N.J releases new school performance reports
The New Jersey Department of Education released a new performance report Wednesday that contains more data and analysis than the former school report card. But it has officials from some districts concerned about how they are being compared with other public schools statewide.
The New Jersey Department of Education released a new performance report Wednesday that contains more data and analysis than the former school report card. But it has officials from some districts concerned about how they are being compared with other public schools statewide.
In addition to the staple data such as demographics, graduation rates, and standardized test scores, the new reports for the 2011-12 school year now compare peer groups, note chronic absenteeism, and track postgraduation education.
"We hope this data will help schools and stakeholders engage in local goal setting and improvement to help all students graduate from high school ready for college and career," state Education Commissioner Chris Cerf said in a statement.
One of the new features - the peer grouping - bundles schools into groups of about 30 that have similar demographics measured by the free and reduced lunch, limited English proficiency, and special education programs. Schools also are compared with all schools statewide.
The idea was to help identify strengths and areas for improvement, according to state officials. But some school officials raised concerns about how the peer groups were formed.
"We still have a lot of questions" on the peer groups, said Lenape Regional High School District Superintendent Carol Birnbohm, adding that the state sent her additional information to review.
Among Lenape High's "peers" were Cherry Hill West, which has double the percentage of students in the free or reduced lunch program, and Audubon High School, where 21 percent of the students require special ed compared with Lenape's 13 percent.
Susan Bastnagel, spokeswoman for the Cherry Hill School District, said district administrators there were "a little uncertain about the peer groups that they've established for each school," specifically for the district's two high schools.
Cherry Hill West has a higher percentage of students enrolled in free or reduced lunch programs - 25.6 percent - than any other school in its peer group.
At East, only 10.6 percent of students are enrolled in free and reduced lunch, and yet some of the same schools that are in West's peer group are in East's peer group, Bastnagel said. She also pointed to variations in the percentage of special education students at the schools.
Camden High School was grouped with Met East High School, a district magnet school, a few charter schools in the city and in Newark, and some Newark high schools, among others. However, Woodrow Wilson, which has similar test scores to Camden High and one of the state's worst graduation rates, was paired with Lindenwold High and Pennsauken High School, both in Camden County, and a couple of East Orange schools.
The new performance reports highlight Camden schools' lack of progress, which already had been noted in the state's takeover plan, announced last month.
The state Department of Education mentioned Camden's graduation rate of 49 percent, compared with 56 percent the year before. It also stated that on the 2012 HSPA Language Arts Literacy assessment, only 62 percent of students tested proficient, and in the math assessment only 28 percent tested as proficient.
The new report showed individual schools' scores, some of which had even lower numbers. At Woodrow Wilson High School, only 24 percent of students tested proficient in Language Arts Literacy and only 18 percent tested proficient in math.
"These reports again illustrate that there is a great deal of work to do in order to ensure every child in Camden has access to a high-quality education," said Education Department spokeswoman Barbara Morgan. "We look forward to working with Camden community members and educators to deliver on that promise to the city's children."
Camden's interim superintendent, Reuben Mills, did not return calls seeking comment.
As part of the state takeover of the district, Cerf will appoint a new superintendent, as well as reorganize and replace top administration positions.
Camden will become the fourth urban district under state control, after Paterson, Newark, and Jersey City. The takeover is expected to be fully implemented by the start of the next school year.
The performance reports also added data on postsecondary enrollment, which was collected by the National Student Clearinghouse. The data measured the percentage of students who graduated from high school in 2011 and were enrolled in a postsecondary institution 16 months later.
Statewide, 62 percent of students were enrolled in postsecondary institutions during the measured time.
The increase in data and descriptive analysis is "an improvement," from previous state performance reports, said Lenape's Birnbohm.
"It's very good data," she said. "I see this as a starting point" for discussion on why certain data is collected for these reports.
Contact Claudia Vargas
at 856-779-3917, cvargas@phillynews.com, or on Twitter @InqCVargas. Read her blog, "Camden Flow," at www.philly.com/camden_flow.
Staff writer Maddie Hanna contributed to this report.
























