Skip to content

Weapons charges possible for Scarfo

Police said two handguns were found in his Egg Harbor home during a search last week. He could be facing up to five years in prison.

Nicodemo S. Scarfo, whose home was searched last week in an FBI investigation into allegations of fraud and money laundering, may be facing collateral legal damage from the raid, in which documents and computers were seized.

Agents also found two handguns in Scarfo's home in Egg Harbor Township during their search Thursday morning, according to several sources familiar with the investigation.

Scarfo, 42, the son of jailed mob boss Nicodemo "Little Nicky" Scarfo, has two convictions - one for bookmaking and the other for racketeering. As a result, he could be charged with possession of a gun by a felon, an offense that carries a potential five-year prison sentence.

"If that's the case, we'll deal with it in due course," Donald Manno, Scarfo's longtime lawyer, said yesterday.

Manno would not confirm that weapons were found in the spacious, newly built house just outside Atlantic City where Scarfo, his new wife, Lisa, and their infant son, Nicodemo, live.

The couple moved into the house, valued at more than $500,000, about a month ago.

Manno's office and the home of Scarfo's former wife, Michele, were also searched, along with about a dozen other locations in a series of raids last week.

There were no arrests.

Officials with the U.S. Attorney's Office in Camden, which is coordinating the investigation, have declined to comment.

Scores of documents and records were seized.

The investigation is centered on financial and business deals conducted by FirstPlus Financial Group and its subsidiaries over the last 21 months. A copy of a search warrant indicates that the investigation centers on mail fraud, bank fraud, wire fraud, interstate transportation of stolen property, money laundering, and extortion.

FirstPlus Financial, based in Texas, is a former subprime-mortgage lender that sustained substantial losses in the economic collapse of the late 1990s. At one point the company stock was selling for about $50 per share and its loan volume exceeded $3 billion, according to business reports.

Most recently the stock, formerly sold on the New York Stock Exchange but now sold over the counter, was selling for pennies a share.

After remaining dormant for several years, the company began to invest in various businesses here, in Texas and in Florida about 18 months ago.

It is unclear what role Scarfo played in any of the companies under scrutiny. Sources familiar with the investigation say his involvement began after Salvatore Pelullo, an Elkins Park businessman with a conviction for fraud, began to take part in FirstPlus operations.

Pelullo frequently refers to Scarfo as his "cousin," associates say, but they believe there is no blood relationship.

Though he is not listed as an owner or officer of FirstPlus, several sources said Pelullo, 41, has been a behind-the-scenes decision maker since at least last summer. In 1999, Pelullo pleaded guilty to a bank-fraud charge and was sentenced to six months in prison.

Pelullo has not returned phone calls seeking comment. A spokesperson for FirstPlus Financial at the company's headquarters in Irving, Texas, said last week that, on the advice of its lawyer, the firm would not comment about the FBI investigation.

One of the company's subsidiaries, FirstPlus Development, is based at 1231 Bainbridge St., the same address as a Pelullo consulting company and a boxing-promotion firm run by his brother, Arthur Pelullo.

Officials at FirstPlus Development have not returned numerous phone calls seeking comment.

Investigators would not discuss any details about the case or the potential gun charge against Scarfo.

Several individuals familiar with the legal process said one reason authorities would not immediately bring the weapons charge was that it would require disclosure of the sworn FBI investigative affidavit used to obtain court authorization for the search warrants that were executed last week.

The document has been filed under seal.

That type of affidavit usually provides an outline of the investigation and what authorities believe various individuals targeted in the probe have done.

It also might contain references to things like wiretap conversations, if they are part of the investigation, or information provided by unnamed individuals cooperating in the probe.

Contact staff writer George Anastasia at 856-779-3846 or ganastasia@phillynews.com.