Skip to content

Phillies' bats go cold in 2-0 loss to Reds

The Phils could not solve Cincinnati’s Brandon Finnegan, who allowed one hit in seven innings.

CINCINNATI - Soon after the grounds crew removed the eight tractors that pinned the white tarp to the field at Great American Ballpark, the Phillies again flaunted their patience. They had bled Cincinnati's opening-day starter, Scott Feldman, for 27 pitches in the first inning two days earlier. On Wednesday, they forced Brandon Finnegan to throw 25 pitches to achieve the first three outs.

"I thought we were going to set the tone of the game," Phillies manager Pete Mackanin said after a 2-0 loss to the Reds, "but then he settled down after that."

It was a night that resembled so many from a season ago, with a thin margin for Jerad Eickhoff that plummeted with one bad pitch to an exceptional hitter. Finnegan retired 19 Phillies in a row; the lineup went six innings between runners on base.

The measured approach from the first inning did not persist. It wasn't as if the Phillies were hacking; the final 27 batters swung at the first pitch eight times. But they were often behind in the count and powerless against Finnegan and the two Reds relievers who followed. The Phillies struck out 13 times. Their only three runners after the first inning reached on infield singles.

"We were pretty darn close to hitting some balls hard," said Tommy Joseph, 0 for 4 with three strikeouts. "We were pretty darn close to hitting some balls in the hole. There's a lot of things that could have gone a different way."

Finnegan, a hard-throwing lefthanded pitcher, silenced the Phillies on one hit in his seven innings. He walked one. He struck out nine. He generated a series of awkward swings and puzzled looks.

So did Eickhoff, until he hung a 1-0 curveball in the seventh to Joey Votto, a man who crushes hanging curveballs.

He deserved better, although it is a familiar feeling for the young pitcher. Since Eickhoff made his major-league debut in August 2015, the Phillies have supported him with zero or one runs in 18 starts. Only the Yankees' Michael Pineda has endured more such starts.

"I can't control that," Eickhoff said. "Those guys are busting their butts. They're working their butts off every day to get hits and to work in the cage. I can't control it. I'm trying to get outs. When I walk off the mound, hopefully I've kept us in the game."

The Phillies have high expectations for Eickhoff, who was slotted as the fourth starter last season and started the second game this season. He emerged as the most dependable presence in the rotation. The 26-year-old righthanded pitched his best in 2016 when his teammates supported him the least, and that happened often.

The rebuilding Reds helped him Wednesday.

"I played into their aggressiveness a little bit," Eickhoff said. "They were swinging early and I was able to kind of throw pitches on the corner there and get some contact to my liking."

Finnegan, after the stressful first inning, encountered no trouble. He threw 30 pitches in the next three innings. New Phillies hitting coach Matt Stairs has implored the team's batters to "grind out at-bats." They drew one walk - Howie Kendrick, the game's second batter.

The middle of the order, so productive in Monday's opener, fell quiet Wednesday. With a lefty on the mound and a desire to somehow insert all of his players in the first week, Mackanin sat Michael Saunders for Aaron Altherr in right field. That pushed Joseph to fifth, behind Maikel Franco.

Saunders appeared in a key moment as a pinch-hitter, with the tying runs on base, but struck out in the eighth inning.

"I'm not platooning Saunders," Mackanin said. "I'm not doing that."

The combination on Wednesday did not thrive. So, with a matinee game Thursday, Mackanin will opt for a different lineup. The bar, after a grand total of four runs in two games, is low.

mgelb@philly.com

@MattGelb

Join The Conversation