Appeals panel backs Coatesville in closing charter
The state Charter Appeals Board has upheld the Coatesville Area School District's decision to close Graystone Academy - a 200-student charter school that has had an acrimonious relationship with the district.
The state Charter Appeals Board has upheld the Coatesville Area School District's decision to close Graystone Academy - a 200-student charter school that has had an acrimonious relationship with the district.
Officials at Graystone say they are preparing to appeal the decision in Commonwealth Court - and insist their doors will be open for the first day of school at the end of the month.
In its ruling this week, the appeals board cited the charter school's "poor academic performance and for making changes to its charter without school district approval," a state Department of Education spokesperson wrote in an e-mail.
The full text of the board's decision has not been released.
Graystone received its charter from the district in 2002 and renewed it five years later.
Over the last three years, it has received between $3.5 million and $4.5 million annually from the district.
In 2010, the district undertook a comprehensive review of the school's operations, officials said. What they found, they said, was enough to begin the revocation process.
Among the district's complaints were low test scores and changes in the academic curriculum without district approval, said school district attorney James Ellison.
The district also took issue with the charter's decision to eliminate grades six, seven, and eight at the end of 2012, and undertook a second round of revocation proceedings, Ellison said.
The charter school, he said, had failed to notify school-board members, parents, or students before it made the decision to eliminate its middle-school programs.
Graystone officials said the school's charter did not require notifications of curriculum changes.
The original agreement "never said 'you have to check with us before you change these things,' " said Brian Leinhauser, Graystone's attorney. "Coatesville is, in essence, trying to rewrite history and rewrite something into our charter."
He said the school board had not objected when Graystone, which originally served kindergarten through 10th grades, eliminated its ninth and 10th grades several years ago. The school now teaches only kindergarten through fifth grades.
Leinhauser is seeking a motion from Commonwealth Court that would allow Graystone to remain in operation while it appeals the board's decision.
In the meantime, school spokesman Ken Kilpatrick said, the school will welcome students as usual Aug. 26 - and provide an iPad for each returning student.
"We'll continue to educate not only our children who have been attending school, but welcome those who are disenfranchised or underserved," he said.
The district says it will accept Graystone's 200 students into local public schools this fall and is conducting a registration push to help parents sign up their children.
"We don't anticipate there being any type of apprehension from parents. We can certainly do better than Graystone in terms of them not meeting proficiency standards," Ellison said. "If parents understand that, we shouldn't have a problem."






















