The Eagles need to energize their fans. Will they choose Jalen Hurts, or a fresh new QB?
The uncertainty surrounding Hurts means an early draft pick spent on a quarterback is something close to a business necessity for the Eagles.

The scariest sight so far in any Eagles game this season hasn’t been their terrible kickoff coverage against the Jacksonville Jaguars … or Andy Dalton’s brutal end-zone interception against the Chicago Bears … or any number of plays on which the offensive line didn’t know who to block … or even the hellacious hit that New York Giants linebacker Arvell Reese laid on Joe Milton. Lord knows there have been plenty more.
No, the scene that had to terrify Jeffrey Lurie most happened as that 19-11 loss to the Giants last week neared its inevitable end. Lincoln Financial Field was as quiet as it has been in years. Few people bothered to boo because few people had bothered to stay. They streamed down the aisles and out of the stadium, making it clear that the Eagles’ most challenging opponent left over their final eight games won’t be the Pittsburgh Steelers this week or the Seattle Seahawks next month or the San Francisco 49ers next year. It’ll be the paying public’s indifference.

Mike Sielski alerts
This is the other uncomfortable aspect to any discussion about the biggest question the Eagles face this offseason: What could and should they do at quarterback? (The quarterback question is more important than the head coach question? Yep. We’ll get to why in a minute.) It’s discomfiting enough that blood clots ended Jalen Hurts’ season, could have put his short- and long-term health at risk, and cast at least some doubt on his future in the NFL. But the Eagles’ descent and their fans’ resulting apathy add another layer of complication, one that would make it shocking if the Eagles didn’t use a high pick on a QB in next year’s draft.
If Hurts can’t play again — and what a horrible, unfair development that would be — then the Eagles will of course have to find a new quarterback. So for the sake of this thought exercise, let’s assume that he will be healthy enough to start Week 1 of the 2027 regular season. There are plenty of reasons it would make sense for the Eagles to keep Hurts as their starter. His accomplishments, both as an individual and based on his role as a team leader, are well known and worthy of respect. He’s a high-character veteran, and the Eagles have just so many left in the locker room.
What’s in even shorter supply in that room (and around the NFL) is competent quarterback play, and Hurts can provide it, and no one, including the Eagles, should take that for granted. A franchise can spend years in the wilderness searching for a decent quarterback, let alone for one capable of winning a Super Bowl (which Hurts obviously was and might still be), and it shouldn’t embark on that chase lightly.
Should Lurie, Howie Roseman, and everyone else with some say-so decide Hurts is the Eagles’ best option, that no quarterback in the draft warrants a first-round pick, they could get creative about rebuilding the rest of the roster. With the top-10 pick they’re likely to have and all the other assets that Roseman has already acquired, they could put together an enticing package that would allow them to move up or drop down in the draft, pick up new players, and still take a chance on a quarterback in the second or third round.
Would drafting a QB even that high bother Hurts? Maybe. So what? Has he given any indication over his career that he would allow such a thing to affect him or his performance? The last time he was in a bona fide positional competition (in his mind, anyway) was in 2020, immediately after the Eagles drafted him. He showed up to his first NFL training camp ready to chew bubblegum and beat out Carson Wentz as the starter, and the Eagles barely had time to offer him a stick of Juicy Fruit before he was in the lineup for good and Wentz was demanding to be traded.
So yes, staying with Hurts as the starter might make the best football sense for the Eagles. But — and here’s where things get complicated — it might not make the best business sense, and whether die-hard fans like it or not, they’d be naive to assume that such matters don’t matter when NFL teams, even the Eagles, make such important decisions. Consider the recent history here. You can pinpoint the moment when Hurts won over most of the town: Week 2 of the 2022 season, when he threw for 333 yards, ran for another 57, accounted for three touchdowns in a Monday night rout of the Minnesota Vikings, and remained an MVP candidate the rest of the season. He has been a reliable and impressive face of the franchise ever since.
» READ MORE: Don’t blame the Eagles if draft position is their priority. The NFL is incentivizing a race to the bottom
Before he became a pariah in ‘20, Wentz was the Eagles’ prospective savior, the rising star who brought renewed hope in the aftermath of Chip Kelly’s ugly exit. And it took Donovan McNabb just two years before he and his mother, Wilma, brought the Eagles into everyone’s living room as spokespeople for Campbell’s Chunky Soup.
Lurie might replace Nick Sirianni, and people here will be curious about the next head coach, but they won’t be excited. When the home team is losing, no one is sticking around to watch the new guy call plays. Only a young, promising quarterback brings that kind of juice. It’s not just about the football. It never is. And it won’t be for the Eagles, especially if those lonely Sundays at the Linc keep piling up.
























