LETTERS - Sept. 9
ISSUE | MIXED DOUBLES Revisit athletic rules The mixed-gender policy of the Pennsylvania Interscholastic Athletic Association supports sexism toward female athletes, shows blatant disrespect toward trans-identifying athletes, and forces schools to ban boys or miss playoffs ("Field hockey player
ISSUE | MIXED DOUBLES
Revisit athletic rules
The mixed-gender policy of the Pennsylvania Interscholastic Athletic Association supports sexism toward female athletes, shows blatant disrespect toward trans-identifying athletes, and forces schools to ban boys or miss playoffs ("Field hockey player drops suit," Sept. 4). Rushed implementation has taken a devastating toll on individuals and teams. Postseason dreams, not negative play, force out boys. Teammates are forced to choose sides, destroying team morale. Coaches have resigned.
The Women's Sports Foundation supports well-regulated co-ed participation due to a "lack of substantial physical differences between the sexes" and greater variance within a gender. Instead, PIAA punishes teams with no postseason. A bylaw permits questioning another person's gender identity.
Schools must lead in promoting gender equity through evaluation of competitive advantage and safety across all genders, with experts, not principals, doing the vetting. PIAA should suspend this bylaw until a better plan, based on sound data and expertise, is developed.
|Jennifer L. Ball, Parishville, N.Y.
ISSUE | A.C. REVIVAL
Shore mecca of old
So let me understand this: Atlantic City will try to revitalize itself as a destination city, just like it was when I was a kid growing up in the '40s and '50s? Amusement parks, nightclubs, theaters, and the boardwalk? Sounds like déjà vu all over again.
|Joe Orenstein, Philadelphia
ISSUE | OVERSIGHT
Check the figures
Recent reports out of Wilmington peg police pay among the highest for all city workers. No doubt, police have difficult, often thankless, challenging jobs that often do not end at the bell. But what exactly are they doing to earn such huge paychecks? The public should know.
I suggest an independent audit of any agency with significant overtime expenses to determine just what is going on. With lawmakers at all levels always looking to fund worthwhile projects, overtime audits make sense.
|Ken Abraham, Dover, kenabraham3138@gmail.com
ISSUE | MEMORY TEST
Can do better
Ed Rendell appears more interested in defending his tenure as governor than actually discussing the facts about Philadelphia ("Clear gains from wise school investments," Sept. 1). Our analysis of school spending, enrollment, and staffing trends spanned several administrations. We present the facts - notably that spending has dramatically increased. Despite that increased investment - more than $1 billion since 2002 - Philadelphia public schools continue to leave children unprepared. Four in five students failed to meet proficiency in reading and math in 2013, according to the Nation's Report Card.
|James Paul, senior policy analyst, Commonwealth Foundation, Harrisburg
ISSUE | TALES OF THE CITY
Neighborhood sommelier, just in time
Having won a wager with a friend, I chose the wonderful Ulivo Restaurant in Queen Village for the payoff dinner. I assumed my friend would provide wine, but he had forgotten Ulivo was a bring-your-own. Faced with the disappointment of delicious food without wine, I recalled neighbors I knew when I lived nearby along East Passyunk Avenue. I rang a doorbell and was greeted warmly by a former neighbor who readily solved our dilemma by providing a fabulous bottle of Barbera d'Alba.
When I returned to the restaurant, my elated and stunned dining companion asked, "How long ago did you live here?" It had been several years since my husband and I had moved to Washington Square. What a neighborhood. What lovely people. (Grazie mille, friends Linda and David.)
|Karol M. Wasylyshyn, Philadelphia
Thanks to city police for this bike patrol
My daughter, a recent Temple graduate living near campus, is an avid cyclist who biked to school and then to her job. One morning, she realized that her bike was gone. She filed a police report but had given up hope until she got a message on Facebook from a member of the Stolen Bikes group that he had seen her bike on Craigslist. She immediately called Temple police, who alerted the Police Department.
Later that day, she received a call from an officer who asked, "How's your day going?" Then he said, "It's going to get better. . . . I have your bike in my trunk." These officers really came through and renewed our family's faith in the Police Department.
|Patty Davis, Wyndmoor
ISSUE | WEATHER
Time to get serious about climate change
Luckily, the large tree that fell on our house during a recent storm caused only minimal damage. And while we obviously cannot blame every incident on climate change, it is clear that storms have become more frequent and more severe. It is also clear that climate change is real and has a real impact on our community.
Almost 90 percent of Pennsylvanians live in a county that was declared a weather-related disaster area in 2012. That's why I believe it's essential that we move from complacency to action.
Power plants are the single largest source of global-warming pollution, and what do they run on? Coal. That's why President Obama has proposed a 30 percent cut in carbon emissions at fossil-fuel-burning power plants by 2030. U.S. Sen. Bob Casey (D., Pa.) has said he is serious about tackling climate change - and now he needs to follow through by publicly supporting Obama's effort to limit the largest source of the carbon pollution fueling global warming. The weather is getting serious. It's time for us to get serious about climate change.
|Nancy Sakaduski, Chadds Ford
ISSUE | LANGUAGE LESSON
Multilingualism aids in learning of English
From my perspective, having taught English to foreign-language-speaking students for many years, Mauro E. Mujica's commentary contains a false dichotomy, because multilingualism aids English-language learning ("English first as a policy starting point," Sept. 4). In respected multilingual grade sequences, the goal is to increase the percentage of English as the target language from year to year. In my experience, it is a myth that the use of the student's native language is a deterrent to learning English.
In an analogous example, in my retirement-years English teaching at the School for International Training program in Oaxaca, Mexico, I made a great leap with my Spanish-speaking beginning students by plunging directly into the reading of Sandra Cisneros' The House on Mango Street, about the experiences of Mexican immigrants in Chicago. First, I had students read paragraphs in the Spanish version twice, and then we read the corresponding English paragraphs.
I wonder if Mujica's "English first" wording is a mask for the discredited California "English only" policy.
|Edward R. Levenson, Philadelphia
ISSUE | THEATER-GOING
Personal dramas are no excuse
On the day prior to a Forrest Theatre production, I severely sprained my foot and called the box office in hopes of exchanging our tickets. We received a very terse response that theater policy does not allow for exchanges.
I understand that the Forrest Theatre does not have to comply with disability laws passed after it was built. However, the building has no elevators, and the one lavatory is on the ground floor. I would like to warn patrons with physical challenges to think twice before purchasing tickets. I will not consider this theater in the future.
|Barbara Katzman, Wynnewood























