Republicans for work on a similar project, according to sources familiar with the probe.

One of those sources said there was no comparison between the scope of work by the two companies, adding that "GCR is like Aristotle on steroids."

One section of the Aristotle contract called for the company to provide updated address lists "so that all districts will be properly loaded and ready for use in the elections."

Last year, Smith revised the Aristotle contract and eliminated large portions of the firm's responsibilities.

Investigators have also scrutinized whether House Democrats used a different taxpayer-funded database for political purposes.

Contact staff writer Mario F. Cattabiani at 717-787-5990 or mcattabiani@phillynews.com.