In thin catcher market, Carlos Ruiz is one trade option
The first major free-agent domino fell Monday when Russell Martin signed with Toronto, a contract that forces other teams to pursue their needs at catcher through a trade. Could Carlos Ruiz be one option?
The first major free-agent domino fell Monday when Russell Martin signed with Toronto for five years and $82 million, a contract that forces other teams to pursue their needs at catcher through a trade. There are no other available starting catchers in free agency. The Pirates — Martin's former employer — and Cubs are both searching for one.
They will look toward Arizona, which has reportedly made Miguel Montero available. They may inquire about Jason Castro, a 27-year-old asset the Houston Astros could flip for younger talent. Dioner Navarro, displaced in Toronto by Martin, is another possible target.
So is Carlos Ruiz.
Ruiz, who turns 36 in January, is available just as every Phillies player is. The team's decision makers have made no secret about their desire to inject younger talent through trades. Ruiz has served them well; the return on an original $8,000 investment in 1998 is overwhelming. But a rebuilding team could now part ways.
There are obstacles, of course. Ruiz's age is the top one. Catchers do not age well, and his injury history is dubious. Ruiz started 104 games, his highest total since 2011, last season. But it is difficult for a team to assume he can start more than 100 games in 2015. Ruiz has spent time on the disabled list in each of the last six seasons.
A catcher age 36 or older has accrued 400 plate appearances just 16 times in the last 20 seasons.
He is owed $17.5 million over the next two seasons, including a $500,000 buyout for a $4.5 million club option in 2017. Ruiz has a four-team no-trade clause, which could further complicate a trade. He could ask for that club option to be guaranteed in exchange for waiving the no-trade clause.
Montero, 31, has $40 million remaining on his contract, which extends through 2017. He posted an .829 OPS in 2012, but that figure dipped to .662 and .699 in subsequent seasons. He leads the majors in innings caught since 2011, a fact that proves his durability but could portend trouble later. Montero's pitch-framing ability is regarded among the best in baseball, an attribute that will attract the progressive front offices in Chicago and Pittsburgh.
The White Sox and Dodgers could also seek an upgrade at catcher this winter.
Ruiz's value stems from his exceptional on-base skills. He makes outs at a far lower rate than his peers. Only Buster Posey (.376) has a higher on-base percentage than Ruiz (.368) among the 35 catchers with at least 1,000 plate appearances since 2010. Pitchers rave about Ruiz's game-calling ability, although advanced defensive metrics are not as kind to Ruiz in recent years.
Ruiz was a 9.8-WAR player for the previous three seasons compared to Montero's 6.7 WAR, according to FanGraphs. (Ruiz outpaced Montero in 2014 WAR, 3.2 to 1.2.) That, of course, is an inexact measurement. But Ruiz, despite his age, holds some value.
The Blue Jays set the market by paying Martin a massive sum. Now, the Diamondbacks and Phillies will canvas the catching-starved teams to see if there is a trade match.
Have a question? Tweet @MattGelb for possible use in a future mailbag.
























