Skip to content

Springtime for schools? Better check the forecast

Mayoral candidates and Gov. Wolf seek better public schools. But policies already in place show a pattern that’s somewhat less than promising.

HAPPY Easter Monday and welcome to the season of renewal.

Feel it in the air?

There's a mayor's race with its wafting aroma of fresh ideas and promises of new strides for the city, especially in public schools.

There's a "fresh-start" governor in Harrisburg with bold state plans to invest new money, especially in public schools.

There's . . . oh, wait, what am I thinking? Who sees schools on the brink of a blossoming rebirth fed and watered with fresh ideas and new money?

No? Then how about a swig of stale reality?

Most of those mayoral ideas - work better with Harrisburg, sue Harrisburg, get nonprofits to pony up, change city tax structure - aren't new.

Many rely on Harrisburg. Some require the Legislature to amend the Constitution.

And that's problematic.

Every sensate Philadelphian knows how Harrisburg feels about Philly: an abyss of abuse, a well of waste, a chasm of corruption, etc.

(Ironically, these are phrases I've used to describe Harrisburg.)

And the "fresh start" promised by Gov. Wolf is, at best, an engine in idle awaiting a Republican rebuild to significantly cut its purported power.

Rebirth?

Philly schools are always in trouble. Harrisburg's always Harrisburg.

Pennsylvania, you may know, is one of only three states without a formula for school funding based on actual conditions in districts, such as high poverty.

The other two are Delaware and North Carolina.

Guess who suffers because of this? If you guessed Philly, you guessed right.

A state commission is working on a formula due in June. But who knows what it looks like, if it's done on time and whether the Legislature ever approves it?

Meanwhile, funding fights focus on "a statewide crisis" and how much money's enough; and there is data supporting almost any case one wants to make.

For example:

To counter the argument of a statewide crisis, there's a 2015 report from 24/7 Wall St., an online financial news service, using Education Week's measurements of schools by state based on finances and K-12 achievement.

It rates Pennsylvania the eighth-best state for schools; 11th in overall per-pupil spending; seventh in graduation rates; sixth in math and reading test scores.

To counter that argument, the National Education Association, the teachers union, puts Pennsylvania near the bottom of states (39th) in percentage of state spending for K-12 at 39.2 percent.

There's more.

For those who say that Philly gets enough from Harrisburg, a 2015 report from Pew Trusts notes that city schools get 46 percent of their funding from the state.

That's above the national and state average and, according to Pew, a higher percentage of state funding than in several other large urban districts such as New York, Dallas and Chicago.

Ah, but wait.

For those seeking more aid in Philly, there's the disparity argument - or, as I like to call it, where we show our true colors.

The National Center for Education Statistics reports that Pennsylvania leads all states in the gap in per-pupil spending between poor and wealthy districts.

This is with local and state money, where disparity gaps are common.

But the national average disparity is 15.6 percent. In Pennsylvania, it's more than double that, 33.5 percent. No other state comes close.

Even when you add federal funding to the mix, we still have double-digit disparity. And we're one of only five states, along with Vermont, Virginia, Nevada and New York, with a disparity after federal funds are included.

Know where there's no gap, where more is spent per pupil in poorer districts (from local, state and federal sources)?

Everywhere else: blue states such as Massachusetts, red states such as Mississippi, big states such as Texas, small states such as North Dakota and a neighbor of ours - (wait for it . . . ) New Jersey.

So, let's review.

Statewide, schools aren't so bad, but state spending isn't so good.

Philly gets lots of state money but suffers on the disparity scale.

Although most states see the innate inequity of spending based on ZIP codes, our state does not.

And so, as Pew found, the Philadelphia School District gets less per pupil from local, state and federal sources than comparative districts across America.

Seem fair? Seem like our elected officials carefully craft funding plans to best serve all of Pennsylvania?

Or more like taxpayer-financed, government-supported segregation, the end result of policy blind to reality?

There's one certainty. Springtime for public schools isn't coming - no matter who's mayor, no matter who's governor - until reality is faced.

Blog: ph.ly/BaerGrowls

Columns: ph.ly/JohnBaer