Skip to content

Bankers out: More turnover at Janney (UPDATES)

New analysts soon, after investment bank shake-up

UPDATE: One of Janney's four new analyst hires, to be announced (this week of Feb. 23, Janney says), is utilities specialist Michael Gaugler, a Florida-based Wharton grad joining from Tampa-based Brean Capital, according to one of his online profiles. (Revised again on Feb. 24.)

EARLIER: On Feb. 3, I noted the departure of Gary Schatz, Director of Research for the stock analyst group at Janney Capital Markets, the largest investment bank still based in Philadelphia, and at least five of his equity analysts, in recent months. Under new DoR Andrew Maddaloni, the firm will focus more on smaller companies in the healthcare, media tech, regional utilities, consumer and finance sectors, Janney spokeswoman Karen Shakoske told me. The next day I noted the departures of tech analyst Bill Choi and indusrials analyst Bill Balliotti.

Since then, I've heard of a string of Janney Capital Markets departures, including bankers Charles Mather IV (co-head, Equity Capital Markets), Steven Higgins (head of the financial sponsors group), Mark H. Belford (Consumer and Retail chief), Andrew Kurz (Technology and Services), and John Damian (Food-Beverages-Restaurants)  among others.

Janney's top investment banker, Christopher White, left in December (he's now COO for HealthCare Royalty Partners, a buyout fund in Stamford, Conn.) Replacements are two Janney insiders with retail bona fides: Cliff Booth (promoted from Finanicial Institutions) and Joe Culley (Infrastructure). White had replaced Andrew Schmucker (who later joined in Delancey Street Partners) in 2011; Schmucker relaced Bill Rulon-Miller (later a managing director at Don Caldwell's Cross Atlantic Capital Partners) in 2008, making Janney's investment banking boss job look very much like a three-year-term position.

Investment banking is 20% of Janney's business, the firm says; retail investment sales are the other 80%, employing most of the firm's staff, which totals 1,851 nationally, 508 in Philadelphia (down from a reported 550 in 2012). Retail has prospered, and not just in the recent stock market inflation: Janney hasn't lost money for more than 20 years, the firm says here.

Shakoske notes the firm is privately owned by Penn Mutual, the Montgomery County-based life insurance company. She says Janney realized "record results" in 2014, though the company won't disclose them.

Two former Janney managers told me Penn Mutual is part of the challenge: Insurance is a broadly cyclical business where sales and earnings tend to grow over time. By contrast, some aspects of investment banking -- M&A, for example -- can be a lumpy business, sometimes very profitable, sometimes not; bankers labor to build relationships that could take years to reach bonanzas. An owner unwilling to suffer occasional losses will have a harder time keeping a team and building a large banking business long-term.

Update: Janney's owners sent this statement in response: "Penn Mutual is proud of our affiliation with Janney since 1982. Janney's unwavering committment to meeting their client's needs first has helped contribute to 32 consectuive years of profitability. While Janney is owned by Penn Mutual, it operates independently and in line with their own strategies and objectives to optimize performance across all market cycles."

At Janney, spokeswoman Shakoske says the firm is responding to larger trends: She notes the Wall Street Journal today (Feb. 20) reports a 20% drop in the number of bankers, traders, salespeople and analysts over the past four years, according to data compiled by London-based Coalition Ltd., which blames pressure to specialize in narrow, profitable markets. In that context, Janney's move to "adjust our strategy," as Shakoske puts it, looks more like the rest of the industry.