Skip to content

TEAM TO CREAM

NEW YORK - So far, the only thing the self-anointed Team to Beat has beaten is itself. Jimmy Rollins contended in January that the Phillies, fueled by a strong finish in 2006, should win the National League East this season since they upgraded their starting rotation. He couched the statement by saying they stacked up well - "on paper."

Phillies shortstop Jimmy Rollins chases down the ball after booting it for an error in the eighth inning Monday.
Phillies shortstop Jimmy Rollins chases down the ball after booting it for an error in the eighth inning Monday.Read more

NEW YORK - So far, the only thing the self-anointed Team to Beat has beaten is itself.

Jimmy Rollins contended in January that the Phillies, fueled by a strong finish in 2006, should win the National League East this season since they upgraded their starting rotation. He couched the statement by saying they stacked up well - "on paper."

The starters have been OK.

Rollins didn't realize that the Phillies wouldn't drive in runners. He didn't realize they wouldn't hold leads. He didn't realize they wouldn't play adequate defense - himself included, with his error key to the Mets' killer eighth inning. Ryan Howard's third of the season gave the Mets a run in the fifth.

Rollins didn't realize they wouldn't win.

Yesterday's 11-5 gift to the Mets left the Phillies with one win in their first seven games for the second straight season. It delighted the 56,227 fans at Shea Stadium, a record for the Mets on Opening Day.

They booed Rollins every chance they got, heckled the Phillies without mercy and supplied a deafening "JIM-MY ROL-LINS" chant when he erred in the eighth.

Rollins keeps his faith.

"You have times when you're up and times when you're down, and right now we're down," Rollins said, smiling. "But if we can get up and get things rolling, it's going to be a helluva season."

That's a big if.

"Obviously, we had chances to win," said Howard, who homered for the first time this season. "We're in games. We've got to finish them."

Phillies manager Charlie Manuel seemed at a loss. He sat in the dugout pondering the latest loss for 8 minutes while the Mets celebrated on the field.

"We're trying too hard. We're pressing a little bit," Manuel said. "I'll be honest with you: I didn't think we'd get off to a 1-6 start. We're way better than that."

There is evidence to the contrary.

The Phillies left nine more runners on base and now lead baseball with 68. They went 1-for-9 with runners in scoring position and stand at .188. They loaded the bases with no outs in the third and fourth innings and scored one run.

Each of their three best relievers - closer Tom Gordon and setup men Ryan Madson and Geoff Geary - have cost them dearly. Yesterday was Geary's turn, in a situation that will supply second-guess fodder through the team's off day today.

"We've got to get guys to step up," Manuel said. He has given them opportunity.

Manuel let Geary hit for himself to start the eighth after Geary put out a fire started by lefty Matt Smith. The Phillies led, 5-4.

Manuel didn't want to double-switch with third baseman Abraham Nunez, who started and batted eighth; his defense usually makes him a late-inning substitute in games in which the Phillies lead.

Manuel didn't want to double-switch with seventh hitter Aaron Rowand, either, since he believes Rowand is part of the Phillies' best defensive outfield alignment. He planned to replace leftfielder Pat Burrell with Michael Bourn after Burrell hit in the ninth.

"I wanted to keep my defense on the field," Manuel said.

Manuel really didn't want to turn the game over to the rest of the bullpen.

Gordon, at 39, is a one-inning pitcher, period, Manuel said. Antonio Alfonseca had pitched in three of the last four games. Madson already lost two games and had pitched two innings in Florida on Saturday. It wasn't a great spot for Jon Lieber, fresh off the disabled list, to make his first relief appearance since 1998 with Pittsburgh. Manuel had never even seen newcomer Francisco Rosario pitch, and Clay Condrey is the long reliever.

What Manuel wanted to do was leave it in Geary's hands, hoping he could get through the eighth and give the game to Gordon.

Geary made the first out of reliever Pedro Feliciano's 1-2-3 inning. And then the Mets jumped on Geary and Lieber for seven runs in the bottom of the eighth, turning a one-run deficit into a six-run lead.

Key in the inning: Rollins, the team's best defensive player, booted a bases-loaded, groundball smash from Jose Reyes that would have led to an out. As a result, three of the seven runs in the inning were unearned.

Not that Geary and Lieber exactly got snakebit.

Around Rollins' error, Geary gave up two hits, two walks and let in the go-ahead run on a wild pitch. He left the bases loaded for Lieber with one out.

Lieber, in his bullpen debut, gave up a sacrifice fly, a walk, a double and a single.

They combined to waste a second straight strong outing from lefty Cole Hamels, who allowed three runs in six innings, striking out seven. One of those runs was unearned, thanks toHoward's third error in seven games.

Howard ran over Nunez on the third-base side of the pitcher's mound as Nunez, calling for the catch, tried to catch a popup by Reyes.

"It was loud. I didn't hear him," Howard said.

He quieted things in the top of the sixth with a 390-foot blast that turned a 3-2 deficit into a 5-3 lead. Howard credited Chase Utley with wearing out Ambiorix Burgos, who needed 12 pitches to retire Utley in the at-bat before Howard's.

"You get to see pretty much everything he had," Howard said.

Utley had crushed his second homer in the fifth, a solo shot off starter John Maine, to tie the game at 2-2. Burrell got two more hits yesterday, improving his team-high average to .385.

But none of the Phillies did anything after Howard's homer.

Things could have been worse for the Phils. Rightfielder Shane Victorino robbed David Wright of at least one RBI with a fine snag to end the seventh. That, combined with Howard's homer, had the momentum swung decidedly in the Phillies' favor.

Then Geary hit for himself, got clobbered, Lieber followed, and Manuel was left searching for solutions to make Rollins right.

"What he said might still come true," Manuel said. "It's not like that's dead."

Indeed, it is a perplexed team, not a deadened one, that shares the worst record in baseball with the Nationals.

"We know what we can do," insisted Victorino, one of the catalysts in last season's surge that endeared the team to a disillusioned following. "We're bitter at the fact we're not doing the things we need to do."

They share that with their rapidly souring fan base. *

Join The Conversation