N.J. schools say voters face leanest of budgets
Local districts cited staff cuts and other efforts to keep taxes stable. The public will weigh in Tuesday.
A winter of state aid delays and federal stimulus uncertainty led to tough budget trade-offs for New Jersey school boards: Jobs or field trips? Sports or preschool fees? New textbooks or swimming?
"This budget represents sacrifice," Cherry Hill School District spokeswoman Susan Bastnagel said of the 2009-10 proposal, which will go before voters Tuesday.
Cherry Hill is cutting 63 jobs, but at the community's request it is seeking $100,000 in corporate sponsorships and discounts to preserve a week-long sixth-grade field trip to Mount Misery in the Pinelands, a 30-year tradition.
Superintendents say their proposed budgets are among the leanest in years - through staff cuts, combined services, refinanced debt, and reduced programming.
Still, in this economy, they worry that may not matter when roughly 550 districts vote Tuesday on school board candidates and the portion of the budgets covered by property taxes.
Cherry Hill, Lumberton, Mount Laurel, Voorhees, and Pennsauken are among South Jersey districts whose 2009-10 budgets would keep residents' property taxes nearly identical to last year's. Others, such as Moorestown and Haddonfield, propose tax increases of less than 2 percent. The state caps increases at 4 percent without a waiver.
"Even if John and Jane Q. Public support the schools, they're nervous about their own fiscal situations," Gloucester County Executive Superintendent Mark Stanwood said. "People's investments are down, and they're worried about losing their jobs."
Freshman sports are targeted for elimination in Deptford and elsewhere if budgets fail. In Gloucester County, Monroe and Kingsway Regional made the sports programs' survival dependent on passage of a ballot question.
Haddon Township residents opposed a proposal to cut freshman sports, so the district will charge families $1,000 to enroll a child in what had been a free half-day prekindergarten program.
Like companies, districts are laying off staff and freezing administrators' raises.
In Washington and Pemberton Townships, staff cuts are due to enrollment declines. Washington Township's enrollment dropped to 8,700, down from 10,000 a few years ago, board members said. The district will lay off staff members - 29 - for the first time in a dozen years.
Pemberton Township, next to Fort Dix, arrived at its $111 million budget by cutting 14 staff members to save $600,000, business administrator Pat Austin said. Enrollment has fallen by about 1,000 in the last decade because of federal military base realignment.
Monroe Township, however, is reducing staff even though its enrollment continues to grow by about 200 a year - 66 percent in the last decade. Its $82.5 million proposed budget would mean about 30 layoffs, including 10 teachers and 11 aides, Superintendent Charles M. Earling said. A ballot question attempts to preserve 20 other positions at a cost of $1.1 million.
"When you start cutting people, that's when you start affecting the quality of schools," said Steve Baker, a state teachers union spokesman. "We're hoping boards keep flexible in case revenues come in ahead of where they expect."
To arrive at its $361 million budget, Camden eliminated 90 positions - about half of them vacant - at least until federal stimulus money comes in. The district will reduce its food-service deficit by $1 million by requiring students who don't qualify for free or reduced lunches to pay for their meals for the first time.
It has been a tough and confusing budget year, said Frank Belluscio, New Jersey School Boards Association spokesman. "There's always a concern when there's an economic downturn, and this is a bad one."
Yet voters have approved at least half the budgets since 1976, he said. Supplemental questions, which require a 60 percent majority to pass, fail more frequently.
In the last decade, 70 to 100 districts annually posed supplementary questions to pay for such things as extra staff, extracurricular or enrichment programs, maintenance, and security. This year, only 11 districts are posing ballot questions - the fewest ever, the school boards association said.
Boards "are afraid to ask because they know they need a supermajority," Stanwood said. "But it also speaks to the respect they have for the property owners. They don't want to ask for more than they need."
Kingsway Regional, based in Woolwich Township, seeks $202,203 to pay for a late bus and middle school and freshman sports. To maintain current class sizes, Monroe's ballot requests $1,140,882 to retain or replace about 20 teachers and a nurse. The money also would fund freshman sports.
Ballots in 19 districts statewide, including six in South Jersey, also contain construction-bond questions. Clearview Regional, in Mullica Hill, and Northern Burlington Regional are trying for solar-panel installations. Kingsway Regional wants to build science labs. Riverside and Mount Holly are looking to renovate schools. Woodlynne seeks funding for an early-childhood-education wing and Americans With Disabilities Act compliance.
With no tax increase and uncontested board races in her district, Cherry Hill's Bastnagel said her biggest worry was voter apathy.
Statewide turnout in the last 10 school elections has been less than 16 percent, according to the school boards association.
"There will always be people who vote no because this is the only budget they can vote on," Bastnagel said.
Inquirer staff writers Jan Hefler and Rita Giordano contributed to this article.






















