Skip to content

Howie Roseman season began by meeting Miami’s Darian Mensah pregame. Is the conclusion really that obvious?

If the Eagles really were interested in drafting Mensah as a potential replacement for Jalen Hurts, then Roseman would only be hurting his cause with such Saturday's public display of affection.

Eagles general manager Howie Roseman met with QB Darian Mensah (shown above) before the Miami-Duke game on Saturday, but it may have not meant much for the team's draft plans come April.
Eagles general manager Howie Roseman met with QB Darian Mensah (shown above) before the Miami-Duke game on Saturday, but it may have not meant much for the team's draft plans come April.Read moreRebecca Blackwell / AP

A tolerance for a certain level of chaos is baked into the way Howie Roseman does business. This has been true since the very beginning of his second act as general manager, when he signed Sam Bradford to a contract extension while simultaneously attempting to trade up and draft Carson Wentz. Bradford’s reaction to the Eagles’ subsequent acquisition of the No. 2 overall pick was similar to Wentz’s reaction when, five years later, they drafted Jalen Hurts at No. 53 overall. The reaction was displeasure, you could say.

It is interesting to note that in neither of these instances did Roseman telegraph his intentions ahead of time. Bradford and Wentz both reacted the way they did in part because they did not see it coming. The Eagles performed plenty of due diligence on Wentz and Hurts in the months leading up to their respective drafts. At no point did Roseman allow himself to be filmed at point-blank range exchanging a demonstrative bro hug with a player he thought might soon replace his current starting quarterback.

Inquirer logo

David Murphy alerts

Weekly

Get David Murphy’s clear-eyed analysis and fresh perspective on the biggest stories in Philly sports.

Which brings us to last weekend’s scouting trip heard ‘round the world. You are probably aware that Roseman not only attended the University of Miami’s homecoming game against Duke on Saturday, but had a warm and extended pregame interaction with Hurricanes quarterback Darian Mensah. The story that the video tells is one of Roseman specifically seeking out Mensah, a potential first-round pick in a year where the Eagles figure to draft well inside the top 10. Though Roseman also shook hands with a few Hurricanes’ receivers, he does so in the manner that one shakes hands with those who do not possess the requisite capital. He did not slap their butts, in other words.

At last glance, nearly 1.5 million people viewed the video on X. Most of them walked away with the same question. It just so happens to be the exact question you’d hope people would ask if you were a general manager looking to build the trade value of a draft pick that figures to be in the range where teams draft potential franchise quarterbacks.

It’s also the exact question Roseman has to know that Hurts himself would be asking.

Put it this way: If the Eagles really were interested in drafting Mensah as a potential replacement for Hurts, then Roseman would only be hurting his cause with such a public display of affection. This is especially true when you consider that one of the teams that could be drafting ahead of them already has a quarterback, and thus could be willing to trade that pick to a team that thinks it needs to leapfrog the Eagles. This is true whether the pick in question falls in the first or second or even third round. Opinions are split on where Mensah will ultimately land.

» READ MORE: Sielski: The Eagles need to energize their fans. Will they choose Jalen Hurts or a fresh new QB?

If you think that’s too much thought to put into a 30 second video, well, you don’t really know Howie Season.

There are obvious competitive disadvantages the Eagles would incur by prompting quarterback-needy teams to operate as if they could potentially be competing with the Eagles for a quarterback. Those competitive disadvantages would be compounded by the potential friction if Hurts begins operating as if the Eagles are looking to replace him this offseason. All of which suggest that the correct read on the Roseman-Mensah video is just as likely to be that the Eagles aren’t looking for a quarterback as vice versa.

To be clear: quarterback is the No. 1 question facing the Eagles this offseason. It’s just hardly the zero-sum proposition that many portray it to be. One thing we’ve learned since the Tom Brady-Peyton Manning era is that quarterback performance is far more relative than the GOATs make it seem. Sam Darnold, Brock Purdy, Jared Goff, Nick Foles/Wentz — all have been to Super Bowls in the last decade. Kirk Cousins, Baker Mayfield, perhaps J.J. McCarthy — that list is long. There are three types of quarterbacks who come out of college. There are the exceedingly rare one who clearly are The Guy. There are the majority who quickly prove that they clearly will never be The Guy. And, there are those who can be The Guy in the right situation.

The problem with teams that enter the draft with a quarterback-or-bust mindset is that they end up drawing dead on two of the three categories. Some teams end up wish casting themselves into a guy who can never be The Guy. Other teams end up with a guy who can succeed in certain situations, but not a situation where a team feels like only a quarterback can save them.

If the Eagles see a Patrick Mahomes somewhere beyond the Mitch Trubiskys of this year’s class, they should and most likely will draft him. Otherwise, they should and will see this disaster of 2026 for what it is: A chance to make themselves significantly better at some other premium positions, and thus return Hurts to a position where he has shown he can succeed. And, perhaps, stockpile some future draft capital that will give them a chance to make a move should The Guy emerge in the coming years.

The Inquirer logo
Listen to the latest episode

A crucial crossroads is here. The Eagles have reached the bye and, as timing would also have it, the NFL trade deadline, mired in their worst stretch of the Nick Sirianni era. There’s no doubt the franchise needs to course correct, but how? With who? Will players be on the move? Could coaches’ jobs be on the line? The Inquirer’s Jeff McLane and Olivia Reiner conduct an autopsy of the Eagles after their seventh straight loss — a 19-11 defeat to the New York Giants — and look at the big picture of an organization that has swiftly fallen far from its Super Bowl glory two years ago. Listen here.

Listen to all episodes here or wherever you get your podcasts.

Join The Conversation