Skip to content

Checkpoint sale: A cheap bid to escape investor wrath?

North Star challenges CCL deal price

The board of Gloucester County-based electronic retail sales system maker Checkpoint System Inc. voted to sell the company to Canada--based CCL Industries at a price below where it traded from 2013 until last Spring, so it could avoid facing insurgent board candidates who planned to challenge three incumbents in this year's election, one of the company's largest shareholders said in a letter today.

The plan by Checkpoint CEO George Babich and his board to sell the 4,800-peson company to Canada-based CCL Industries, at just $10.15 a share, came the day after North Star Partners, a West Port, Conn. company that owns nearly 4 percent of Checkpoint, had proposed a list of three insurgent directors to oppose Babich allies.

Checkpoint didn't return calls Wednesday on why the company was willing to sell at such a depressed price.  In the letter sent to Checkpoint today, Andy Jones, managing partner at North Star, said Checkpoint is "acutely" undervalued in the stock market and it wouldn't let the sale go through at that low price without a challenge. Jones said his firm feels "extreme disapointment" in the plan to sell the company "below the true intrinsic value of the business."

Instead of selling at a bargain price, Checkpoint shares have "significant upside potential" -- if it were run by "appropriate leadership," Jones added. 

In announcing the merger, Jones noted, CCL praised Checkpoint trends which Jones said ought to be making more money for Checkpoint shareholders. Those include rising profits, more sales contracts with "blue chip" retail stores, a rebound in "loss prevention spending," and continued rapid increase in RFID retail tag sales, a major Checkpoint business. CCL also told investors that "things are not quite right" in Checkpoint's management, Jones added.

He also quoted a client report from Imperial Capital complaining the share price is "disappointing" given Checkpoint's previous growth claims. 

Jones wrote that Babich's regime has "blatantly ignored" his prior complaints, and that Institional Shareholder Services, which advises investors in voting on corporate questions, last year gave Checkpoint its lowest governance rating  and recommend shareholders vote against Babich's pay package, which a majority did.

"No doubt you and the rest of the Board were keenly aware that you would likely face opposition to the election of such deeply entrenched and ineffective directors at this year's annual meeting.  Instead of allowing shareholders the opportunity to elect representatives that would truly represent their interests and hold management accountable, the Board has entered into a poorly conceived transaction that significantly undervalues the future prospects and earnings potential of our business," Jones added.

"It appears that the Board is leaving no stone unturned in its attempts to avoid the indignity of losing its hand-picked members.... the solution here is not to give the Company away at a cheap price.  The solution is to focus on improving Checkpoint under the oversight of a strengthened Board," and to avoid handing out fat merger bonuses "to an undeserving management."