Phillies 2027 bullpen outlook: Free-agent options, prospect forecast, and more
The bullpen was beleaguered by injuries, and several trusted arms fell down the depth chart after disappointing seasons. Let’s dive into their option to improve for next season.

In the three-game wild-card series loss to the Atlanta Braves, the Phillies used just four relievers.
Game 2 even required 10 innings to be decided. And still, the majority of the bullpen stayed seated, with manager Don Mattingly preferring to call on rookie starter Andrew Painter to cover the last three innings in that potential elimination game. The Phillies’ only true relievers to make appearances in the series were Jhoan Duran, Alex McFarlane, Jonathan Bowlan, and Tim Mayza. Members of the rotation covered the rest.
It was a reflection of the state of the bullpen, and how few arms remained in Mattingly’s circle of trust by that point.
The unit was beleaguered by injuries all year, and several trusted arms fell down the depth chart after disappointing seasons. There were a few bright spots, namely the continued regular-season dominance of Duran and the emergence of McFarlane. But the bullpen as a whole is a major area of need for the Phillies this winter.
Here’s a breakdown of the relievers’ outlook for 2027 and beyond:
The closer
The Phillies’ last three postseason series losses — the 2024 National League Division Series against the New York Mets, the 2025 NLDS against the Los Angeles Dodgers, and the 2026 wild-card series against the Braves — all had a common thread. A late lead in Game 1, blown by the Phillies bullpen, that the team could not come back from.
The go-ahead three-run homer Duran surrendered to Austin Riley in the eighth inning of Game 1 was just the latest example. But this one was perhaps the most stunning, because it was against the Phillies’ most trustworthy reliever.
Before Riley’s homer, Duran had a 1.82 ERA, 0.994 WHIP, and 33 saves in the regular season. He had surrendered two total home runs over 59⅓ innings. It all contributed to Duran’s second-place finish in National League Reliever of the Year voting to the San Diego Padres’ Mason Miller.
» READ MORE: A (likely long) lockout looms again for MLB. Why a salary cap is at the center of it all. Again.
Based on what was available to Mattingly, there likely wouldn’t have been a better matchup on paper against the right-handed Riley. Which was why the closer was in the game at all, having entered in the seventh with the goal of a three-inning save.
But therein lies the issue: The Phillies need more options. The bullpen starts with Duran, but cannot rely solely on him. Especially as the flame-throwing righty enters his final season of team control in 2027, the Phillies need to build around him.
The setup arms
The “bridge to Duran” was a question mark that remained unanswered all season. Brad Keller signed a two-year, $22 million contract last offseason to fill that role, but he had an uneven first half that ended abruptly with a UCL tear.
Phillies president of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski said that Keller is on pace to return from Tommy John surgery at some point in the second half of 2027. Even if he remains on track, however, pitchers don’t always return to their pre-injury level immediately after surgery. Keller had a 4.02 ERA in 31⅓ innings in 2026, up from the 2.07 ERA in 69⅔ innings the year before with the Chicago Cubs. If he does return to the Phillies’ bullpen in 2027, it’s fair to wonder what version they’ll get.
For a good part of the season, it appeared that Bowlan was the front-runner for the setup job. But a groin strain in April followed by another in September cost him some time. And even before the second strain, Bowlan had been struggling for the last month of the season.
» READ MORE: Phillies want to ‘really emphasize’ finding left-handed relievers\
An ERA of 2.90 across the first four months shot up to 6.75 in seven appearances in September, which included one loss and one blown save. The struggles continued when Bowlan returned from the injury in Game 3, giving up a homer to Matt Olson in his only postseason appearance.
But Bowlan still has one of the best four-seam fastballs on the team. In 2026, the pitch had a plus-10 run value, with a 37% whiff rate. According to StatCast, Bowlan’s four-seam has 18 inches of rise, which is 2.4 inches more than the average right-handed pitcher. Armed with a pitch that limited hitters to a .118 batting average last year, Bowlan enters 2027 as one of the Phillies’ top available arms after Duran.
