Skip to content

Villanova’s playoff hopes in jeopardy after its overtime loss to Holy Cross

Saturday’s 30-27 loss to Holy Cross made it nearly impossible for Villanova to win the Patriot League title, but the Wildcats still have an outside chance to earn an at-large bid to the FCS playoffs.

Villanova quarterback Pat McQuaide threw two touchdowns and three interceptions on Saturday.
Villanova quarterback Pat McQuaide threw two touchdowns and three interceptions on Saturday.Read moreYong Kim / Staff Photographer

Villanova visited Holy Cross on Saturday in Worcester, Mass., knowing it was a must-win matchup.

And despite a comeback that forced overtime, the Wildcats fell, 30-27, to the Crusaders, which moved Holy Cross into second place in the Patriot League and ended Villanova’s hopes of winning a conference title. At 6-5 overall, 5-3 in league games, the Wildcats are two games behind league-leading Lehigh (9-2, 7-1) with one game left.

The Wildcats were unable to find the end zone after getting the ball first in extra time and settled for a 38-yard field goal on fourth-and-18. Holy Cross running back Jake Croce then punched it in for the winning touchdown on third-and-goal from the 1.

» READ MORE: Pat McQuaide has Villanova in the Patriot League title hunt after a rough start. Holy Cross is up next.

Villanova struggled with consistency on offense, especially on the ground. The Wildcats rushed for 48 yards, their lowest total this season.

Pat McQuaide threw for just 71 yards in the first half before unleashing 342 passing yards in the second and overtime. The sixth-year quarterback completed 33 of 58 attempts. He threw two touchdowns and three interceptions, tying his season high in picks from the opener against William & Mary.

While the offense was finding its footing late in the game, the Wildcats went 2-for-15 on third down, only converting their first early in the fourth quarter.

It was also a tale of two halves for Villanova’s defense. The unit allowed 196 yards and three touchdowns in the first. After halftime, the defense flipped a switch and held the Crusaders’ offense to 72 yards before allowing the game-winning score in overtime.

Playoff picture

Saturday’s loss put the Wildcats’ playoff hopes in jeopardy, as Holy Cross dropped Villanova to third place.

Holy Cross now holds the tiebreaker over Villanova, but Lehigh sits in first place. The 8-2 Mountain Hawks defeated the 6-5 Crusaders in the season opener but also lost to Villanova.

Regardless, Saturday’s loss has made it impossible for Villanova to win the automatic qualifier for winning the Patriot League.

The Wildcats still have a chance to earn an at-large bid to the FCS playoffs, but next Saturday’s clash with Georgetown is an absolute must-win.

Turnovers doom Wildcats

Villanova hasn’t lost a turnover battle since its September loss to Colgate. The early-season problem showed up against the Crusaders.

Isaiah Ragland fumbled with under a minute left in the second quarter, contributing to the Wildcats trailing by 14 points entering the half.

In the second half, McQuaide threw three interceptions. His second was costly, as it went right into the hands of Crusader cornerback Anthony Redfern, who returned it back 65 yards to set up a Holy Cross field goal, their last score in regulation.

» READ MORE: Nick Gaynor first ‘hit it off’ with the future pope in 2023. The Villanovans recently reunited in Rome.

Up next

Villanova will head home for their regular-season finale against Georgetown (3-6, 3-4 Patriot League) next Saturday (1 p.m., ESPN+). The Hoyas are coming off consecutive losses to Holy Cross and Fordham.

It has been 76 years since these two programs played, with the Wildcats winning 20-14 over the Hoyas on Oct. 28, 1950. Villanova is 7-3 all-time against Georgetown.

Join The Conversation