Skip to content

There’s now more room for rigatoni at one of Philly’s top Italian restaurants

Chef Marc Vetri's always-crowded pasta bar has been upsized by eight seats after it took over part of the alley.

Eight new seats face the counter at Fiorella, 817 Christian St.
Eight new seats face the counter at Fiorella, 817 Christian St.Read moreMonica Herndon / Staff Photographer

The alley next to Fiorella Pasta used to hold propane tanks, ladders, and random outdoor furniture. Now it’s home to an extension of the dining room at Marc Vetri’s South Philadelphia pasta bar.

With eight seats at three tables, it has boosted the indoor capacity by more than 50%.

Fiorella has been a tough reservation since opening in February 2020, just weeks before the pandemic shut down indoor dining for months. During the surge of streeteries, the restaurant added about 30 outdoor seats, which it has since used year-round.

But as temperatures drop, Vetri said, keeping diners warm becomes more difficult. With just 14 seats inside, including the counter and a couple of tables, plenty of customers were left out in the cold.

Vetri and his team began sketching out what they could fit if they removed the wall separating the dining room from the alley. Like homeowners cleaning out a basement, staff sorted through the alley’s accumulated items, throwing away what they could, Vetri said.

Then they broke through the wall — after removing and saving the former butcher shop’s decorative tile — and created a recessed nook framed with wooden paneling and mirrors, with a wooden bench for seating.

The conversion took about two months, with construction done during off-hours.

The new section blends into the dining room and faces the counter and open kitchen, where chef Matt Rodrigue turns out menu staples such as rigatoni with sausage ragù, ricotta gnocchi, and cacio e pepe, along with seasonal specials.

Fiorella occupies the former butcher shop that Luigi Fiorella opened in 1892 at 817 Christian St., near the Italian Market. Vetri had tested the pasta-bar concept at pop-ups in the demonstration kitchen at Vetri Cucina before bringing it to Christian Street.

He kept the Fiorella family name, the original tin ceiling, and a brass cash register that had briefly gone missing before resurfacing in a Northeast Philadelphia antiques shop.

When Fiorella opened, customers could leave a phone number and wander the neighborhood while waiting for a seat. Today, it takes indoor and outdoor reservations through OpenTable.

As for the new dining area, Vetri said, “It looks like it was always there.”

Join The Conversation