Philly foster mom accused of killing girl faked texts to mislead police, report says

In the days after 10-year-old Malayshia Allford was reported missing, her foster mother went to great lengths to misdirect investigators: texting herself affectionate notes from the girl’s phone, responding throughout the day to feign concern, and later, claiming the child had fallen down some steps, according to a police report.

All the while, police say, Malayshia was already dead — hidden in the trunk of a car in South Jersey.

Witnesses who spent time inside the West Philadelphia home of Carprice Williams, the foster mother charged with killing Malayshia, also described chronic and horrific abuses: withholding food from Malayshia for as long as a week, beating her with a phone cord, and throwing her down stairs, according to the report obtained by The Inquirer.

The report, which details interviews with unnamed witnesses, provides a grim account of what happened inside Williams’ West Philadelphia home. It also raises questions about what supervision city-contracted social workers provided, and how Williams was able to continue in her role as a Philadelphia School District teacher.

Williams, 36, was arrested Nov. 5 and accused of killing Malayshia, whose body was found the day before in the trunk of a car at an apartment complex in Lindenwold, in Camden County.

The Defender Association of Philadelphia, which represents Williams, did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Since early 2025, Williams taught fifth grade at Lewis C. Cassidy Academics Plus School, a kindergarten-through-eighth-grade school in Overbrook. She had also worked at Mifflin Elementary in East Falls for a time, at Young Scholars Charter School, and at a Montgomery County preschool.

School district officials said they could not answer questions about Williams’ tenure, but her $114,041 salary is at the “senior career teacher” pay rate, indicating she had at least 10 years of teaching experience plus a master’s degree and further postgraduate education. Williams’ LinkedIn profile said she holds a master’s and doctorate from Drexel University. Asked to confirm that, a Drexel spokesperson confirmed only the master’s degree.

Arthur Steinberg, president of the Philadelphia Federation of Teachers, said Malayshia’s death was “a horror,” and “a tragedy.” Steinberg called for an investigation into the foster care system, but said the matter “had nothing to do with her role as a teacher.”

“To have something like this happen, it’s just unspeakable,” he said.

Williams had been a foster parent since at least 2020.

That’s when she took in two young siblings — one of whom ended up in the hospital the next year with a traumatic brain injury, severe malnutrition, and marks indicative of being struck with an object, according to a lawsuit.

A Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia doctor certified that 2021 event as a “near fatality,” triggering a review that found the foster mother had committed abuse and recommended that she never be allowed to foster again, the lawsuit said.

However, a state Department of Human Services spokesperson said that Williams successfully appealed the child-abuse finding, and her record was expunged.

The Bureau of Hearings and Appeals, an administrative review board within the state human services agency, overturns some 90% of cases brought on appeal, according to a 2021 report by Pennsylvania’s auditor general that found the system was failing child victims.

Nadeem Bezar, a lawyer representing Malayshia’s estate, said that even if Williams was not on the child-abuse registry, the information about the 2021 incident would have been retained in an internal database and should have been used to bar her from future foster placements.

In that 2021 case, Williams told officials that she heard a loud noise and then found the child unresponsive with labored breathing. Later, the children in that case alleged that Williams had grabbed the child’s braids and slammed her head to the floor.

Last month she tried to cover up the circumstances of Malayshia’s death over the nearly two weeks the child was missing, the police report alleges. Williams provided relatives and law enforcement with conflicting accounts about when she’d last seen the girl, and crafted a phony text exchange to support her story that her biological parents had kidnapped her, according to the report.

Investigators concluded that Williams used Malayshia’s phone to text herself: “Mommy I know you are waiting for me to come home but my family they don’t want me to be adopted. … I love you.”

The report lays out allegations by unnamed witnesses who claimed that Williams bent a child’s fingers backward until they were injured, made another stand in a corner all night, directed her 4-year-old son to hit another child with a sword, and forced Malayshia to go up and down stairs wearing a heavy weighted vest. Williams had the inside of the home under video surveillance, according to the report, and required Malayshia to ask permission to use the bathroom.

But Williams contradicted the witnesses’ accounts, saying she had never hit Malayshia, though the child had recently fallen down a few steps. She said Malayshia sometimes wore a weighted vest to calm her during tantrums but had not worn it in about six months.

A medical examiner determined that Malayshia died of blunt force trauma. The report noted a fractured rib, bruises on her head, torso and buttocks, and whiplike marks across her legs.

Surveillance video recorded shortly before 2 a.m. on Oct. 26 shows a man dragging a large bag from the alley behind Williams’ block, with what appeared to be a strand of braided hair sticking out, and loading it into a vehicle, the report said.

The man, a relative who initially denied his involvement, later told police that Williams said the little girl “didn’t wake up,” and when he urged her to call police she told him it was too late, according to the report.

Authorities have not said whether the relative will be charged.

Acknowledgment

The Inquirer’s journalism is supported, in part, by the Lenfest Institute for Journalism and readers like you. News and editorial content are created independently of The Inquirer’s donors. Gifts to support The Inquirer’s high-impact journalism can be made at inquirer.com/donate. A list of Lenfest Institute donors can be found at lenfestinstitute.org/supporters.