Another is McFarlane, who burst onto the scene in August and continuously earned more trust. McFarlane bounced between the minors and majors earlier in the season, including a daylong stint in April when he didn’t even get into a game. But after he was recalled a third time on Aug. 11, McFarlane ensured he wasn’t going back to triple A.
In 19 major league innings, McFarlane put up a 2.84 ERA and racked up 20 strikeouts. He jumped right into the fire, with his first major league out coming against Shohei Ohtani, and also later striking out the likes of Mike Trout, Nolan Arenado, Brice Turang, and Juan Soto. According to those around him, he has the demeanor suited for high-leverage moments. And at 25 years old, McFarlane is a needed injection of youth into the bullpen.
» READ MORE: After tragedy hit, Alex McFarlane lived with his former teachers in Georgia. Now he faces their favorite team
But McFarlane doesn’t have enough experience to truly seize the setup role just yet. Entering 2027, it’s still a question mark.
“Is there [a setup man] that you would anoint right now? My answer is no,” Dombrowski said. “Do I think there can be one? Yes. As does our pitching people. I mean, you cannot believe the number of inquiries we get about a couple of our right-handed relievers to the point where somebody thinks they might be their closers.”
Other righties
The Phillies didn’t have much to judge Caleb Kilian on, as he suffered an oblique injury just 3⅓ innings into his Philadelphia tenure. Before the trade deadline swap that also brought over Luis Arraez in exchange for a pair of pitching prospects, Kilian had a 4.26 ERA with the San Francisco Giants.
The 29-year-old right-hander saw a large velocity jump in 2026, going from 93.6 mph with his fastball in 2024 (his last season in the majors) to 96.6 mph this season. With his four-pitch arsenal — four-seam, knuckle curve, sinker, slider — the Phillies believe he has the stuff to be a key piece.
“We think he’ll be an important part of our bullpen next year,” Dombrowski said of Kilian.
» READ MORE: Justin Crawford hopes to make a big leap in Year 2, just like his friend Chandler Simpson
Chase Shugart, 30, will likely remain a right-handed depth arm. Shugart took the ball whenever asked in 2026, even twice in one day to earn the win in both ends of an April doubleheader. Shugart had a 4.02 ERA in 53⅔ innings, and is primarily suited for low-leverage.
The bigger question will be the future of Orion Kerkering. The Phillies reached an impasse with the righty in September as his second-half struggles continued, and decided to option him to triple A knowing it would prevent him from being included on the wild-card roster. It was the first time Kerkering, 25, had been optioned since making his major league debut in September 2023.
“It got to the point where it’s almost unusable,” Mattingly said at the time.
He started the season strong, rebounding from the infamous Division Series-ending error that had some wondering if Kerkering would ever throw another pitch in a Phillies uniform. But things fell apart after the All-Star break.
“It’s not like he started out struggling,” Dombrowski said. “People have talked about we should have moved on after the year that he had, after what happened in L.A. the year before. I thought he approached that very well, and did what he needed to do to help himself, and it was apparent he did it, because he pitched well for us. But that’s going to kind of be up to us to try to figure that out with him. And I do think he has a chance to still be an effective big league pitcher.”
In the first half, Kerkering had a 2.43 ERA and 1.16 WHIP. In the second half, those figures ballooned to 9.43 and 1.95. He dealt with turf toe that had him in a walking boot away from the field for a period of time, but the Phillies did not believe there was anything physical causing Kerkering’s struggles.
» READ MORE: Baseball gears up for a player movement frenzy as a lockout looms. Here’s where the Phillies stand.
In his final outing before being demoted, Kerkering’s velocity had lost a few ticks. His fastball, which averaged 97.2 mph, was down to 95.3 mph. Batters were hitting all his pitches hard, but especially his signature sweeper, which they averaged .429 against in the month of September.
It’s fair to wonder at this point whether Kerkering’s time in Philadelphia has run its course, and if a change of scenery might benefit him. But Dombrowski expressed some confidence in Kerkering’s capability.
“He has the ability to turn it around. He’s got a good fastball. He’s got a good sweeper, and they’ve given him a splitter,” Dombrowski said. “He didn’t perform to those capabilities. Am I confident? I’m not going to go into there and say that he’s going to be our setup guy or seventh-inning guy. Do I think he can turn it around? I think he can, but we’ll have to wait and see on that.”
