Skip to content

Phillies’ Chase Utley is top returning vote-getter on 2027 Hall of Fame ballot

Six other former Phillies are listed on the 27-player ballot, released on Monday by the Hall of Fame.

The poll numbers rose to 59.1% last year for former Phillies second baseman Chase Utley, who has a chance to make it to Cooperstown in 2027.
The poll numbers rose to 59.1% last year for former Phillies second baseman Chase Utley, who has a chance to make it to Cooperstown in 2027.Read moreYong Kim / Staff Photographer

When the Phillies announced that Chase Utley would be added to their Wall of Fame this year, it made sense to ask the question.

Can the Hall of Fame be far behind?

“One step at a time,” Utley said in March.

Well, the time has come to talk about it ... again.

Utley is the top returning vote-getter on the 27-player ballot released Monday by the Hall of Fame. Six other former Phillies are listed, including Jimmy Rollins, Cole Hamels, and Bobby Abreu. Jake Arrieta, Jay Bruce, and Asdrúbal Cabrera are among 14 first-time candidates, a group headlined by Buster Posey and Jon Lester.

» READ MORE: Phillies Wall of Fame and then Hall of Fame? Chase Utley putting ‘pieces together’ on his Cooperstown chances.

But Utley might want to get started on his speech. The iconic Phillies second baseman’s poll numbers rose to 59.1% last year, up from 39.8% and 28.8% in the previous two cycles since he made his ballot debut in 2024.

History says Utley will eventually vault over the Hall’s 75% bar for election. His trajectory is similar to Scott Rolen, who climbed from 35.3% in 2020 to 52.9% in 2021, 63.2% in 2022, and finally 76.3% in 2023.

Will 2027 be the year Utley paints Cooperstown red?

Consider this: Each year, new voters enter the process as they reach 10 consecutive years of membership in the Baseball Writers’ Association, while other voters are weeded out. It explains how a candidate’s year-to-year vote total changes when his statistics don’t.

Utley tends to do well with newer voters, many of whom are analytically-minded and/or value big peaks over longevity. There were more first-time voters than usual last year (46, according to Ryan Thibodaux’s Hall of Fame tracker). Thibodaux is estimating only 15 to 20 first-time voters this year.

Since 1975, only Larry Walker and Ralph Kiner reached 75% without clearing 60% in the previous election cycle. And in both cases, they were in their final year of eligibility on the writers’ ballot.

Then again, Posey is the only first-year candidate with a strong chance to get elected. And his presence on the ballot could help Utley’s case. The three-time World Series-winning Giants catcher finished with 1,500 career hits; Utley had 1,885.

Regardless, Utley knows he’s getting closer.

“I’ve tried to educate myself on how the process works,” he said. “And, yeah, it seems like it’s evolving a little bit different than it has in the past. But I think the game is evolving. We as people are evolving as far as how we identify good players and great players and Hall of Famers.

“Obviously you can’t help but pay attention to it.”

Rollins, entering his sixth cycle on the ballot, is seeking to continue his momentum after making his biggest jump yet to 25.4% last year.

Abreu also made a sizable gain last year, reaching 30.8% after treading water the previous three cycles (19.5%, 14.8%, 15.4%). But he’s running out of time in his eighth year on the ballot. (The Hall allows candidates to remain on the writers’ ballot for a maximum of 10 years.)

Hamels debuted last year with 23.8%, slightly ahead of fellow lefty Félix Hernández’s 2025 debut (20.6%) before he jumped to 46.1% last year.

The Inquirer logo
Watch the latest episode

In discussing Justin Crawford’s first year in the majors, Phillies manager Don Mattingly and president of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski used the same expression: “He kept his head above water.” Moving forward, they will hold the 22-year-old center fielder to a higher standard. Crawford sat down with Phillies Extra to talk about his goals for 2027, including stealing more bases, improving his defense, and more. Watch here.

You can also subscribe to the podcast version of Phillies Extra on Spotify or Apple Podcasts.

Previous episodes: Jim Duquette | Garrett Stubbs | Tim Mayza | Aidan Miller | Scott Franzke | Larry Andersen | Matt Klentak | Jeff Francoeur | Luke Murton | Mike Hazen | Tony Gwynn Jr.

Join The Conversation