Skip to content
The exterior of the Sergeantsville Inn on Thursday, March 20, 2025 in Sergeantsville, NJ.
The exterior of the Sergeantsville Inn on Thursday, March 20, 2025 in Sergeantsville, NJ.Read moreMonica Herndon / Staff Photographer

Sergeantsville Inn

Hunterdon CountyAmerican, Modern American$$-$$$

The Sergeantsville Inn in Hunterdon County offers a cozy, historic setting with a menu focused on thoughtfully prepared meats and seasonal ingredients. Steaks are a highlight here, especially the dry-aged NY strip served with house frites and a green peppercorn sauce. The wine list is also well-curated, making it a good fit for casual dinners and those looking for a more indulgent meal.

How we choose our best lists

The Inquirer aims to represent the geographic, cultural, and culinary diversity of the region in its coverage. Inquirer staffers and contributors do not accept free or comped meals — all meals are paid for by the Inquirer. All dining recommendations are made solely by the Inquirer editorial staffers and contributors based on their reporting and expertise, without input from advertisers or outside interests.