Left-handed struggles
One of the first moves the Phillies made this offseason was re-signing Mayza to a one-year, $2.75 million contract. The 34-year-old was one of the bullpen’s veteran leaders in 2026, filling a variety of roles: opener, bulk, and even occasionally high-leverage. He was also the Phillies’ only left-handed reliever to touch the mound during the wild-card series.
But that signing was just the first step. During the general managers’ meetings last week in Las Vegas, Dombrowski made his priority clear in acquiring a left-handed setup man.
“It’s something we want to really emphasize, with the number of left-handed hitters,” Dombrowski said.
» READ MORE: The Phillies are counting on Aidan Miller in 2027. Could they also turn to Teruaki Sato for outfield help?
That was what the Phillies hoped Brooks Raley might be at the trade deadline. It cost two prospects to acquire the lefty from the Mets, in what will likely live on as one of the worst trades in recent Phillies history. The 38-year-old had a 1.96 ERA with New York, but a 7.94 ERA with the Phillies. In 16 appearances after the trade, he was charged with three blown saves and two losses.
Raley wasn’t included on the wild-card roster.
He wasn’t the only lefty to struggle for the Phillies last season. As a collective, their left-handed relievers had a 4.58 ERA in 2026, which was third-worst in baseball. The Athletics and Washington Nationals were the only teams whose lefty relievers had higher ERAs, and they finished with records below .500.
José Alvarado is a free agent, with his tumultuous Phillies tenure likely coming to an end after a 5.86 ERA and 1.646 WHIP this season.
The Phillies are hoping for a rebound from Tanner Banks, whose struggles led him to be optioned in June. After a 3.07 ERA campaign in 2025, Banks struggled to a 6.19 ERA this season. His walk rate went from 4.5% to 8.5%.
Banks also missed over two months of the season with a forearm strain, returning to fill a bulk role in September. He was somewhat improved in 7⅓ innings that month, with a 2.45 ERA.
Kyle Backhus remains intriguing, if only because he brings something different than any other pitcher on the Phillies roster. With an arm angle of 6 degrees, Backhus had the fourth-lowest arm slot of any lefty in the league in 2026.
» READ MORE: Phillies think they can count on Gage Wood for starting pitching depth in 2027
For reference, the Phillies’ next-lowest left-hander is Jesús Luzardo with an arm angle of 26 degrees. Backhus had a 4.95 ERA in 20 innings in 2026 and didn’t quite carve out a major league role. But as a sidearmer he gives opposing hitters a completely different visual compared to anyone else on the staff.
However, none of these options seem likely to fulfill the setup role. And as the number of left-handed hitters in baseball continue to rise, the left-handed reliever increases in importance, too. In that regard, the Phillies are back to the drawing board.
Free-agent options
It’s a relatively deep free-agent class for relievers this winter, with Padres lefty Adrián Morejón leading the charge. Morejón would suit the Phillies’ needs exactly, as he pitched to a 2.83 ERA as the Padres’ setup man last season.
Morejón, whose four-pitch arsenal contributed to a 38.6% chase rate, 34.2% whiff rate, and 30.4% strikeout rate, could be a closer on most teams in baseball. He just happened to be blocked from that role on the Padres by Miller, who beat out Duran for National League Reliever of the Year and even garnered some Cy Young votes.
But Morejón is accustomed to high-leverage situations, and has the stuff to back it up. He can touch triple digits with his fastball, and his 58% ground-ball rate in 2026 was in the 98th percentile of pitchers.
» READ MORE: The looming lockout complicates roster decisions for teams, including the Phillies
Morejón, who will be 28 in February, has recorded an ERA under 3.00 in each of the last three seasons.
To sign a pitcher like Morejón, it’s likely that the Phillies will have to offer a multiyear deal. That’s not something Dombrowski typically likes to do for relievers, excluding last winter’s two-year deal for Keller. But it will be necessary if the Phillies want to compete for a higher-caliber arm.
“Last year, we gave [Keller] two, we hadn’t done in a while, he got hurt. It shows the volatility,” Dombrowski said. “There’s the rare exception of the star relievers, but there’s not very many of them around. I prefer [one-year contracts], but [it] doesn’t mean you’re going to get a deal done if you stick to that all the time. Sometimes you have to. I have felt myself, for relief pitchers, the shorter the better because of the volatility.”
For a sense of the market, one of the first relief pitchers off the board this winter was righty Evan Phillips, who signed with the Braves for three years and $35 million. And that was after Phillips only pitched 26 innings in 2026 upon returning from Tommy John surgery in July.
Alex Vesia is another top left-hander available, coming off a strong season with the Dodgers. Vesia, 30, recorded a 2.64 ERA and 1.07 WHIP in 58 innings. He doesn’t have blazing velocity, sitting at 92.1 mph with his fastball, but the pitch is deceptive and helps Vesia generate a lot of whiffs (33.6%). He is effective against lefties (.138 batting average against) and righties (.155).
At 33 years old, A.J. Minter might be a more affordable option. The lefty had a 2.56 ERA and 1.051 WHIP in 45⅔ innings this season, and netted the Mets a pair of infield prospects when they dealt him to the Minnesota Twins at the trade deadline. Minter does have an injury history, though. He missed some time early in the season as he worked his way back from left lat surgery, returning to the mound in May.
» READ MORE: Dave Dombrowski, proactivity vs. reactivity, and four World Series worthy trades
Just because lefties are the Phillies’ priority, however, doesn’t mean they won’t look to add to their stable of righties if a deal comes together. A pitcher like Jonathan Loáisiga could also be a fit after his 2.42 ERA season with the Arizona Diamondbacks.
The 67 innings Loáisiga turned in for Arizona this year was his highest workload in five seasons. He saw the bulk of his appearances in the seventh, eighth, and ninth innings, recording two saves. Loáisiga’s fastball sat around 98 mph, and hitters averaged .148 against his four-seam. He generated a lot of chase (35.9%), while keeping his walk rate to just 5%.
On the farm
The Phillies continue to view top pitching prospect Gage Wood as a starter, and will continue to build him up with the goal of impacting their major league rotation. But they are not closing the door completely on a future move to the bullpen.
In fact, the Phillies discussed potentially calling up Wood, who spent most of 2026 in double A, as a reliever last season. They ultimately decided against it, but it was an option on the table. If the need arose again, the Phillies would consider it.
“I can never say no to anything, but for me, I think it’s important he continues to develop as a starter,” Dombrowski said of Wood. “We think he can be a starter. We need starting pitching depth, so I think it’s more important for us to use him like that. ... You could always do that later. You can’t stretch them out, necessarily, later, but you can do that.”
» READ MORE: Phillies offseason tracker: Free agency news, trades, key dates, and the latest on the lockout
Right-hander Wen-Hui Pan returned from Tommy John surgery this season after being sidelined for all of 2025. Ranked the Phillies’ No. 20 prospect by MLB Pipeline, Pan had a 3.10 ERA in 38 relief appearances this season. His 40 ⅔ innings spanned three levels, with Pan finishing the season in double A.
Pan, 24, gets a lot of chase, with a 35.87% rate. He picked up six saves and finished the year strong, with five consecutive scoreless appearances to close out September.
Mavis Graves is another intriguing prospect. He began the season in the starting rotation for high-A Jersey Shore, but the lefty shone after a promotion to double A that came with a change in role. Graves, who turns 23 this week, had a 0.96 ERA in 14 relief appearances (18⅔ innings) for Reading. He held opposing hitters to a .152 batting average.
Estibenzon Jimenez also had a strong season at double A, converting all seven of his save opportunities after taking over closing duties from the graduated McFarlane. Jimenez, a 24-year-old right-hander, had a 2.38 ERA in 45⅓ innings and threw the final pitch to clinch Reading’s first Eastern League title since 1995.
Jimenez continued to get reps in the Arizona Fall League, where his numbers weren’t as stellar, with a 7.88 ERA in eight innings. However, that is somewhat inflated by one blowup outing on Oct. 26, when Jimenez was charged with five earned runs in one inning.























